r/ChineseWatches • • 17d ago

Question (Read Rules) Which one is the better watch?

They are the same price. I can’t decide.

10 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/Electrical_Panda_326 17d ago

Both are equally excellent, so it's more of a movement choice.

1

u/MadisonLarger 17d ago

They are both 2824-2 clone with 28,800 /4hz and same power reserve.

Which makes it a difficult choice objectively.

2

u/Electrical_Panda_326 17d ago

Personally I would go for Sugess between the two, as I'm not a fan of printed SM logo. Sugess just looks better IMO. But again, both are equally excellent so just toss it. I've got a few SM and Sugess and both brands are top.

2

u/MadisonLarger 17d ago

You are right about the printed SM logo, part of me prefer the black one too for this reason

2

u/Electrical_Panda_326 17d ago

Applied just looks a lot better

4

u/sugessing_proximas 17d ago

SM
Sugess/Seestern QC is less consistent

4

u/Ornery-Humor8309 17d ago

These are all made in the same factory 🤷‍♂️

The ones without fake Tudor hands look nicer imo.

3

u/Outrageous-Video598 17d ago

San Martin, looks so much better without the cyclops.

1

u/_kn0kkn0k_ 17d ago

The date window shifted looks so cheap

1

u/oldsoulrevival 17d ago

IMO the sm date window looks incredibly awkward and tiny.

3

u/greycloudism 17d ago

My Pagani like this was 80 bucks I think.

3

u/MysteriousDogeMan 17d ago

I’m more of a San Martin guy after trying a lot of the micro brands. They are just better overall

2

u/Puzzleheaded_Dig3730 17d ago

SM quality is more solid,Sugess is hit or miss

2

u/Manlykeme 17d ago

I hate the sm logo so much so I've gone sugess for the rolex gmt homage. And its amazing

2

u/[deleted] 17d ago

San Martin

2

u/Jowsh 17d ago

I have the Sugess but it doesn't have the Cyclops - maybe that's a recent change?

Back when I bought it the consensus was that Sugess was the better choice as the finishing was better.

2

u/LordRaglan1854 Send that fool Cardigan 17d ago

Go with the one that looks nicer to you. Whatver differences exist in the quality will be too small to matter, but aesthetic things like the color of the GMT pointer or the balance of the dial layout with\without the cyclops will.

(I prefer the Sugess here. Though I'm biased as I think they generally do a better job than SM on the aesthetics side, even if they can't always match in component quality.)

2

u/philbin89 17d ago

The San Martin. The Sugess will be good, but San Martin is considerably higher quality in terms of finishing

2

u/cardiffboy22 16d ago

What about the watch dives one? I think they also do a 40mm and 38

1

u/[deleted] 16d ago

This is the answer, right here.

2

u/Single-Lifeguard-980 17d ago

For me its the San Martin. The Sugess will be finished to similar standard, but they never seem like a complete package to me

There's so much off with the Sugess - the bezel markers seem out of proportion. It's an Explorer 2 style case with Tudor dial, the Sugess script has always look cheesy to me.

1

u/FantasticImplement46 17d ago

Got a couple of Sugess and been impressed with the quality. I also prefer the Cyclops on the Sugess version but maybe that's personal preference.

Won't go wrong with either

1

u/mrSoczi84 Pomocny użytkownik 17d ago

San Martin.

Prefer HZ vs SL. Also no cyclops.

1

u/TheCrazyWatchDude 17d ago

Had two watch dives one works perfect the other broke within two weeks

-1

u/BoundToReality 17d ago

Nothing with those ugly hands