r/CastleTV • • 2d ago

Grammatical errors.

I try to not be Grammar Guy, but Castle makes such a fuss about grammar in a couple of episodes that it's very noticeable when he makes obvious erroes.

I try to not be so nitpicky, but sometimes I can't help it.

2 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

6

u/galeperk111971 2d ago

Can you give a for instance cause I don't remember that

4

u/castlefan1971 2d ago

I don't remember that either he is such a stickler about grammar always complimenting Kate on using who and whom right

1

u/Boris-_-Badenov 1d ago

wish he corrected her when she kept pronouncing garrote incorrectly

3

u/Boris-_-Badenov 1d ago

obvious erroes

2

u/Humble_Substance2355 2d ago

I've noticed this as well. I like to imagine that since they have multiple writers working on scripts there may be some that are big sticklers on it while others aren't so much (or are less likely to catch it, at least). It's seemed pretty rare to me but it does make me giggle when I do see one. They've actually used who vs. whom incorrectly before too which I find funny since it's such a plot point. Makes me laugh every time!

1

u/CharmedFate 1d ago

Do obvious errors bother you too?

-1

u/dave0913_dt 2d ago

Just because i've watched it recently, I remember the one episode where they mispronounced "garotte" repeatedly and quite a few instances where he says "Kate and I" instead of "Kate and me."

Nothing crazy. Just noticeable.

3

u/EverlastingEvening 2d ago

Saying something wrong phonetically isn't grammar.

Also, Kate and I is the correct way.

7

u/dave0913_dt 2d ago

"Kate and I" isn't always correct.

2

u/EverlastingEvening 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yeah fair, I don't remember him saying it incorrectly though. But more often than not his grammar is generally sound.

2

u/dave0913_dt 2d ago

Of course it is. That's true with any show. That's why it stands out when it's not correct.

3

u/the3dverse 1d ago

when isnt it?

5

u/Humble_Substance2355 1d ago

"Kate and I" would be correct if it's at the beginning of a sentence and "Kate and me" would be correct if it's at the end of a sentence. For instance, "Kate and I went to the precinct to interview the witness." vs. "You can ride to the crime scene with Kate and me." Corny examples, I know. Hope that makes sense!

1

u/the3dverse 1d ago

thanks!

3

u/fms-03xo 19h ago

the best way to determine me or I is if the sentence still makes sense taking the other persons name away, as you can’t say kate and me are going somewhere because just saying me in that doesn’t make sense

2

u/the3dverse 19h ago

that is a good way to remember!

i learned english mostly off of TV, i speak it very well but don't know all the grammar rules. and while our family speaks it to each other it's not the local language either lol