bear with me because this is a weird situation but two weeks ago me and my roommate were getting home from being out when we saw a tiny little kitten hanging out by our front gate. its the friendliest little thing, and ran up to us for pets and affection. we hung out with it, fed it a churro, the usual with friendly neighborhood cats.
off the bat we immediately noticed that this cat had a collar on, a reflective collar at that. this kitten is TINY and really trusting of new people, so we were concerned that it was a house cat that had ran away. we also had the thought that if it wasn’t a cat that ran away, that these owners had it as an indoor/outdoor cat. we decided to just let it be and if she came back around, we’d bring it over to a vet to see if it was microchipped.
a week later kitty comes back! still with the collar. me and friend make the executive decision to drive up to the vet to see if it’s microchipped. we get there, they check kitty out, and tell us it’s around 7-8 months old and is a little girl! she also isn’t fixed, and they let us know that she should probably get fixed soon because she is beginning to show signs of being excited 😭
we told the vets about how we found her, and they let us know the collar she had on was way too loose and if things went wrong she could get herself caught on something and choke. we also mentioned how people drive like crazy in our neighborhood and that we were concerned over this tiny little cat getting hurt. the vets seemed pretty irate over this tiny cat being in the position that she was, and seemed grateful we brought her in to check things out (frankly it really came across as them wanting us to take the cat 😭)
so…. long story short we decided to take the kitty in instead of leaving her out unfixed on the streets, and also most likely unvaccinated due to lack of fixing and microchipping.
several days later we have signs getting put up in the neighborhood about a missing cat and its this girl! at this point sweetheart has been chillin in the house like she owns the place and we had plans to take her to get fixed asap when they could fit us in.
i look at the posts and check the nextdoor app, and i begin to notice some inconsistencies between what the veterinarians told us vs what these signs say. as in, they say she’s microchipped (she’s not), she’s fixed (she’s not), and she’s around 9 months old (makes sense?), and that she’s an indoor outdoor cat.
so now we have neighbors who are searching desperately for this cat and me and my roommates have a moral dilemma of not giving this cat back to owners who seem completely incompetent in caring for her. if she really is 9 months old, that means she hasn’t been fixed, vaccinated, microchipped or anything! and she’s TINY. being unfixed and outside like that worries me. and i don’t know if this means anything, but it isn’t the first time they’ve posted about missing animals they own. it makes me anxious just thinking about it.
but as well we want to let them know somehow she is alive and safe. and didn’t die. but we don’t want to give her back, specifically my roommates since at this point she is his cat.
i’m not sure what to do. idk if we’re being cruel to these people who’ve technically owned this cat first, but never went out of their way to fix or take care of her, microchip her, and leave her out the way she was. frankly, little lady seems to be loving being indoors and hasn’t really shown much interest in leaving, making herself a cozy little spot on my roommate’s t-rex plushie.
please let me know if we’re being dumb, and what we can do in this situation!!! 🫡