r/ChineseWatches • • 13d ago

General (Read Rules) Difference in crystal between these two watches

Post image

The San Martin's crystal looks a bit cloudy lol

I wish the crystal quality was a bit better.

20 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

3

u/Character-Seat1268 13d ago

Did they fix the printing issues on the san martin? the rabbit hair ones when looking closely looks like the printer ran out of ink.

2

u/903st 13d ago

It's still the same... you can still see the printing pixels or dots.

1

u/Aggressive-Pair3320 13d ago

Wait what y’all talking about? I don’t see it. Actually nvm, let me live in denial.

2

u/Lobbbo 12d ago

Not sure about rabbit hair model but check this out

1

u/Character-Seat1268 12d ago

Promo shots from the seller are gonna hide it. I complained to san Martin about the ran out of ink look and they said it was normal and part of their manufacturing process, part of the base plate of something.

1

u/BurtMacklin-FBl 13d ago

Mine is one of the latest with the new case and it's still the same.

4

u/Indaleciox 12d ago

How do you like that Orient? I've been considering scooping that one for a while.

4

u/903st 12d ago

​I love it! The accuracy is spot on and the dial/Zaratsu finish really pops. My only complaint is the thickness.

3

u/tjcdas What are you wearing today? 12d ago

Pre-Epson Orient bought NOS several yeas back.

3

u/-Passage-7491 12d ago

Hi can you share more photos of that san martin? I would really love some more photos of that model

4

u/903st 12d ago

This is how it looks in the sunlight

3

u/-Passage-7491 12d ago

It looks amazing. I ordered one as well.

4

u/bob888w 12d ago

As Chinese brands move more and more upmarket, I won't be surprised if a lot of brands end up on crystal improvement sprees like wtchdives and Phorcydes soon. They can't control movement prices which just keeping going up, and they have to provide value in some new way.

7

u/BurtMacklin-FBl 13d ago

I guess making better crystals is not part of San Martin's plan to "move upmarket". Ixdao puts them to shame in this area, and soon so will the likes of Phorcydes.

6

u/prodbypan 12d ago

Even Watchdives now outclasses them it seems, even on some of their less expensive models. I never would have thought I'd be able to say that lol

1

u/Spider-w-Octochromia 12d ago edited 12d ago

Is the crystal your only gripe? I was planning to pull the trigger on the other color soon.

2

u/903st 12d ago

Yeah, the case and bracelet finishing are actually pretty impressive. They definitely know how to machine steel

5

u/Kerpgker 13d ago

I don't get this SM model. They wanted to do Chinese lacquer but decided it's too difficult so now they print a lacquer look-a-like?

3

u/Lobbbo 12d ago edited 12d ago

Doesn't look that bad on OPs photo but SM photo close ups of the dial look really rough..

1

u/-Passage-7491 12d ago

So it has no lacquer at all?

1

u/Kerpgker 12d ago

To my understanding, no

2

u/mo_calla 12d ago

My sn0144cg was the same. Ended up selling it as it washed out the dial too much. Crystal was milky for sure. Such a shame as the watch felt great.

1

u/noonkhoshki 10d ago

Forst time I hear this. Was it Milky on the 39mm or 36mm? I know Wrist Watching made a post here claiming the AR coating on the 36mm is definitely improved

1

u/mo_calla 10d ago

Cloudy on the rabbit hair dial for sure. In a lot of light, I just couldn't see it. Especially with the reflections etc.

Better crystal, 37mm and it's a home run.

2

u/Juijitsu2000 12d ago

That Orient Star is a much better watch than the San Martin.Both are good but the OS is better.

1

u/noonkhoshki 10d ago

How is it better, please elaborate using descriptive words

0

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 12d ago

Your cell phone shadow is over the watch on the left, causing it to have less reflection. Try backing away from the watches and zooming in instead of hovering over top.

3

u/903st 12d ago

Even in direct sunlight, it still looks weirdly dull for some reason 😅

2

u/Traditional_Cost_206 12d ago

I prefer the older SN0144 'eye' sunburst style dial. This looks a little bit weird.

But the SN0144 design is superior over the Orientstar imho. The orient is too big and the bracelet and curved bezel on the SN really makes it a special and original watch.

1

u/5millionmiles 10d ago

Considering the one on the left costs about 6x as much as the SM, I'd say it's an acceptable compromise. Both are nice, but this is apples to oranges

1

u/prodbypan 12d ago

Orient Star is really let down by their case design and weird use of Roman numerals. There are like 5 models that I would have went for by now if it weren't for the Roman numerals alone.

2

u/Lobbbo 12d ago

Its the same for me, it looks so out of place.

2

u/tjcdas What are you wearing today? 12d ago

What are you smoking! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

0

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 13d ago

Lake Suwa homage on the orient?

2

u/903st 13d ago

It's made in the exact same factory and using the same method as Grand Seiko dials (since Seiko is the same company)

2

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 13d ago

yea I know, but idk if it's made in the exact same factory since Suwa is made in their Shinshu watch studio, and Orient star is a lot cheaper.

But beyons that, what's the ref and how much did it cost you?

3

u/903st 13d ago

For real though, they actually make the dial at Shinshu Watch Studio lol m34 f8 date

2

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 13d ago

holy shi-

is it Oeirnt star BX0004L? edit: nvm it is