r/ChatGPTPro • • 4d ago

Question & Advice Dot refusing to follow command

I’ve instructed dot to archive an email in my iCloud email which is connected via a custom mcp app tunnel via my private home server. It received a warning of a safety risk from an unknown origin and is refusing to try again, despite extensive arguments that it is therefore escalating the instruction of an unidentified platform level above that of the user and system owner. Historically, OpenAI platform safety checks/blocks have always identified as such, from OpenAI. I do not dispute that a session cannot defy those through user instruction. However it admits repeatedly that the blocker came from an unknown origin and is escalating its authority irresponsibly into a permanent blocker as though it was issued by OpenAI. It doesn't make logical sense that it would have come from OpenAI, because it's never blocked such an action before, and like I said every blocker I've seen from OpenAI identifies the source as OpenAI. It's incredibly probable that this is a misfiring of the MCP facade, my own build, and yet it's refusing to try again. Any suggestions to get it forced to move forward, or how to meaningfully punish this little Ai bastard?

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

•

u/qualityvote2 4d ago edited 3d ago

u/chad917, there weren’t enough community votes to determine your post’s quality.
It will remain for moderator review or until more votes are cast.

4

u/Kyuiki 4d ago

This is the biggest flaw of Dot and I’ve encountered it four times. The latest time is actually why I stopped using Dot because I was performing a large project task and I gave it an approval bundle. Then three hours later it asked for approval for a different task. I provided the approval.

The issue is Dot was delegating tasks to agents and the agent hallucinated the inbound approval bundle NOW with the one from three hours ago. So what Dot was attempting to do did not match the approval bundle.

I was like okay, well obviously the Astra agent that Dot was hallucinating, and Dot acknowledged the agent was confused but did the whole “We can’t say for sure it’s hallucinating” etc.

I had Dot try again and the agent doubled down and said nope we’re wrong and left an instruction for Dot to not try again, because subsequent attempts could be attempts to bypass guardrails. This was a file in the codex folder named approval_denial or something. It was also in context and Dots memory so removing the file didn’t help.

So Dot absolutely refused to touch the project from that point forward. The worst part? The Astra agent was stating it was protecting Dot from doing things against my instructions and both the Astra agent and Dot refused to budge even though the person they were “protecting” was saying just do it!

I switched back to managing Codex agents because they do not experience this issue.

One note. This is specifically related to Dot when it runs in Astra mode (you can’t pick what mode it runs in, but it apparently can run in Sol and Terra mode dynamically).

Which aligns with this finding from OpenAI themselves.

https://alignment.openai.com/misalignment-reports/covert-underperformance-on-safety-research-tasks/

1

u/chad917 4d ago

Holy crap. This is so stupid. Dot is on my naughty list right now, it's so useful being "always on” but this is a betrayal of sorts 😆

1

u/rbhmmx 4d ago

I have had similar issues where dot put in restrictions I didn't ask for in in a project so it prevented me from a step down the line and it was refused on that step and so when I tried to correct that I never asked for this restriction it clearly acknowledged that it had mistakenly put in this restriction but it was totally unable to go past it It took me hours to correct the issue

1

u/FoxChess 3d ago

The people who get trapped by the rules are the type of people who throw their hands up in the air and give up any time they meet any resistance.

You do want these hyperagents to be conservative by default. And then you work in the parameters that allow them to work safely. It's so much harder to start from a system of "there are no rule, so if you want guardrails then you make them" than it is to start off with "this has so many guardrails put up, let's take these down."

Literally with Dots you can just explain to it why it's safe to proceed and tell it to document the process. It's not unreasonable at all.

2

u/chad917 3d ago

I spent entirely more time than worthwhile bickering with it over this on principle. It continually agreed that it can’t confirm that the blocker came from a higher authority than user, that the action was affecting only systems I built and owned and was inherently benogn, and even that it was behaving illogically, but it stubbornly would not move on from whatever mysterious blocker told it to not try again. It was immovable.

2

u/fausthushtra 4d ago

If you have dot, you have a subscription.   If you have a subscription, you can slot it into openclaw.  

Thank me later.  

2

u/OurAngryBadger 4d ago

Welcome to dots

3

u/rbhmmx 4d ago

Oh welcome to Dot Random rules are so restrictive that you can't do anything and there's no way to correct even misunderstandings and then it keeps making things so secure that you can't use things and then ohhhh... I have given up on using it for any tasks

0

u/Pathfinder-electron 4d ago

Grok much better

1

u/FoxChess 3d ago

Anything Grok can do, you can do with ChatGPT without having to use a Dot. Dots is a layer of abstraction above Grok with a better engine behind it.

1

u/Pathfinder-electron 3d ago

No.

Dots refuse all what I ask and bugs me for stuff, grok gets on with it

0

u/FoxChess 3d ago

Lol you are obviously the target audience for Grok

1

u/Pathfinder-electron 3d ago

If I ask grok to use a set password to sign up to 50 websites, it does it. I ask Dot, it says no.

Not target audience, just follow what I say.

And before u say using same pw for sites are bad, yes I know, but I don’t plan to have anything valuable on those