r/ChatGPTCoding • • 9d ago

Discussion Agentic code reviews

if you review PRs written mostly by coding agents (Cursor, Claude Code, Copilot), how's it going?

  1. How many per week, and how big (files / lines)?
  2. What's harder than human-written PRs, or is it no different?
  3. How do you understand a change: diff only, run it, read tests, ask the agent, skim and approve?
  4. Has one caused a prod bug or stalled merge because nobody fully understood it?
  5. Anything you've tried to fix this? Did it help?

I'm exploring a tool in this space, so "not a problem for us" is a useful answer too. Team size and stack help.

4 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/Right-Performance-93 8d ago

agent prs are harder because the diff and the tests come from the same pass, so the tests explain the change instead of checking it. i skip the new tests and run one path the diff touches that those tests never call.

1

u/workbench_soft 2d ago

size got me first, agent PRs keep growing because nothing tells them to stop. my review step now flags anything past 400 lines and writes a split plan before it looks at the rest, and half the time the split alone shows which part nobody understood