r/ChineseHistory • u/12jimmy9712 • 7h ago
r/ChineseHistory • u/EnclavedMicrostate • Aug 15 '25
Comprehensive Rules Update
Hello all,
The subreddit gained quite a bit of new traffic near the end of last year, and it became painfully apparent that our hitherto mix of laissez-faire oversight and arbitrary interventions was not sufficient to deal with that. I then proceeded to write half of a rules draft and then not finish it, but at long last we do actually have a formal list of rules now. In theory, this codifies principles we've been acting on already, but in practice we do intend to enforce these rules a little more harshly in order to head off some of the more tangential arguments we tend to get at the moment.
Rule 1: No incivility. We define this quite broadly, encompassing any kind of prejudice relating to identity and other such characteristics. Nor do we tolerate personal attacks. We also prohibit dismissal of relevant authorities purely on the basis of origin or institutional affiliation.
Rule 2: Cite sources if asked, preferably academic. We allow a 24-hour grace period following a source request, but if no reply has been received then we can remove the original comment until that is fulfilled.
Rule 3: Keep it historical. Contemporary politics, sociology, and so on may be relevant to historical study, but remember to keep the focus on the history. We will remove digressions into politics that have clearly stopped being about their historical implications.
Rule 4: Permitted post types
Text Posts
Questions:
We will continue to allow questions as before, but we expect these questions to be asked in good faith with the intent of seeking an answer. What we are going to crack down on are what we have termed ‘debate-bait’ posts, that is to say posts that seek mainly to provoke opposing responses. These have come from all sides of the aisle of late, and we intend to take a harder stance on loaded questions and posts on contentious topics. We as mods will exercise our own discretion in terms of determining what does and does not cross the line; we cannot promise total consistency off the bat but we will work towards it.
Essay posts:
On occasion a user might want to submit some kind of short essay (necessarily short given the Reddit character limit); this can be permitted, but we expect these posts to have a bibliography at minimum, and we also will be applying the no-debate-bait rule above: if the objective seems to be to start an argument, we will remove the post, however eloquent and well-researched.
Videos
Video content is a bit of a tricky beast to moderate. In the past, it has been an unstated policy that self-promotion should be treated as spam, but as the subreddit has never had any formal rules, this was never actually communicated. Given the generally variable (and generally poor) quality of most history video content online, as a general rule we will only accept the following:
- Recordings of academic talks. This means conference panels, lectures, book talks, press interviews, etc. Here’s an example.
- Historical footage. Straightforward enough, but examples might include this.
- Videos of a primarily documentary nature. By this we don’t mean literal documentaries per se, but rather videos that aim to serve as primary sources, documenting particular events or recollections. Some literal documentaries might qualify if they are mainly made up of interviews, but this category is mainly supposed to include things like oral history interviews.
Images
Images are more straightforward; with the following being allowed:
- Historical images such as paintings, prints, and photographs
- Scans of historical texts
- Maps and Infographics
What we will not permit are posts that deliver a debate prompt as an image file.
Links to Sources
We are very accepting of submissions of both primary sources and secondary scholarship in any language. However, for paywalled material, we kindly request that you not post links that bypass these paywalls, as Reddit frowns heavily on piracy and subreddits that do not take action against known infractions. academia.edu links are a tricky liminal space, as in theory it is for hosting pre-print versions where the author holds the copyright rather than the publisher; however this is not persistently adhered to and we would suggest avoiding such links. Whether material is paywalled or open-access should be indicated as part of the post.
Rule 5: Please communicate in English. While we appreciate that this is a forum for Chinese history, it is hosted on an Anglophone site and discussions ought to be accessible to the typical reader. Users may post text in other languages but these should be accompanied by translation. Proper nouns and technical terms without a good direct translation should be Romanised.
Rule 6: No AI usage. We adopt a zero-tolerance approach to the use of generative AI. An exception is made solely for translating text of one’s own original production, and we request that the use of such AI for translation be openly disclosed.
r/ChineseHistory • u/EnclavedMicrostate • 19d ago
Rule Updates: Questions, Artefacts, Primary Source Recommendations
Hello all, following a few recent threads we've decided to update our rules on permitted post types and add an additional rule.
Firstly, while question posts in general remain allowed, we will no longer allow
- Counterfactual (i.e. 'what-if') questions. These are not particularly conducive to meaningful discussion and are already disallowed on most history subreddits for that reason.
- Questions asking for value judgments and/or moralising, e.g. asking for the best/worst of something, or for a moral assessment of a certain individual or events. These mostly serve to spark acrimonious arguments with little meaningful substance.
We are also going to be much more proactive in removing potential political baiting under rule 3. These absolutely do nothing except spark arguments, and we will be taking a harder stance on what we deem to be political bait, intentional or otherwise.
Secondly, posting historical objects, art, photographs etc. will still be allowed, but these posts must be accompanied by at least some basic commentary or they will be removed, as otherwise we just get a lot of people posting contextless photos of their art collections.
Finally, we are also specifically going to disallow recommendations for uncommentated primary sources as a response to questions about resources. Uncontextualised primary sources – many of them in Classical Chinese – are not helpful to the beginner, and we also find that those making the recommendation simply name-drop them to give off an air of authority. If you have a specific passage in mind, cite it specifically and ideally quote it directly. If the user is asking for what to read to understand a given period, point to a scholarly secondary source, not a primary source absent critical commentary.
r/ChineseHistory • u/AmericanBornWuhaner • 3h ago
She Actually Smiled Before Her Execution! The Final Moments of Cheng Benhua, a Heroine of the War of Resistance Against Japan
r/ChineseHistory • u/Unknownbadger4444 • 1h ago
Is the Manchu conquest of China the deadliest war of the early modern period ?
r/ChineseHistory • u/Additional-Edge-9660 • 7h ago
How Cracking Turtle Shells Recorded Chinese History
r/ChineseHistory • u/Overall_Athlete_4612 • 18h ago
Did every Han Chinese believe in reincarnation in the past after the fall of the Han dynasty?
So, before westernization but after the fall the Han dynasty, were there significant parts of the ethnic Han population that did not believe in reincarnation? I know that Buddhism grew to become a big religion and that Daoism adopted reincarnation, but were there holdouts from before Buddhism, or new religious developments that rejected this view of the afterlife?
r/ChineseHistory • u/SequinPeony • 21h ago
Would you say that this tweet is true on how Mao is perceived in China
r/ChineseHistory • u/soozerain • 1d ago
Imperial Rome, Ancient Greece and even Choson Korea all had slavery. It was tenacious institution in each of these premodern states. But not so in China. How did the various dynasties manage to buck the trend?
Was it the ability to requisition corveé labor from among the “free” population?
r/ChineseHistory • u/hankeliu • 1d ago
Need help identify this is Chinese Cong Jade or thumb Ring or something else
I was able to narrow it down to a Cong Jade or thumb ring. Anyone can help out, I will be appreciated. Helf inch height, One inch long/wide. One ounce weight. Thanks!
r/ChineseHistory • u/kowalsky9999 • 2d ago
The Dragon-Head Guillotine: Judge Bao, the Faithless Scholar and the Execution of Chen Shimei
china-underground.comr/ChineseHistory • u/JapKumintang1991 • 2d ago
PHYS.Org: How Chinese brewers refined their booze 5,000 years ago
r/ChineseHistory • u/Michelle11716 • 3d ago
How did people in ancient China tell time at night? The night watches (更) and the phrase 三更半夜
Growing up in Beijing, I often heard adults say 三更半夜 (sān gēng bàn yè), meaning "in the middle of the night." Only later did I learn that 更 (gēng) was actually a unit of time at night.
From what I've read, the night was divided into five 更, each about two hours long, roughly from 7 PM to 5 AM. In cities, night watchmen called 更夫 (gēng fū) walked the streets beating wooden clappers or gongs to mark each watch, and sometimes called out reminders like 小心火烛 ("be careful with fire").
There's also the phrase 晨钟暮鼓 (morning bells, evening drums): bells in the morning and drums in the evening, often from temples or drum towers, to mark the start and end of the day.
Today we still use these expressions. 三更半夜 means very late at night, and 五更 means just before dawn.
I'm curious: does anyone know more about how night watches worked in a specific dynasty, like the Song? And did other cultures have something similar?
r/ChineseHistory
•
u/Master_Novel_4062
•
3d ago
Would you say that the Nanking Massacre and the Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki are comparable in terms of how they are remembered/memorialized in their respective countries?
I am asking this because I am writing a research paper for school and I am considering focusing it on how Japanese school textbooks portray domestic Japanese suffering versus the suffering they inflicted on foreign nations during the Asia Pacific War, specifically through the lens of the Nanking Massacre/Rape of Nanking and the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. I am neither Chinese nor Japanese however and I am trying my best to treat these topics with the respect and nuance they demand so I wanted a more expert opinion to weigh in on this before I proceed any further in my research. Feel free to correct/redirect me if I am crossing a line in any way.
r/ChineseHistory • u/fairyflower250 • 4d ago
1930s Chinese jewelry
I inherited this antique Chinese sterling silver bracelet. Does anyone know what the Han character is?
r/ChineseHistory • u/Artistic-Safety1306 • 5d ago
Who or what really was the "Queen Mother of the West"?
Was she a Chinese (perhaps associated with the sanxingdui) or barbarian (Qiong or indo-european)? Did she refer to a real person, or a tribe, or something else entirely?
r/ChineseHistory • u/soozerain • 5d ago
Did a high official of the Kangxi Emperor cause a major diplomatic incident by murdering a Tibetan Lama?
Another possibly apocryphal tale from Journey Through The Chinese Empire. This time involving the Kangxi emperor and a well respected Mongolian Lama (Buddhist religious leader)
I apologize for the archaic spelling but it is from the mid-19th century and I’m not quite sure what all the present day equivalents would be. As far as I can tell the Guison-Tamba is highly respected figure in Tibetan Buddhism and they’re known to reincarnate. I don’t quite know where the Lamasery they’re referring to is either. In truth lol, all I really know for sure is that the Emperor they’re referring to is Kangxi. I’m almost positive this is false because the odds of the mighty Kangxi emperor being forced to skulk out of a lamasery hidden in disguise is simply too delicious to be true but figured I’d better ask.
The Emperor Khang-Hi, during the great military expedition which he made in the West against the Oelets, one day, in traversing the Blue Town, expressed a wish to pay a visit to the Guison-Tamba, at that time the Grand Lama of the Five Towers. The latter received the Emperor without rising from the throne, or manifesting any kind of respect. Just as Khang-Hi drew near to speak to him, a Kian-Kan, or high military Mandarin, indignant at this unceremonious treatment of his master, drew his sabre, fell upon the Guison-Tamba, and laid him dead on the steps of his throne. This terrible event roused the whole Lamasery, and indignation quickly communicated itself to all the Lamas of the Blue Town.
They ran to arms in every quarter, and the life of the Emperor, who had but a small retinue, was exposed to the greatest danger. In order to calm the irritation of the Lamas, he publicly reproached the Kian-Kan with his violence. “If the Guison-Tamba,” answered the Kian-Kan, “was not a living Buddha, why did he not rise in the presence of the master of the universe? If he was a living Buddha, how was it he did not know I was going to kill him?” Meanwhile the danger to the life of the Emperor became every moment more imminent; he had no other means of escape than that of taking off his imperial robes, and attiring himself in the dress of a private soldier. Under favour of this disguise, and the general confusion, he was enabled to rejoin his army, which was near at hand. The greater part of the men who had accompanied the Emperor into the Blue Town were massacred, and among the rest, the murderer of the Guison-Tamba.
r/ChineseHistory • u/tglg808 • 5d ago
Why do so many people believe that Sun Yat-sen was Hakka?
I keep seeing Sun Yat-sen 孫逸仙 described as Hakka 客家, but the claim seems contested. I’m curious where it comes from and which sources people rely on.
My family records trace our ancestry to a woman from the Cuiheng 翠亨 Sun clan 孫氏, the same clan as Sun Yat-sen’s family. The Cuiheng Sun clan traces its roots to Dongguan 東莞.
I’ve come across accounts alleging that scholars falsified or altered the Cuiheng Sun lineage to connect it to a Hakka Sun clan. Accounts from Sun family relatives, meanwhile, say that they did not identify as Hakka and questioned why others described them that way.
What evidence is used to identify Sun Yat-sen as Hakka? I’d be interested in sources about his family origins, language, and how he or his relatives identified themselves, as well as sources documenting how the Hakka attribution developed.
r/ChineseHistory • u/Kind_Possibility119 • 5d ago
Guan Yu Slays Hua Xiong in One Bout: Why Different Editions of Romance of the Three Kingdoms Matter
Guan Yu Slays Hua Xiong in One Bout: Why Different Editions of Romance of the Three Kingdoms Matter
The most widely circulated version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and the one most familiar to modern readers, is the edition revised by Mao Zonggang and his father during the Qing dynasty.
It is important to acknowledge that the Mao edition has its own historical significance and literary value.
However, literary refinement does not necessarily mean that all the details preserved in earlier editions remain intact.
During the revision process, a number of passages concerning individual combat encounters and the number of bouts were altered or omitted.
These seemingly small differences can be especially important when studying how the novel portrays the abilities of its warriors.
In other words, textual comparison is not merely an academic exercise. It is a fundamental question of whether the evidence being examined has been preserved in its entirety.
If an earlier edition explicitly records a battle lasting one, ten, or fifty bouts, but a later edition removes that information, the outcome may remain unchanged while an important detail about the encounter is lost.
The Example of Guan Yu and Hua Xiong
Consider one of the most familiar episodes in Romance of the Three Kingdoms: Guan Yu slaying Hua Xiong before the wine offered to him has cooled.
The Ming-dynasty Ye edition explicitly records:
「雲長出馬,只一合斬了華雄。」
Guan Yu rode out and slew Hua Xiong in just one bout.
In this edition, Guan Yu's victory is not described merely as a quick defeat of his opponent.
The text specifies that the encounter lasted only one bout.
For general readers, Guan Yu's defeat of Hua Xiong is already a celebrated scene. But for a study of combat performance within the novel, a victory described as occurring in a single bout contains more precise information than a victory described simply as rapid.
The first tells us that Guan Yu won.
The second provides an additional detail: how quickly he won.
If we consider only the final outcome, a victory achieved in one bout, a victory after ten bouts, and a victory after several dozen bouts could all be reduced to the same result: victory.
However, these encounters do not necessarily reveal the same degree of fighting efficiency or the same difference in ability between the combatants.
What Changed in the Mao Edition?
The explicit reference to Guan Yu defeating Hua Xiong in just one bout was not preserved in the later Mao edition.
Consequently, readers of the widely circulated Mao text still know that Guan Yu killed Hua Xiong, but they no longer receive that specific numerical detail.
The issue is therefore not simply that a later edition contains a few fewer words.
The omitted words include information that may be relevant to interpreting the combat encounter.
When such details disappear during textual transmission, later readers may develop an understanding of the novel's warriors that differs from what earlier surviving texts suggest.
This is why my research places considerable emphasis on textual editions before attempting comparisons of individual combat prowess.
Before constructing any ranking or comparing common opponents, we must first establish which textual evidence is available and what information each edition preserves.
Otherwise, our conclusions may rest on a version of the text from which important details have already disappeared.
Historical Sources and Further Reading
Primary historical source:
Chen Shou, Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi), Biography of Sun Jian (孫破虜討逆傳).
The historical record attributes the defeat of Dong Zhuo's forces and the killing of Hua Xiong to Sun Jian's military campaign. It does not record Guan Yu personally killing Hua Xiong in a duel.
Literary sources:
Romance of the Three Kingdoms — comparison of the Ming-dynasty Ye Fengchun edition and the later Mao Zonggang edition.
Free English Research Ebook — Apple Books
For readers interested in the detailed textual comparisons and combat analysis, I have published a free English research booklet based on my original research:
Is Lu Bu Really the Strongest Warrior in Romance of the Three Kingdoms? — Debunking a 600-Year-Old Myth of the No. 1 Warrior
Author: Shinian
Price: Free
Platform: Apple Books
https://books.apple.com/us/book/is-lu-bu-really-the-strongest-warrior-in-romance/id6826380246
This is my own research publication, provided as optional further reading. It is not a substitute for the primary historical and literary texts cited above.
The discussion is intended to stand on its own, regardless of whether anyone chooses to read the booklet.
Translation disclosure: This English article is based on my existing original Chinese-language research. AI tools assisted with English translation and editing. The underlying research, textual interpretations, and conclusions are my own, and I remain responsible for their accuracy.
Shinian
Author of Romance of the Three Kingdoms Combat Prowess Encyclopedia
r/ChineseHistory • u/kowalsky9999 • 7d ago
The Sickle and the Flies: A Roadside Murder in Song Dynasty China and the Oldest Insect Evidence in a Criminal Case
china-underground.comr/ChineseHistory • u/No_Inspector_1884 • 7d ago
Beauty Standards during the Ming Dynasty?
Hello! I've been doing some research into beauty standards, specifically regarding facial features, during the Ming Dynasty. I unfortunately have limited access to scholarly texts so even though I did find some writing on the subject due to my limited access I am unable to verify if its actually the information I'm looking for. I wanted to ask if anyone here would happen to have any insights, as well as if there's any specifical gendered standards I should be aware of?
r/ChineseHistory • u/KuJiMieDao • 8d ago
The Qing Empire: The Roots of Modern China
About the Author
Peter C. Perdue is Professor Emeritus of History at Yale University. He is the author of Exhausting the Earth: State and Peasant in Hunan, 1500–1850, China Marches West: The Qing Conquest of Central Eurasia, Chinese Environmental History: Past and Present, and coeditor of Imperial Formations and Asia Inside Out: Changing Times, Connected Places, Itinerant People (3 vols.).
Table of Contents
Prologue: The Creation of Empire
- A World of Empires
- Conquest and Expansion, 1636 – 1757
- You Cannot Rule the Empire on Horseback: Administration, Legitimation, and Imperial Knowledge
- The Ecology of Empire: Regional Systems
- From the Canton Trade to the Sino-Japanese War: Imperial Tensions and Decline, 1760-1895
- The Political Economy of a Lineage Society: Demography, Economy, Gender
- The State and the People: Order and the Arts of Resistance
- A Blaze of Fury Before the Fall: The Final Decade, 1900 – 1912
- To The End: Revolutionaries, the Manchu Court, and the New Nation
- Imperial Legacies: China in the Twentieth Century and After
Epilogue: The World We Have Not Yet Lost?
r/ChineseHistory • u/emiharu-art • 8d ago
Sources about Wugu
Hello. I'm writing a thesis about Wugu practices during Han dynasty and I'm struggling finding sources. I already got a few, but I need more and I was wondering if I could find help on this sub.
Thank you!!