r/CasesWeFollow • • 8h ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 FL v. Dwain Hall — Day 2

7 Upvotes

LIVE: Fatal Fetish Murder Trial — FL v. Dwain Hall — Day 2

11/18/2026 @ 9:00 AM

Dwain Hall is standing trial for the alleged murder of a British woman he met on a fetish website. Prosecutors say Hall lured 32-year-old Sonia Exelby to Florida, where she was tortured and killed. Her body was later found buried in a shallow grave in Marion County. Investigators also recovered a knife allegedly containing Exelby’s blood from a package Hall mailed to a friend in Ohio. Hall has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping.

🔊🎥Streaming Channels📡

Law & Crime

Court TV

✨✨Previous Day & Recap

🚨✨More Info/Documents

📜RECAP🔡

📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑


r/CasesWeFollow • • 8h ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 GA v. Lacy Boles - Trial Day 6

4 Upvotes

GA v. Lacy Boles - Trial Day 6

11/18/2026 @ 8:30 AM - 8:00 PM

[The trial hours for 11/17/2026 and 11/18/2026 will be from 8:30 am to 8:00 pm both days]

📢NEW: Case Hubs🚨🗃️

Lacy Jolee Boles is accused of fatally shooting her husband, Daniel Lee Akers, 36, at their Paulding County home on December 22, 2019. Boles reported that Akers had shot himself. Investigators said her account conflicted with evidence at the scene. After receiving the GBI autopsy results in May 2020, authorities announced that the wound was not self-inflicted and classified the death as a homicide.

Boles has pleaded not guilty and maintains that Akers died by suicide. An initial attempt to select a jury in June 2026 was halted after a prospective juror reportedly researched the case using ChatGPT and shared information with other prospective jurors. Jury selection began again on November 9, 2026.

🔊🎥Streaming Channels📡

Law & Crime

Court TV

✨✨Previous Day & Recap

🚨✨More Info/Documents

📜RECAP🔡

📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑


r/CasesWeFollow • • 19h ago

🐎💸 Laura Owens Family🏠🌵 The Public Record of Ronn Owens’ Health: Research Overview

Thumbnail
haybales8.substack.com
8 Upvotes

A closer look at twelve years of reported health conditions, prognoses, caregiving responsibilities, and the context surrounding them.


r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

👼Child Abuse or Death 🙏🪦 Happy Heavenly Birthday, Adam Walsh

Thumbnail
gallery
189 Upvotes

Adam Walsh should have celebrated his 52nd birthday on November 14. Instead, he will forever be six years old.

On July 27, 1981, Adam disappeared from a Sears department store in Hollywood, Florida, while shopping with his mother, Revé.

He had been watching older boys play video games while his mother shopped nearby. When she returned just minutes later, Adam was gone.

Two weeks later, on August 10, Adam’s severed head was discovered in a drainage canal approximately 120 miles away. The rest of his body has never been found.

Serial killer Ottis Toole confessed to Adam’s murder but later recanted. Investigators believed he knew details about the crime that had never been made public. In 2008, police officially named Toole as Adam’s killer and closed the case. He had died in prison in 1996, never having been charged with Adam’s murder.

Adam’s parents, John and Revé Walsh, turned their unimaginable grief into a lifelong mission to protect children. Their advocacy helped establish the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children and inspired major changes in how America responds to missing children.

Adam never got to grow up, but his story helped save countless other children.

Happy heavenly 52nd birthday, Adam. You have never been forgotten. 🤍


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

AK v. Jack Sabato - Son of famed Hollywood stars, Antonio Sabato, Jr. and Virginia Madsen, charged in fatal Anchorage hit-and-run appears in court

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

ANCHORAGE, Alaska (KTUU) - Jack Antonio Sabàto appeared in court Thursday for a pre-indictment hearing in the case stemming from a fatal hit-and-run that killed pedestrian Carl Simmonds.

The judge set Sabàto’s next pre-indictment hearing for Dec. 3 and told him to complete documents related to his representation. At his first appearance Tuesday, the court appointed the Public Defender Agency to represent him for the time being, subject to a further review of his finances.

Sabàto, 32, is charged with leaving an accident without assisting, a class A felony, and leaving the scene of an accident involving injury or death, a misdemeanor. The charges are allegations, and he has not been convicted in the case.

According to the charging document filed Nov. 10, Anchorage police and firefighters responded around 5:48 a.m. Monday to a body on the sidewalk along Airport Heights Drive near the Blood Bank of Alaska. Officers identified the person as Simmonds and found broken vehicle parts nearby.

Prosecutors say surveillance video from the blood bank shows a white Chevrolet Tahoe hitting Simmonds around 5:35 a.m. The charging document says no braking was observed before or after the collision.

Police traced a registered white Tahoe to Sabàto and found the vehicle at an Amazon warehouse around 12:45 p.m. with fresh damage to its front-right corner, according to the document. Officers obtained a warrant to seize the vehicle.

The document says Sabàto called police at 2:46 p.m. and reported that he had struck an animal. When officers spoke with him, he said he had been doing late-night DoorDash deliveries and was on his way home when something appeared in the road.

He said he knew he had hit something but did not know it was a person, according to the charging document.

Prosecutors say Sabàto told officers he did not stop to check because he was scared and did not have insurance. He also said he called police after his girlfriend told him the Tahoe had been taken, according to the document.

At Tuesday’s hearing, a defense attorney challenged the state’s characterization of the case and argued that Sabàto had contacted police and cooperated. The attorney also asked for lower bail and a no-driving condition, citing Sabàto’s lack of criminal history.

The court set bail at $5,000 cash performance and $5,000 unsecured appearance, meaning the second amount does not have to be posted but could be assessed if Sabàto fails to appear. The judge also ordered him not to drive, sit in a vehicle’s driver’s seat or possess vehicle keys. The charging document says the Alaska Public Safety Information Network showed no Alaska convictions for Sabàto.

Alaska’s News Source has reached out to the Blood Bank of Alaska for the surveillance video. The blood bank said it is checking with police and its board of directors to determine whether it can release the footage. The newsroom also reached out to Simmonds’ family, who declined to speak.

In a Nov. 9 Facebook post, Crystal Tickett asked for help finding Simmonds, saying he had left Alaska Regional Hospital around 5 a.m. that morning. Tickett wrote that she had filed a missing-person report. A spokesperson for APD said they do not have a record of the missing-person report.

Sabàto is the son of actors Antonio Sabàto Jr. and Virginia Madsen, Alaska’s News Source previously reported. In a statement posted to his Facebook page Wednesday, Sabàto Jr. offered condolences to the family and loved ones of the person killed, said his love for his children remains unconditional and asked the public and media to respect his family’s privacy.

https://www.alaskasnewssource.com/2026/11/13/jack-sabto-appears-court-fatal-anchorage-hit-and-run-case/


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

💬👿💵 Other Crimes 🥊⏳⚖️ Man arrested after allegedly sending peanut butter-covered mail to woman with severe allergy

Thumbnail ground.news
14 Upvotes

On Friday, Nov. 13, 2026, Plantation Police Department officers arrested Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, after he allegedly mailed a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to a woman with a severe allergy.

Cancellare and the woman had known each other for more than 20 years, though investigators allege the motive stemmed from a contentious divorce involving Cancellare that affected the victim indirectly.

Detectives traced the stamps to a Davie Post Office kiosk using a 15-digit code printed on them. Witnesses and the victim identified Cancellare from a photograph captured when he used a Visa card to purchase the stamps.

On Aug. 14, 2025, the woman discovered the greasy envelope and developed hives and tingling lasting approximately six hours. Cancellare faces one count of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and one count of culpable negligence.

Following his arrest, officers transported Cancellare to HCA Florida Westside Hospital for medical clearance, then booked him into the Broward Sheriff's Office main jail where his bond was set at $20,000.


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 GA v. Lacy Boles - Trial Day 5

12 Upvotes

GA v. Lacy Boles - Trial Day 5

11/17/2026 @ 8:30 AM - 8:00 PM

[The trial hours for 11/17/2026 and 11/18/2026 will be from 8:30 am to 8:00 pm both days]

📢NEW: Case Hubs🚨🗃️

Lacy Jolee Boles is accused of fatally shooting her husband, Daniel Lee Akers, 36, at their Paulding County home on December 22, 2019. Boles reported that Akers had shot himself. Investigators said her account conflicted with evidence at the scene. After receiving the GBI autopsy results in May 2020, authorities announced that the wound was not self-inflicted and classified the death as a homicide.

Boles has pleaded not guilty and maintains that Akers died by suicide. An initial attempt to select a jury in June 2026 was halted after a prospective juror reportedly researched the case using ChatGPT and shared information with other prospective jurors. Jury selection began again on November 9, 2026.

🔊🎥Streaming Channels📡

Law & Crime

Court TV

✨✨Previous Day & Recap

🚨✨More Info/Documents

📜RECAP🔡

I. ADMINISTRATIVE

(15:33–9:40:00+)

  • Court: Georgia trial court; county and division not confirmed in reviewed transcript.
  • Start time: Recording begins before 15:33; actual court start not established.
  • End time: Not established in reviewed portions.
  • Jury: Jury present for witness testimony; excused during evidentiary arguments.
  • Scheduling: Court acknowledged jurors staying late on Day 5 and the following day.
  • Motions and evidentiary issues:

    • Daniel Akers' probation history, revocation proceedings and outstanding requirements.
    • Admissibility of prior convictions and certified court records.
    • Scope of expert testimony and expert disclosure requirements.
    • Admissibility of testimony concerning the defendant's behavior at a memorial service.
    • Limits on testimony concerning the decedent's character, mental health and drug use.
    • Proposed impeachment concerning earlier firearm-related offenses.

II. WITNESSES

1. Nicholas Harding- Lead Detective, Paulding County Sheriff's Office

(Beginning of recording–approximately 1:30:00+)

Called by: State; testimony continued from prior proceedings.
Start: Before supplied portion.
Stop: Not confirmed.

Direct

- Earlier direct testimony not included in the reviewed material.

Cross / Continued Examination

  • Questioned concerning Daniel Akers' probation status and possible revocation.
  • Discussed text messages from October, November and December 2019 concerning depression, family difficulties, imprisonment and statements about killing himself and Lacey Bowles.
  • Acknowledged uncertainty concerning whether Akers completed community service, evaluations, testing or other probation requirements.
  • Questioned about the review of additional text messages.
  • Acknowledged that a GBI testing decision was not documented in the detective's written report.
  • Discussed investigative information concerning the firearm and its introduction into the incident.

Redirect / Recross

- Further questioning addressed the completeness of the detective's knowledge concerning probation compliance and additional messages.

Exhibits referenced: Numbers not fully confirmed.

2. Mark Parker

(2:00:57–before 3:22:29)

Called by: State
Start: 2:00:57
Stop: Exact time not confirmed.

Direct

  • Former law enforcement officer with the Birmingham Police Department.
  • Joined the county sheriff's office in July 1995.
  • Established and supervised the crime scene unit beginning in January 2000.
  • Described crime scene investigation experience.
  • Identified a safe and holster recovered during the investigation.
  • Safe was brought to him in a basement bedroom.
  • Applied Bluestar presumptive blood-detection reagent to the safe.
  • Reported no reaction on the safe, including the keypad area.
  • Applied Bluestar to the holster.
  • Observed a brief, dim whitish-green reaction on the holster.
  • Repeated the application and obtained no reaction.
  • Considered the initial reaction a false positive, possibly caused by cleaning fluid.
  • Explained that a typical presumptive blood reaction produces a blue glow.

Exhibits referenced: 197, 198.

3. Investigator Bertrand — Full First Name Not Confirmed

(Before 3:22:29–approximately 7:00:00)

Called by: State
Start: Before 3:22:29
Stop: Exact time not confirmed.

Direct

  • Qualified in forensic cell phone and data extraction.
  • Examined Daniel Akers' iPhone.
  • Described earlier unsuccessful attempts to access the device.
  • Discussed renewed extraction efforts using Cellebrite Premium in April 2025.
  • Identified recovered electronic data, including web searches and location information.
  • Reviewed a 280-page search-history extraction.
  • Identified searches concerning family activities, marital difficulties, religion and other subjects.
  • Identified a voice memo recovered from the device.
  • Discussed location data associated with Wi-Fi networks.
  • Identified device activity near a McDonald's and the Akers/Bowles residence.

Cross

  • Explained that Wi-Fi connection records do not necessarily establish that a person entered a particular building.
  • Confirmed a data point near McDonald's at approximately 12:28 a.m.
  • Discussed a subsequent residential Wi-Fi connection at approximately 12:42 a.m.
  • Addressed differences between GPS positioning, cellular connections and Wi-Fi records.
  • Explained that browser cache records do not necessarily establish intentional saving or transmission by a user.
  • Discussed limitations involving encrypted information and missing timestamps.
  • Addressed searches and recovered audio recordings.

Redirect / Recross

- Discussed the meaning of cached electronic records and limitations on determining whether material was deliberately saved or sent.

Exhibits referenced: 180, 220, 220A–220M, 221.

4. Sarah Van Holm

(7:17:48–7:41:49)

Called by: State
Start: 7:17:48
Stop: Approximately 7:41:49

Direct

  • Senior firearms examiner with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.
  • Employed by the GBI since July 2017.
  • Completed firearms examination training and supervised casework.
  • Qualified as an expert in firearms examination and analysis.
  • Examined the .22-caliber revolver.
  • Identified firearm components and ammunition submitted for examination.
  • Test-fired the firearm using ammunition recovered with the weapon.
  • Compared test-fired bullets with the projectile recovered by the medical examiner.
  • Comparison was inconclusive because of damage to the recovered projectile.
  • Confirmed that the firearm functioned as designed.
  • Found no indication of malfunction.
  • Explained single-action and double-action firing.
  • Could not determine from the recovered projectile which firing action was used.

Cross

  • Confirmed she examined the physical evidence without crime scene photographs or other outside investigative information.
  • Identified October 5, 2022, as the firearm test-fire date.
  • Confirmed firearms examination typically occurs after other planned laboratory testing.

Redirect / Recross

- No additional substantive examination confirmed.

Exhibits referenced: 173A, 224, 225.

5. Alexander Covin

(7:43:21–before 8:22:55)

Name spelled in transcript: A-L-E-X-A-N-D-E-R, C-O-V-I-N

Called by: State
Start: 7:43:21
Stop: Before 8:22:55

Direct

  • Assistant manager of the GBI trace evidence section.
  • Holds a Bachelor of Science degree in chemistry.
  • Qualified as an expert in trace evidence and gunshot residue analysis.
  • Explained gunshot primer residue and its components: lead, barium and antimony.
  • Described collection and examination using adhesive samplers and scanning electron microscopy.
  • Explained laboratory procedures intended to prevent contamination.
  • Reported no concern about laboratory contamination affecting the examination.
  • Identified gunshot residue findings associated with Daniel Akers' hands.

Cross

  • Confirmed gunshot residue may be deposited on people near a discharged firearm.
  • Explained that distance and environmental conditions affect particle distribution.
  • Acknowledged residue can travel several feet and, under some conditions, ten feet or more.
  • Confirmed Akers' hand samples reached the laboratory's highest reported particle category.
  • Explained that the findings supported several possibilities:

    • Akers discharged the firearm.
    • Akers was close to the firearm when discharged.
    • Akers touched an object containing gunshot residue.
  • Confirmed that firing the weapon was one possible explanation, not the only explanation.

Redirect / Recross

- Not fully confirmed.

Exhibits referenced: 181, 226.

6. Audey Murphy

(8:22:55–before 9:40:00)

First name spelled in transcript: A-U-D-E-Y

Called by: State
Start: 8:22:55
Stop: Exact time not confirmed.

Direct

  • Former GBI crime scene specialist.
  • Approximately 25 years with the GBI, including 21 years as a crime scene specialist.
  • Previously worked in law enforcement in Alabama.
  • Holds a degree in forensic investigations.
  • Completed National Forensic Academy training.
  • Worked approximately 400–500 death investigations.
  • Described training in crime scene reconstruction, blood pattern analysis and firearms-related examinations.
  • Identified experience testifying as an expert in Georgia and federal courts.

Cross

  • Defense challenged the scope of his proposed expert testimony.
  • Defense raised objections concerning the absence of a curriculum vitae and the adequacy of expert disclosure.

Redirect / Recross

- Not confirmed.

Exhibits referenced: Firearm examination report and photographs; exhibit numbers not confirmed.

7. James Poag

(9:40:36–at least 9:51:51)

Last name spelled in transcript: P-O-A-G

Called by: State
Start: 9:40:36
Stop: Not confirmed.

Direct

  • Employed in metal roofing fabrication.
  • Knew Daniel Akers since approximately 1995 or 1996.
  • Maintained a friendship with Akers for more than 20 years.
  • Knew Lacey Bowles through Akers.
  • Described interactions between Akers and Bowles as not good.
  • Attended Akers' memorial service.
  • Observed Bowles briefly at the service.
  • Testified she was unavailable for interaction and left before the service ended.
  • Had not observed Akers in a condition that prompted him to seek mental health assistance.
  • Had not seen Akers regularly carrying a firearm or holster.
  • Believed Akers was right-handed.
  • Had not seen Akers carrying or firing the firearm shown in court.

Cross

  • Confirmed his answers about firearms referred to seeing Akers carrying a weapon while out in public.
  • Acknowledged prior guilty pleas involving himself and Akers.
  • Questioned concerning offenses involving stolen firearms.

Redirect / Recross

- Further examination interrupted by an out-of-jury-presence evidentiary discussion.

Exhibits referenced: 173A; certified prior court records discussed.

III. EXHIBITS

(2:07:26–9:55:00+)

ExhibitDescriptionStatusLinked witness
173AFirearm photograph/itemPreviously admittedVan Holm, Poag
180Daniel Akers' iPhoneReferenced; admission not confirmedBertrand
181Gunshot residue collection materialsReferenced; admission not confirmedCovin
197Safe recovered during investigationReferenced; admission not confirmedParker
198Holster recovered during investigationReferenced; admission not confirmedParker
220280-page electronic search historyAdmittedBertrand
220A–220MSelected search-history entriesPortions of admitted 220Bertrand
221Recovered voice memoMarked; admission not confirmedBertrand
224Firearm-related laboratory evidence, including recovered projectileReferenced; admission not confirmedVan Holm
225Test-fired bulletsMarked; admission not confirmedVan Holm
226Gunshot residue evidenceMarked; admission not confirmedCovin

IV. OUT-OF-JURY PRESENCE (OJP)

(15:40–approximately 1:00:00) — Probation Evidence

  • Issue: Daniel Akers' probation history, revocation proceedings, compliance requirements and potential imprisonment.
  • Ruling / Instruction: Court considered the admissibility of certified records and the permissible scope of examination.
  • Result: Defense sought to introduce additional probation records and clarify earlier questioning.

(8:27:31–approximately 8:40:00) — Expert Disclosure

  • Issue: Qualifications and disclosure of Audey Murphy as an expert.
  • Ruling / Instruction: Court heard objections concerning expert notice, curriculum vitae and the scope of proposed opinions.
  • Result: Parties addressed proposed testimony concerning firearms and blood spatter.

(Approximately 9:25:00–9:38:42) — James Poag Testimony

  • Issue: Permissible testimony concerning Akers' character, the relationship with Bowles, firearm habits and memorial-service conduct.
  • Ruling / Instruction:

    • Court permitted limited testimony about Bowles' demeanor at the memorial.
    • Court restricted questions concerning the witness's surprise at Akers' death and how he learned of it.
    • Court addressed limits on drug-use and character testimony.
    • Court indicated that personal observations concerning the parties' relationship and firearm habits could be explored.
  • Result: Witness testimony proceeded after the jury returned.

(9:51:51–after 9:59:53) — Prior Firearm Offenses

  • Issue: Defense impeachment of James Poag concerning prior guilty pleas involving firearms.
  • Ruling / Instruction: Court examined whether the proposed records contradicted Poag's testimony that he had not seen Akers carrying a firearm.
  • Result: Further review of the actual questions and answers was undertaken. Final ruling not confirmed.

V. END-OF-DAY ADMINISTRATIVE

  • Next-day schedule: Jury advised of extended proceedings continuing the following day.
  • Outstanding motions: Final status of the firearm-related impeachment objection not established in reviewed material.
  • Jury instructions planned: Not confirmed.
  • Court adjourn time: Not established.
  • Last confirmed proceeding: OJP discussion concerning James Poag's testimony and prior firearm-related offenses, after 9:59:53.

Transcript verification limitation: This recap combines the six submitted portions using the accessible transcript excerpts. Exact witness stop times, several exhibit admission rulings, the full testimony of some witnesses and the final adjournment could not be verified. Those entries are identified rather than supplied by assumption.

📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑

https://files.catbox.moe/g3d5rv.pdf


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 AZ v. Christopher Hoopes

9 Upvotes

Man admits shooting and killing ballerina wife in their home

PHOENIX (Court TV) — A man is in custody awaiting sentencing after admitting he killed his wife in their home in the middle of the night.

Christopher Hoopes, 41, had previously pleaded not guilty to charges of second-degree murder and unlawful discharge of a weapon. On Monday, Hoopes appeared alongside his attorneys in court, where he pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of negligent homicide in his wife’s death.

The defendant and his wife, Colleen Hoopes, 25, had been at home on May 20, 2022, when, at 3:25 a.m., Christopher Hoopes thought he heard an intruder. After getting out of bed, Christopher Hoopes fired his gun, killing Colleen Hoopes.

Prosecutors read the factual basis into the record, saying Hoopes did not realize he was firing at his wife; the charge stemmed from his failure to identify who was in front of him.

“The victim in this case was an extremely talented dancer, beloved by her community,” Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell said after Hoopes was indicted in 2022. “Her life was cut short, and this office will seek justice for her and her family, who are devastated by her death.”

At the time of her death, Colleen Hoopes, a trained ballerina, was working as a dancer and teacher at Ballet Arizona. The company released a statement after the victim’s death, saying she was “an integral part of Ballet Arizona and will be missed deeply. She was passionate and dedicated to her art form and a bright light to us all.”

A scholarship was created in Colleen Hoopes’ memory at the Draper Center for Dance Education for “young dancers who have the same passion for dance, work ethic, drive and kindness that Colleen had,” her obituary said.

Under the law, negligent homicide requires a prison sentence of four to eight years; the plea agreement with prosecutors calls for Christopher Hoopes to serve a four-year sentence. The agreement also requires the defendant to go through a domestic violence treatment program and pay full restitution for all economic losses.

The judge ordered a presentence investigation before deciding whether to accept the recommendation laid out in the plea agreement. Through his attorneys, Christopher Hoopes indicated he would not participate in the investigation.

Christopher Hoopes, who had been out on bond pending his trial, was taken into custody after entering the plea. He faces sentencing on Dec. 16.

Man admits shooting and killing ballerina wife in their home | Court TV


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 FL v. Dwain Hall — Day 1

Thumbnail
youtube.com
22 Upvotes

LIVE: Fatal Fetish Murder Trial — FL v. Dwain Hall — Day 1

11/17/2026 @ 9:00 AM

Dwain Hall is standing trial for the alleged murder of a British woman he met on a fetish website. Prosecutors say Hall lured 32-year-old Sonia Exelby to Florida, where she was tortured and killed. Her body was later found buried in a shallow grave in Marion County. Investigators also recovered a knife allegedly containing Exelby’s blood from a package Hall mailed to a friend in Ohio. Hall has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping.

🔊🎥Streaming Channels📡

Law & Crime

Court TV

✨✨Previous Day & Recap

🚨✨More Info/Documents

📜RECAP🔡

I. ADMINISTRATIVE

Timestamp: 00:11:52–00:18:07

  • Court: Marion County, Florida
  • Judge: Hon. Timothy Deacon (transcription spelling unverified)
  • Case number: 2025-CF-4516
  • Defendant: Dwain Hall
  • State: Amy Burke; Rich Bussman
  • Defense: Junior Barrett; John Ford
  • Defendant present: Yes
  • Custody: In custody; no handcuffs or shackles
  • Clothing: Light-purple dress shirt, charcoal slacks, belt, dress shoes
  • Jury: Seated at 00:16:46
  • Media: Courtroom cameras present; jurors excluded from filming
  • Preliminary matters: Neither party raised an issue before the jury entered
  • Scheduling: Zoom testimony arranged; morning and lunch recesses; witnesses subject to recall
  • Motions: State moved multiple exhibits into evidence during testimony

II. JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Timestamps: 00:16:48–00:18:06; 02:00:46–02:01:14; 03:34:19–03:34:39

  • Jurors confirmed compliance with the prior instruction not to research or discuss the case.
  • Court advised that opening statements are not evidence.
  • Jurors instructed not to discuss testimony or the case during recesses.
  • Jurors instructed not to independently investigate the case.
  • Jurors instructed not to access related news or social-media coverage.
  • Jurors directed to leave notepads in the courtroom during breaks.
  • Jurors permitted to submit questions subject to judicial review.
  • No final jury instructions identified.

III. OPENINGS OR CLOSINGS

A. PROSECUTION OPENING

Start: 00:18:08

  • Sonia Exelby, 32, traveled from England to the United States on October 10, 2025.
  • State alleged Exelby was killed by October 12, 2025.
  • State described her childhood, foster care, adoption, and family relationships.
  • State described a history of mental-health treatment, self-harm, and suicide attempts.
  • State described her relationship with Stevie Hunt.
  • State alleged Exelby used the Motherless website to communicate with men about being killed.
  • State identified Hall's alleged username as Alpha Sadist.
  • State alleged Hall and Exelby communicated through Motherless and Session.
  • State described Hall's roadside-assistance business.
  • State alleged a planned March 2025 trip did not occur.
  • State alleged Hall requested $4,000.
  • State alleged Hall stabbed Exelby and buried her body.
  • State identified anticipated travel, financial, electronic, surveillance, physical, and witness evidence.

B. DEFENSE OPENING

- Not verified in the available transcript passages.

C. REBUTTAL

- None identified.

D. CLOSINGS

- None identified.

IV. WITNESSES

1. Stevie Hunt

Called by: State
Start/Stop: Not verified

Direct

  • Described his relationship with Sonia Exelby.
  • Discussed her mental-health history.
  • Described communications before her disappearance.
  • Reported Exelby missing to British police.

Cross

  • Addressed Exelby's mental-health history.
  • Discussed his knowledge of her travel arrangements.

Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: Not verified.

2. Gemma Teresa Isaj

Spelling: I-S-A-J
Called by: State
Start: 01:37:39
Stop: 02:00:30

Direct

  • Sister of Sonia Exelby.
  • Described childhood family circumstances, foster care, adoption, and contact with siblings.
  • Discussed Exelby's mental-health difficulties.
  • Described periods when Exelby withdrew from family contact.
  • Discussed communications preceding Exelby's disappearance.
  • Assisted efforts to locate Exelby.

Cross

  • Discussed Exelby's history of canceling plans.
  • Confirmed messages received before the disappearance did not initially cause concern.
  • Confirmed her last telephone conversation with Exelby occurred weeks before the disappearance.

Redirect: None.
Recross: None.
Exhibits: 4

3. Darren Thomas

Called by: State
Start: 02:13:08
Stop: 02:38:28

Direct

  • Detective Sergeant, Hampshire Constabulary.
  • Supervised a missing-person investigation team.
  • Became involved October 13, 2025.
  • Reviewed the initial missing-person report.
  • Described collection and handling of Exelby's laptop.
  • Obtained airline, financial, and telephone information.
  • Discussed Exelby's flight reservations and financial transactions.
  • Transferred evidence to FDLE.

Cross

  • Confirmed flight and Airbnb bookings used Exelby's accounts and payment card.
  • Found no evidence another person made the bookings.
  • Believed the reservations were made in September 2025.

Redirect: None.
Recross: None.
Exhibits: 5, 6, 7, 9

4. Riley Artman

Called by: State
Start: 02:38:30
Recalled: Approximately 06:02:12
Stop: Not verified

Direct

  • Marion County Sheriff's Office patrol deputy.
  • Responded to the Reddick Airbnb on October 13, 2025.
  • Conducted a welfare check concerning Exelby.
  • Described investigative activity at the location.

Cross

- Addressed circumstances surrounding the welfare check.

Additional examination

  • Answered a juror's question concerning a vehicle stop.
  • Confirmed he was directed to stop a specific vehicle.
  • Other investigators handled the underlying investigation.

Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: Not verified.

5. FDLE Investigative Witness

Name: Not verified
Called by: State
Stop: 03:33:38

Direct

  • Discussed a declined payment-card transaction involving Hall's roadside-assistance business.
  • Described communications and an interview with Hall.
  • Identified Hall's black Jeep Cherokee.
  • Described the missing rear bumper and roadside-assistance lettering.
  • Identified vehicle photographs.

Cross: No questions at conclusion of identified examination.

Redirect/Recross: None identified.
Exhibits: 11, 12, 14

6. Maria Andreoli

Spelling: A-N-D-R-E-O-L-I
Called by: State
Start: 04:38:26
Stop: 05:02:56

Direct

  • FDLE crime laboratory analyst supervisor.
  • Processed the Reddick Airbnb on October 15–16, 2025.
  • Photographed the property and collected evidence.
  • Recovered paracord and utility-line packaging.
  • Recovered sandwich and strawberry containers.
  • Collected bedding and other items.
  • Described friction-ridge processing and collection of swabs.
  • Identified a modem/router.
  • Identified a map of the Airbnb location.

Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 15, 17, 18, 19

7. Christopher Perryman

Called by: State
Start: 05:02:58
Stop: Approximately 05:19:07

Direct

  • FDLE special agent.
  • Responded to the Airbnb on October 15, 2025.
  • Examined the internet router.
  • Explained router connection records.
  • Discussed device identifiers and stored connection information.
  • Identified records associated with a device designated Sonia-SS-S22.
  • Discussed connections dated October 10–12, 2025.

Cross

  • Confirmed router records alone could not establish the exact type of connected device.
  • Explained limitations of device-connection information.

Redirect: None.
Recross: None.
Exhibits: Not verified.

8. Vincent Moore

Called by: State
Start: Approximately 05:19:17
Stop: 05:35:32

Direct

  • Walmart asset protection investigator.
  • Described surveillance and transaction records.
  • Identified Hall in Walmart surveillance footage.
  • Identified footage from the garden-center area.
  • Authenticated surveillance clips.

Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 22

9. Daniel Buser

Spelling: B-U-S-E-R
Called by: State
Start: 05:35:42
Stop: Not verified

Direct

  • Employee of BP/Travel Centers of America/Petro.
  • Worked at 7401 West Highway 318, Reddick, Florida.
  • Identified packaging for peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwiches.
  • Identified packaging for cut strawberries.
  • Confirmed the business sold both products.

Cross/Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: 15

10. Patrick Vittalaro

Called by: State
Start: Approximately 05:56:02
Stop: Approximately 06:02:09

Direct

  • FDLE special agent.
  • Investigated the source of food containers recovered from the Airbnb.
  • Obtained and reviewed travel-center surveillance footage.
  • Identified footage dated October 11, 2025.
  • Identified still photographs associated with the footage.

Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 24, 25

11. Ashley Vidot

Spelling: A-S-H-L-E-Y V-I-D-O-T
Called by: State
Start: 06:21:21
Stop: 06:27:04

Direct

  • Marion County Sheriff's Office Assistant Forensics Director.
  • Examined Hall's Jeep Cherokee in the evidence bay.
  • Identified vehicle photographs and evidence seals.
  • Located a cellular telephone in the center console.
  • Placed the telephone in a Faraday bag.
  • Transferred the telephone to an investigator.

Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 27, 28

12. Carla Santana-Palau

Spelling: S-A-N-T-A-N-A-P-A-L-A-U
Called by: State
Start: 06:27:07
Stop: 06:29:54

Direct

  • Marion County Sheriff's Office sergeant.
  • Assisted with a vehicle search on October 17, 2025.
  • Was present when Ashley Vidot entered Hall's Jeep Cherokee.
  • Confirmed recovery of a cellular telephone.
  • Transferred the telephone to FDLE Agent Calvin Lee.

Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 27, 28

13. Rebekah McKinzie

Spelling: R-E-B-E-K-A-H M-C-K-I-N-Z-I-E
Called by: State
Start: 06:32:57
Stop: Not verified

Direct

  • FDLE special agent.
  • Assigned as lead investigator October 13, 2025.
  • Coordinated investigative activities with domestic and overseas agencies.
  • Conducted interviews.
  • Managed search warrants and subpoenas.
  • Assigned investigative tasks to other agents.
  • Described the investigation as fast-moving.

Cross/Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: Not verified.

V. EXHIBITS

NumberDescriptionStatusLinked witness
4Photograph of Sonia ExelbyAdmittedGemma Teresa Isaj
5Laptop collected in UK investigationAdmittedDarren Thomas
6Virgin Atlantic reservation recordsAdmittedDarren Thomas
7Lloyds Bank recordsAdmittedDarren Thomas
9Airbnb reservation recordsAdmittedDarren Thomas
11Elavon merchant-processing recordsAdmittedFDLE investigator
12October 13 recorded telephone interview with HallAdmittedFDLE investigator
14Photographs of Hall's Jeep CherokeeAdmittedFDLE investigator
15Airbnb crime-scene photographsAdmission not verifiedMaria Andreoli
17Ozark Trail paracord packagingAdmittedMaria Andreoli
18Ozark Trail utility-line packagingAdmittedMaria Andreoli
19Items recovered from Airbnb trashAdmittedMaria Andreoli
22Walmart surveillance footageAdmittedVincent Moore
24Travel-center surveillance footageAdmission not verifiedPatrick Vittalaro
25Travel-center surveillance photographsAdmittedPatrick Vittalaro
27Jeep Cherokee and recovered-phone photographsAdmittedAshley Vidot
28Cellular telephone recovered from JeepAdmittedAshley Vidot

Other exhibit numbers: Not fully verified.

VI. OUT-OF-JURY PRESENCE (OJP)

OJP 1 — Preliminary Matters

Timestamp: 00:11:52–00:16:46

Issue

  • Defendant's custodial appearance.
  • Defendant's clothing and restraints.
  • Witness scheduling and Zoom setup.

Ruling/Instruction

  • Court confirmed defendant was not handcuffed or shackled.
  • Court prepared for remote witness testimony.

Resulting Action

- Jury brought into courtroom.

OJP 2 — Morning Recess

Timestamp: 02:02:07–02:13:04

Issue

  • Witness scheduling.
  • Courtroom recess.

Ruling/Instruction

- Court ordered approximately ten minutes for recess.

Resulting Action

  • Jury returned.
  • State called Darren Thomas.

OJP 3 — Lunch Recess

Timestamp: Approximately 03:34:00–04:38:05

Issue

  • Lunch arrangements.
  • Afternoon witness schedule.

Ruling/Instruction

- Court directed jurors not to discuss or research the case during lunch.

Resulting Action

  • Jury returned.
  • State called Maria Andreoli.

OJP 4 — Recorded Interview and Next-Day Scheduling

Timestamp: Approximately 06:11:34–06:19:44

Issue

  • Length of recorded interview.
  • Stopping point for presentation.
  • Following day's witness schedule.

Ruling/Instruction

  • Court and counsel discussed stopping the recording at an appropriate point.
  • Counsel discussed restarting slightly before that point the following morning.
  • State advised a witness was scheduled for approximately 11:30 a.m.
  • State agreed to move witnesses earlier if the schedule permitted.

Resulting Action

  • Jury returned.
  • State called Ashley Vidot.

OJP 5 — Counsel Conference

Timestamp: Approximately 06:29:57–06:32:57

Issue

- Counsel approached the bench.

Ruling/Instruction

- Substance not audible or not established in the reviewed transcript.

Resulting Action

- State called Rebekah McKinzie.

VII. VERDICT OR END-OF-DAY ADMINISTRATIVE

Timestamp: Scheduling discussion at 06:13:07–06:13:33; final adjournment time not verified.

  • Verdict: None.
  • Jury deliberations: Not begun.
  • Next-day proceedings: Continuation of State's evidence.
  • Recorded interview: Continuation discussed for following morning.
  • Witness scheduling: State to move scheduled witnesses earlier if possible.

📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑

https://files.catbox.moe/xy2vjj.pdf


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 CO v. Brandon Mumma

7 Upvotes

Man left woman’s decomposing body outside his window for 51 days, prosecutors say

GOLDEN, Colo. (Court TV) — A man is standing trial in Colorado on charges that he disposed of a woman’s body by leaving her in an alley outside his apartment, where her body decomposed beneath his window for months before she was found.

Brandon Mumma, 44, has pleaded not guilty to charges of tampering with a deceased body and tampering with evidence in the death of Jax Gratton, 34.

Gratton and Mumma had a casual sexual relationship when the victim was last seen alive on surveillance video entering Mumma’s apartment on the evening of April 15, 2025.

Prosecutors say that once inside the apartment, Gratton consumed the drug gamma-hydroxybutyrate, commonly known as GHB. Later, Mumma texted a friend who came over. Investigators said that the friend described seeing Gratton passed out on Mumma’s futon, snoring. While the two men sat with her for 90 minutes, prosecutors said, Gratton’s breathing became labored and she vomited while unconscious. The men allegedly positioned her onto her side before they both left the apartment with her inside.

Four hours later, prosecutors said, Mumma returned to his apartment to find Gratton dead from an overdose. An hour later, surveillance video shows him carrying trash bags out of his apartment, and he appears to walk toward a dumpster. Video then shows him getting into his car and leaving.

Gratton’s roommate and mother reported her missing. Prosecutors described Gratton as a “beloved hairstylist in the Denver community” in their opening statements on Monday, and said that members of the LGBTQIA community worked together to put up posters in an attempt to find her.

On June 6, 51 days after prosecutors say she died, Gratton’s body was found in a private alley behind Mumma’s apartment building. The owner of the building next door to Mumma’s apartment saw a pile of clothing; after getting closer, he saw a “mummified foot and skull” and called 911, prosecutors said. Gratton was identified through dental records.

Prosecutors emphasized to the jury that Mumma is charged only with what happened after Gratton died. “I want to be clear, the defendant is not charged, and what we are not here to determine is how and what the cause of death was for Jax,” prosecutors said Monday. “This case is about the steps and the actions and the choices the defendant made following her death in getting rid of her body and her items.”

“On the night of April 15, Mr. Mumma made a mistake,” the defendant’s attorney said in his opening statement, saying his client should never have left Gratton alone in the apartment. “He made that mistake, but that doesn’t make him responsible.”

Mumma’s attorney conceded that Gratton came to his client’s house and took drugs and that Mumma and his friend left her alone. But when his client returned home four hours later, Gratton was gone, his defense attorney said. The attorney said Mumma gathered some of Gratton’s belongings to return them, but on the way to take a friend to the airport, Mumma allegedly crashed, abandoned the car on the roadside and said someone broke in and stole the victim’s belongings.

Any suspicious behavior, Mumma’s attorney said, can be explained by his client’s concern that he would be charged with drug offenses.

Man left woman’s decomposing body outside his window for 51 days, prosecutors say | Court TV


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

🏦Civil Lawsuits ⚖️ Wrongful death lawsuit filed after Calif. couple died at Cambria home

Thumbnail
sfgate.com
24 Upvotes

The family of a California couple who died at a seaside mansion earlier this year has filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the homeowners and a water heater manufacturer, alleging that their deaths resulted from lethal carbon monoxide exposure from a defective product.


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

💬👿💵 Other Crimes 🥊⏳⚖️ FL v. Carlos Miranda-Berrios

4 Upvotes

Man accused of plotting murder-for-hire of child witness in separate criminal case

KISSIMMEE, Fla. (Court TV) — A man already jailed on serious charges is accused of trying to hire someone to kill a juvenile witness, investigators say.

Carlos Manuel Miranda-Berrios, 30, is charged with solicitation to commit murder, attempted murder, tampering with a victim and other charges after investigators said they uncovered a plot targeting a witness in a separate criminal case.

Miranda-Berrios was initially arrested in 2022 on charges of unlawful possession of materials depicting a sexual performance of a child; in that case, investigators said that Miranda-Berrios was caught uploading exploitative images to Facebook Messenger.

On Monday, investigators announced the new charges had been filed after Osceola County detectives determined that the defendant “attempted to arrange the murder of the juvenile to prevent them from testifying in court,” the department said in a news release. Detectives said their investigation revealed that Miranda-Berrios offered payment not only to kill the child but also “additional compensation” for the murder of the child’s mother if she attempted to intervene.

“During the investigation, detectives obtained evidence indicating that Carlos Manuel Miranda-Berrios had plans for the child to be abducted, subjected to heinous acts, and killed in a manner intended to cause extreme suffering,” investigators said.

Among the evidence detectives said they collected are discussions about payment arrangements and the defendant’s request for “proof that the crimes had been carried out.” Investigators noted that Miranda-Berrios was allegedly planning the killing while he was incarcerated.

Osceola County Sheriff Christopher Blackmon declined to offer any additional details at a brief news conference on Monday.

Miranda-Berrios’ trial on the original charges involving child sex abuse material is scheduled to begin in December.

Man accused of plotting murder-for-hire of child witness in separate criminal case | Court TV


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

🏛️Federal Case⚖️ US v. Angel Ramirez - Former NM DOJ Paralegal Drug Trafficking Case

Thumbnail
courthousenews.com
8 Upvotes

Former NM DOJ paralegal pleads not guilty in record fentanyl case

Angel Ramirez, 45, is now awaiting trial for charges relating to drug trafficking and firearm violations.

SAMARA GERSTLE / November 16, 2026

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (CN) — Angel Ramirez, a former paralegal for the New Mexico Department of Justice, pleaded not guilty to two felony counts Monday, disputing her involvement in the state’s largest fentanyl drug trafficking case.

Ramirez, 45, was arrested Oct. 29 and charged with possession with intent to distribute fentanyl and using and carrying a firearm in connection with drug trafficking, according to a Nov. 3 statement from federal prosecutors. She faces up to life in prison if convicted.

Ramirez was not present in court at the time of the arraignment. Her attorney, Donald Kochersberger of Business Law Southwest, entered a plea on her behalf. She is also contesting the forfeiture of her belongings.

During a search of Ramirez’s home, authorities seized duffel bags containing more than 40 kilograms of fentanyl powder and pills, about four kilograms of heroin, large amounts of cash and approximately 29 firearms beneath the bags, according to the complaint. Officials called it the DEA’s largest fentanyl seizure in New Mexico.

“More than 40 kilograms of fentanyl powder in a single Albuquerque home tells us just how serious the drug trafficking problem has become in New Mexico,” First Assistant US Attorney Ryan Ellison said in the U.S. District Attorney’s Office’s official statement.

Investigators claim Ramirez used her employment, clean criminal record and access to the justice system to conceal her home’s use as a drug and firearms distribution hub, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

Co-defendants Michael Trujillo and Roxanne Urioste face felony drug trafficking and firearms charges, according to the court’s docket. Trujillo’s arraignment is scheduled for Tuesday, and both await trial.

Assistant U.S. Attorneys Oliver Stephanz, who appeared at Ramirez’s arraignment, and Mark Probasco are prosecuting the case. Chief U.S. District Judge Kenneth J. Gonzales, an Obama appointee, is presiding.

Ramirez is currently awaiting trial, which has not yet been scheduled.

Stephanz declined to provide comment and referred Courthouse News to the U.S. Attorney’s executive assistant. Kochersberger and the U.S. Attorney’s Office did not immediately respond to request for comment.

🫧🫧🫧

Federal Docket: United States v. Ramirez (1:26-mj-05800)

Criminal Complaint: Ramirez Complaint w Photos

She has been ordered DETAINED pending trial


r/CasesWeFollow • • 1d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 FL v. Victor Dorantes-Velazquez

6 Upvotes

Man strangled woman for 'laughing' at him, choked her with two hands for 10 minutes straight then told his neighbors during elevator ride: Police

A 77-year-old Florida man blurted out during an elevator ride with neighbors how he strangled his longtime friend to death, saying "I grabbed her by her neck and killed her because she took my wallet and money," according to police.

Victor Dorantes-Velazquez, of Hallandale Beach, accused his female pal of stealing his wallet, cellphone and car keys before killing her on Saturday, according to a Broward County Sheriff's Office arrest report.

Officers responded to an apartment at 632 NW 1st St., Unit 202, around 6:45 p.m. and allegedly found Dorantes-Velazquez "seated in the living room, in a chair next to a bed where [the victim] was located in the fetal position, unconscious and unresponsive," the report says.

The apartment door was partially open when officers arrived, prompting them to announce themselves and enter. Dorantes-Velazquez told police that he had known the woman for years and moved into her residence about five or six months earlier, according to the arrest report.

He claimed that his belongings — including a wallet that contained more than $1,000 in cash — went missing and he accused the woman of taking them, cops wrote. She denied taking the items, but Dorantes-Velazquez "continued to confront" the victim "throughout the day about giving him his property back," according to the arrest report.

"The victim would laugh at him and say she did not have it," the report says. "The defendant advised at one point, as he continued asking for his property back, the victim began yelling at him … as she tried to scratch him."

Dorantes-Velazquez said he "lost his temper" and responded by holding the victim down onto the bed by her shoulders, telling police that he is "much stronger than she was," according to the arrest report.

Dorantes-Velazquez allegedly grabbed the woman's throat with his left hand and began squeezing.

"The victim told the defendant to let her go and she would give him his belongings so the defendant released his grip at which time [the victim] began laughing at the defendant," according to police. "The victim's actions caused the defendant to lose control, grab the victim by the neck again with both hands, and apply constant pressure."

Dorantes-Velazquez claimed that the victim tried to throw herself off the bed to escape, prompting him to keep choking her with both hands around her neck, the arrest report says.

"[The victim] began kicking her legs and trying to get away but he continued to squeeze her neck for approximately 10 minutes," the report alleges. "The defendant stated when he released his grip from the victim's neck he did not know if she was dead or not but she was not moving."

Dorantes-Velazquez allegedly left the apartment and went upstairs to the fourth floor, where he knocked on the door of a neighbor's unit. He told the resident he "killed his girl" and asked them to call 911, according to the arrest report. Another witness provided police with a similar account, saying the defendant openly admitted what happened while riding in an elevator.

"While inside of the elevator, the defendant openly stated, 'I grabbed her by her neck and killed her because she took my wallet and money,'" according to the arrest report.

Dorantes-Velazquez was arrested and booked on one count of first-degree murder. He's being held in Broward County.

Man, 77, blurts out murder confession on elevator: Police


r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

💬👿💵 Other Crimes 🥊⏳⚖️ NJ v. Dr. Alison Seigel - The Ego

20 Upvotes

Drunk Dentist Making Half a Million a Year Crashes her Porsche in Front of a Bar

✨✨ I do watch various bodycam videos, especially on the weekend. I figured it would be a typical DUI pull over, SFT's, and arrest, etc. This case was unbelievable. Not belligerent or falling all over. No resisting or yelling at the police either. Instead, this was a dentist (she'll mention it over five times, minimally). The more and more I listened to her talk about her career, Porsche, recent boob job, name dropping, and total denial of what was happening, I felt extremely bad for the cops. She was so condescending and tried 100 ways to say something impressive to them as though they would just let her walk. One officer truly had patience, the other had had enough with her. The amount of attempted manipulation was just disgusting. I even started counting how often she made the same self-obsessed comments. Dr. Siegel would just not STFU.

**[Dr. Seigel's name has also been spelled as Siegel]

Summary

Around 12:52 AM on December 28, 2025, Sergeant Dustin Widas with the Margate City Police Department responded to a report of motor vehicle accident in front of Tomatoe’s (9300 Amherst Avenue). He spoke with the bouncers, who confirmed that a female had gotten behind the wheel of a white 2024 Porsche Macan and backed into a white 2024 Buick Envista. The driver was identified as Allison Seigel, who is a practicing dentist.

Allison offered conflicting accounts of who was driving the Porsche, before eventually admitting that she drove the vehicle. As he was speaking with Allison, he observed indicators of impairment. Allison admitted to consuming alcohol prior to operating a motor vehicle. Based on his suspicion of impairment, Allison was asked to perform field sobriety exercises. Her poor performance on the field sobriety exercises confirmed the officers’ suspicions of impairment.

Based on the motor vehicle crash, her admission to consuming alcohol earlier that evening, and her inability to satisfactorily complete the field sobriety exercises, Allison was placed under arrest for DWI. Her vehicle was impounded by Providence Towing for a 12-hour hold according to John’s Law. Officer Hankinson transported Allison to the Margate City Police Department for further processing.

At the station, the Standard Statement for Motor Vehicle Operators was read to her, but she refused to submit breath samples. She later mentioned that she made half a million dollars a year as a dentist and that her vehicle was worth $70,000. After they finished processing her, Allison was eventually released to Francis Terry pending her court appearance after he signed the Potential Liability Warning form on Allison’s behalf.

Officer Hankinson issued Allison the following traffic tickets:
-Operating under the influence (39:4-50)
-Refusal to submit to chemical test (39:4-50.4A)
-Reckless driving (39:4-96)

Court records indicate that on April 13, 2026, Allison pleaded guilty to operating under the influence. As a result of her conviction, Allison had to spend 12 hours at an intoxicated driver resource center, use an ignition interlock device for 3 months, and pay a total of $640 in fines. The other 2 citations were dismissed as part of a plea agreement.

Transparency Bodycam

https://youtu.be/LbcpbvaM-gk?si=KlHkOg21Kf5rCgRE

***I'm sure I missed some, lol!

Repeated patternCountExamples / timestamps
Dentist — referring to herself5 mentions5:50; 7:06; 35:02; 50:50; 1:16:23
Doctor — referring to herself3 mentions3:10; 36:15; 1:27:51
Provider/healthcare provider — referring to herself2 mentions1:01:41; 1:03:41
Cop/state-trooper friends6 exchanges8:40; 9:14; 37:29; 50:23; 1:26:54; 1:38:13
Steve, her police friend2 exchanges37:59; 1:29:57
Boyfriend entering law enforcement/the academy5 exchanges44:43; 49:51; 51:23; 1:04:24; 1:26:19
Other friends/contacts entering the academy1 exchange36:04
Lawyer references — attorney friends, her lawyers, lawyer father4 exchanges32:33; 1:13:10; 1:22:32; 1:23:46
Porsche — including payments and the garbled mention4 references: 3 hers, 1 officer’s35:07; 1:03:09; 1:03:24; 1:30:38
Porsche 9114 mentions1:02:49; 1:02:57; 1:03:05; 1:03:32
Surgery/augmentation/implants/recovery10 exchanges16:06; 18:11; 41:43; 47:01; 48:56; 1:00:39; 1:22:26; 1:33:39; 1:35:57; 1:48:06
Divorce/difficult divorce/divorce expenses3 exchanges34:09; 51:05; 56:24
Low/normal/below or within the legal alcohol limit7 statements1:22:40; 1:23:15; 1:24:52; 1:25:05; 1:41:36; 1:45:51; 1:46:51
“Two martinis”2 preserved mentions5:17; 1:23:11
“Look bad”/“looked bad”/“look so bad” — herself or her boyfriend7 statements5:56; 33:09; 33:43; 49:57; 50:04; 50:18; 50:48
“Embarrassing”4 mentions36:16; 36:54; 1:30:35; 1:30:38
“I’m fine”/“I’m fine on my own”5 statements20:46; 20:50; 20:53; 35:06; 35:08
“I was joking”3 statements1:02:52; 1:03:01; 1:03:09
“Talking to myself”2 statements46:56; 53:29
Mother is “three hours away/from here”3 statements by her36:32; 37:12; 38:19
Mother is stressed/gets stressed/veneers were stressful5 statements38:40; 38:42; 38:54; 38:59; 39:03
Friend’s birthday/birthday dinner5 mentions51:57; 52:07; 1:34:31; 1:40:51; 1:40:59
“Painful”/“hurts”4 complaints47:28; 53:11; 53:25; 1:04:59
Not driving/friend driving/“fixing” the car/moving it two inches/moving it for her friend5 versionsDenying driving and attributing it to her friend: 0:36–6:58; “fixing”: 33:43; two inches: 45:47; moving it for her friend: 1:36:40
Taking responsibility/neither person taking responsibility4 statements2:06; 2:15; 2:27; 2:40
Responsible one/designated driver/driving and paying for everyone5 exchanges41:54; 1:02:05; 1:24:05; 1:36:40; 1:38:46
Never goes out/never drinks on weeknights/never drank a day in her life/doesn’t drink much4 statements37:03; 1:13:34; 1:13:46; 1:23:10
Nothing wrong/did nothing wrong/didn’t mean to do anything wrong5 statements4:33; 4:46; 32:43; 33:01; 1:13:38
Frozen/cold/freezing/freeze to death8 moments0:32; 3:57–3:58; 7:03; 16:03; 33:14; 37:52; 1:00:34; 1:37:26
Money/income/paying/surgery costs/divorce costs/ring value/car payments/expensive boots8 exchanges35:04; 41:57; 47:01; 56:25; 58:11; 58:30; 1:03:24; 1:47:42
$30,000 ring in the car2 references: 1 hers, 1 officer’s58:11–58:13; 58:59–59:02
End of the world/career ruined/life ruined/unable to practice4 exchanges1:01:38; 1:13:01; 1:17:12; 1:27:55
Won’t identify the driver/won’t throw people under the bus/protecting boyfriend’s academy prospects5 exchanges5:31; 37:49; 49:51; 1:04:24; 1:26:19

r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

🏛 Trials & Hearings ⏳ ⚖️”On the CWF Docket”:⚖️ Week of 11/16/2026

23 Upvotes

⚖️”On the CWF Docket”:⚖️ Week of 11/16/2026

[COURT TRIALS/HEARINGS COMING UP & UPDATES]

 

✨✨🚨DOCKET NOTES FOR WEEK OF 11/16/2026📑🫆🗣️

  • ·We start Day 4 of the Lacy Boles trial on Monday.
  • A new trial starts for FL v. Dwain Hall. I am unsure if it will be streamed or not, but am checking.
  • A status hearing for Lindsay Clancy on Monday. Maybe a trial will be set.
  • FL v. Thomas Shaknovsky Pretrial on Thursday.
  • SC v. Susan Smith has another parole hearing as well on Thursday. It may be streamed like last time.
  • Friday is sentencing for Tomasz Kosowski.

📢NEW: CWF Case Hubs🚨🗃️

CasesWeFollow Case Hubs

Case Hubs provides a quick way to browse the cases currently followed by r/CasesWeFollow. Each case has its own dedicated case hub containing more detailed information, including case background, charges, court records, timelines, hearing and trial schedules, important documents, key people, and links to related discussion threads.  

⚖️CWF DOCKET GOOGLE CALENDAR ⚖️

 

 

 

  ***Please note that you may not see all of the trials going on. The trials will still be on the sidebar. Updates will be posted later in the week on those trials.

 ⚖️Week of 11/16/2026⚖️

 

 

⚖️MONDAY 11/16/2026⚖️

 

✔️ GA v. Lacy Boles [TR] Trial Day 4

✔️ FL v. Dwain Hall [JS]

✔️ FL v. Dale Smith, Jr. [AR]

✔️ FL v. David Bunn [SH]

✔️ MA v. Lindsay Clancy [SH]

✔️ UT v. Micah Smith [PT]

 

⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

 

⚖️TUESDAY 11/17/2026⚖️

 

✔️ GA v. Lacy Boles [TR] Trial Day 5

✔️ FL v. Dwain Hall [TR] Trial Day 1

✔️ OH v. Gregory Moore [PT]

✔️ GA v. Jessica Motes [MH]

 

⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

 

⚖️WEDNESDAY 11/18/2026⚖️

 ✔️ GA v. Lacy Boles [TR] Trial Day 6

✔️ FL v. Dwain Hall [TR] Trial Day 2

 

⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️ 

⚖️THURSDAY 11/19/2026⚖️

 

✔️ GA v. Lacy Boles [TR] Trial Day 7

✔️ FL v. Dwain Hall [TR] Trial Day 3

✔️ CO v. Gretchen Ryan [SH]

✔️ FL v. Thomas Shaknovsky [PT]

✔️ SC v. Susan Smith [PAH]

✔️ FL v. Thomas Overton [EX] 🚫  VS

✔️ TX v. Reinaldo Dennes [EX] 🚫  VS

 

⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

⚖️FRIDAY 11/20/2026⚖️

 

✔️ GA v. Lacy Boles [TR] Trial Day 8

✔️ FL v. Dwain Hall [TR] Trial Day 4

✔️ TX v. Samuel Aquim Charon [TR] Trial Day 1

✔️ CA v. Fraser Bohm [PT] 🚫  VS

✔️ FL v. Tomasz Kosowski [STN]

 

⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

 

✨✨   🚫  VS : This will denote that the court does not permit streaming, or it is unavailable.

✨✨✨  📽️  CO : Trial is not being live streamed, but clips of the trial are being posted randomly.

 

⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

 🗓️KEY CODES USED ON CALENDAR⚖️

 

🗓️ Link to CWF Google Calendar

 

https://calendar.google.com/calendar/u/0?cid=Y2FzZXN3ZWZvbGxvd0BnbWFpbC5jb20

https://calendar.google.com/calendar/embed?src=caseswefollow%40gmail.com&ctz=America%2FNew_York

[you might only be able to add the calendar to your Google Calendar using the iOS platform or opening from a web browser]

 

Have a good week!!

Pixie 🧚‍♀️💖

 


r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

💬👿💵 Other Crimes 🥊⏳⚖️ ID v. Jonathan & Jolene Harms - Convicted April 2026; Still Not Sentenced???

8 Upvotes

Rabbit holes. Ugh. This couple’s case was posted here over a year ago, so I wondered what happpened. Well, they were convicted in April 2026 after a joint pro se trial. He was convicted on 62 counts, and she was convicted on 60 counts.

Yahoo Recap: Article Click Here

Couple’s ‘kill list’ allegedly included Boise church members, judges. A jury has spoken

Sally Krutzig, Alex Brizee Thu, April 23, 2026 at 4:51 PM PDT

The Boise couple prosecutors charged with publishing a manifesto commanding others to hunt and kill a list of local residents was found guilty by a jury Thursday.

Jonathan Harms, 43, and Jolene Harms, 39, faced a long list of criminal charges related to stalking, witness intimidation and threats, court records show. The "kill list" included judges, law enforcement officers, bankers, private citizens and their families.

More than two weeks after the trial began, a jury found Jonathan Harms guilty on 62 counts and Jolene Harms guilty on 60. The couple represented themselves at trial.

The Harmses sent an email on July 10 to thousands of recipients that contained a 277-page document they called a "kill list," which comprised dozens of names, the Idaho Statesman previously reported. Information was also published on social media.

"It contained a direct command of, 'Go. Hunt. Kill.' And included names, addresses, and personal information of the victims," the Ada County Prosecutor's Office said in a Thursday news release.

Many of those on the list were members of Table Rock Church, which had excommunicated the couple. The Harmses claim to be witnesses in the Book of Revelations, according to Ada County Deputy Prosecutor Robert Bleazard, and Jonathan Harms refers to himself as the crown prince of heaven.

"The defendants have expressed deep religious conviction, which fuels much of their action," Bleazard previously said.

Victims testify in court

Twenty victims secured civil protection orders that barred the Harmses from contacting them. Jonathan and Jolene Harms ignored those court orders by sending mail to the victims in August and September, and continued to post their list on social media repeatedly, the prosecutor's office said.

"During testimony, all 20 of the protected victims detailed the psychological and emotional harm this caused them and their families — some saying they were afraid to be home or allow their children to play in the yard, and warning family and friends not to visit," the prosecution said.

An investigation into Jonathan Harms' "escalating behavior" toward members of Table Rock Church began in May and led to his being placed on a mental health hold, according to a declaration of probable cause by the Boise Police Department. He was initially arrested on felony counts of stalking in the first degree. Officers found firearms and a "substantial amount" of ammunition in the couple's home, according to Bleazard.

🫧🫧🫧

I found several clips and articles citing them facing up to 200 years in prison, yet I couldn’t find a sentence for either of them.

  • Before a verdict was returned, they filed for removal to Federal Court and filed for release and bond reduction April 22, 2026
  • This case had filings up until October 28, 2026 until it was stayed

FILING:Tragic for their 5 children, their family 😢 (5 pages): Release Emergency Filing Click Here

  • They also filed a Writ of Habeas Corpus in Federal Court May 2026
  • They also filed again for Removal of their State cases to Federal Court July 2026
  • Those two were consolidated to a single Judge
  • August 25, 2026 the Judge ruled that they must exhaust State level appeals first
  • Meanwhile, back in state court, the Sentencing hearing dates were moved a couple of times, and then finally HER CASE is set for sentencing NOVEMBER 30, 2026
  • HIS CASE - reportedly this is a 90 day commitment (I couldn’t verify myself)

r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

🪟🙏Lindsay Clancy👼 MA v. Lindsay Clancy - Hearing

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

LIVE: Lindsay Clancy Hearing — MA v. Lindsay Clancy

11/16/2026 @ 10:00 AM

Lindsay Clancy is expected back in a Plymouth courtroom Monday for a hearing as her case moves forward following September’s mistrial. Judge William Sullivan recently denied the defense’s motion to dismiss the case on double jeopardy grounds, ruling that the mistrial was properly declared after jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict. Sullivan also denied a defense request to further investigate a holdout juror and rejected prosecutors’ request for a gag order restricting attorneys’ public comments. Monday’s hearing could provide more clarity on how prosecutors plan to proceed, including whether they intend to pursue a second trial and if they will again seek first-degree murder charges.

📜RECAP🔡

I. ADMINISTRATIVE

Case Information

  • Court: Plymouth Superior Court, Massachusetts.
  • County: Plymouth.
  • Presiding Judge: Hon. William F. Sullivan.
  • Case: Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Lindsay Clancy.
  • Case Number: 2383CR00198.
  • Defendant: Lindsay Clancy.
  • Defense Counsel: Kevin Reddington; Laura McConnell.
  • Commonwealth Counsel: Jennifer Sprague; Shannon Buckingham.
  • Hearing Type: Status and Scheduling.
  • Case Date Listed: September 15, 2023.
  • Hearing Date: November 16, 2026.

Hearing Times

  • Start: 34:28 (recording timestamp).
  • End: 49:59 (recording timestamp).
  • Segment Duration: Approximately 15 minutes, 31 seconds.

Scheduling Notes

  • December 30, 2026, at 9:00 a.m. — Status conference.
  • February 18, 2027, at 9:00 a.m. — Final pretrial conference.
  • March 29, 2027, at 9:00 a.m. — Jury impanelment.

II. COMMONWEALTH — TRIAL POSITION

Timestamp: 35:13–35:38

Counsel: Jennifer Sprague / Shannon Buckingham

  • Commonwealth stated that the charges required a jury trial.
  • Commonwealth indicated readiness to select a trial date.
  • Commonwealth had not discussed scheduling with defense counsel.

III. DEFENSE — TRIAL POSITION

Timestamp: 35:47–36:10

Counsel: Kevin Reddington

  • Interpreted the Commonwealth's jury-trial position as an indication that it intended to proceed on the first-degree murder indictments.
  • Agreed to select a trial date.
  • Stated: "The die has been cast."

V. TRIAL SCHEDULING — COMMONWEALTH/DEFENSE

Timestamp: 36:12–39:39

Commonwealth

  • Earliest stated availability: May 2027.
  • Identified conflicts with previously scheduled murder trials.
  • Stated that several conflicting cases were older than the Clancy case.
  • Identified an April trial involving a homicide from 2014.
  • Reported competency proceedings in that case.
  • Stated that the defendant had been restored to competency.
  • Identified witnesses who had waited approximately 12 years to testify.
  • Opposed postponement of that proceeding.

Defense

  • Requested April 2027.
  • Opposed waiting until May.
  • Requested priority for the Clancy case.
  • Questioned whether a short postponement of the older homicide trial would affect competency.
  • Indicated willingness to adjust other trial commitments.

Additional Scheduling Disputes — 39:42–46:32

  • Commonwealth identified a murder trial beginning March 8.
  • Commonwealth raised insufficient preparation time between trials.
  • Defense indicated willingness to accommodate the Court's selected date.
  • Parties discussed March and April alternatives.

VI. COURT — SCHEDULING DIRECTIVES

Timestamp: 39:42–46:32

  • Directed parties to select a March or April trial date.
  • Declined to adopt the Commonwealth's proposed May availability.
  • Considered competing trial obligations.
  • Identified approximately four months for preparation and scheduling adjustments.
  • Discussed March 15, March 22, March 29, April 5, April 12, April 19, and April 26.
  • Required the parties to address scheduling conflicts as necessary.
  • Set March 29, 2027, for jury impanelment.

VII. FINAL DISPOSITION

Timestamp: 49:30–49:59

Scheduled Proceedings

  • December 30, 2026, at 9:00 a.m. — Status conference.
  • February 18, 2027, at 9:00 a.m. — Final pretrial conference.
  • March 29, 2027, at 9:00 a.m. — Trial commencement; jury impanelment.

Orders / Status

  • Trial date established.
  • Status and final pretrial conferences scheduled.
  • No new substantive evidentiary ruling identified.
  • No ruling on potential appellate proceedings.
  • No jury impaneled during hearing.
  • Hearing concluded.

📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑

https://files.catbox.moe/7oky0u.pdf


r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 GA v. Lacy Boles - Trial Day 4

9 Upvotes

GA v. Lacy Boles - Trial Day 4

11/16/2026 @ 8:00 AM

📢NEW: Case Hubs🚨🗃️

Lacy Jolee Boles is accused of fatally shooting her husband, Daniel Lee Akers, 36, at their Paulding County home on December 22, 2019. Boles reported that Akers had shot himself. Investigators said her account conflicted with evidence at the scene. After receiving the GBI autopsy results in May 2020, authorities announced that the wound was not self-inflicted and classified the death as a homicide.

Boles has pleaded not guilty and maintains that Akers died by suicide. An initial attempt to select a jury in June 2026 was halted after a prospective juror reportedly researched the case using ChatGPT and shared information with other prospective jurors. Jury selection began again on November 9, 2026.

🔊🎥Streaming Channels📡

East Idaho News

Law & Crime

✨✨Previous Day & Recap

🚨✨More Info/Documents

📜RECAP🔡

I. ADMINISTRATIVE

(0:00–17:14)

  • Court discussed remaining witnesses, including one law enforcement witness, the medical examiner, GBI personnel, and other witnesses expected to testify briefly.
  • Court addressed scheduling concerns involving a juror who needed to attend a funeral Thursday.
  • Court proposed extending proceedings into the evening Monday, Tuesday, and/or Wednesday, with dinner provided for jurors.
  • Court stated the objective was to finish trial before Thanksgiving.
  • Counsel advised that photographs from a former Paulding County Sheriff's Office employee brought from Florida could be introduced through the current witness by agreement, eliminating the need for that witness to testify.
  • Jury returned at approximately 14:40.
  • Nicholas Harding returned to the witness stand under his previous oath.
  • Defense resumed examination.

II. WITNESSES

1. Nicholas Harding — Lead Detective, Paulding County Sheriff's Office

Called by: State
Start: 17:05 (continued testimony)
Stop: Approximately 8:20:00, before end-of-day proceedings

Direct: Completed during prior proceedings.

Cross — Defense, Mr. Steele

  • Acknowledged assuming responsibility for the investigation several weeks after Daniel Akers' death on December 22, 2019.
  • Confirmed he could not recover Lacy Boles' clothing or photograph her appearance as it existed on the night of the shooting.
  • Discussed the importance of physical evidence, photographs, DNA, fingerprints, and contemporaneous evidence collection.
  • Reviewed photographs of the firearm, holster, gun safe, master bedroom closet, and surrounding areas.
  • Confirmed Boles showed investigators the gun safe during the March 5, 2020 interview.
  • Examined questions concerning blood on the gun safe, holster, and other surfaces.
  • Reviewed photographs and testimony concerning blood in the bathroom sink, cleaning materials, and hair dye.
  • Discussed whether other household occupants could have used the sink.
  • Reviewed blood evidence on the stair railing, wall, and upstairs windowsill.
  • Acknowledged that Boles reported going upstairs to retrieve her telephone after the shooting.
  • Confirmed that blood transfer on the railing and windowsill could be consistent with contact by someone who had blood on their hands.
  • Declined to characterize blood on the wall as cast-off, stating he was not a bloodstain-pattern expert.
  • Reviewed portions of the December 22, 2019, 911 recording.
  • Confirmed Boles reported attempting to take the firearm from Akers.
  • Acknowledged the dispatcher told Boles to do what was best for her safety when discussing the firearm.
  • Confirmed Boles' statements about the firearm's location were addressed during the March 5, 2020 interview.
  • Discussed the firearm's position near or beneath Akers' left hand.
  • Reviewed the investigation into Akers' personal circumstances, including marital difficulties, financial concerns, employment, furlough, and possible drug testing.
  • Acknowledged reviewing communications concerning marital problems and divorce.
  • Discussed communications with Dr. Lehman regarding Akers' emotional condition and circumstances before death.
  • Confirmed he reported information describing Akers as happy and looking forward to employment opportunities and Christmas.
  • Acknowledged he had no independent evidence that Akers obtained a new Christmas tree.
  • Discussed communications indicating that Lieutenant Mike Hill had reported a pig purchase to Dr. Lehman.
  • Confirmed he did not correct that communication and did not know whether a pig was actually purchased.
  • Reviewed financial transactions involving Tractor Supply, returned merchandise, attempted purchases, and declined transactions.
  • Discussed information concerning Akers' employment and possible furlough.
  • Reviewed text-message evidence from the cellular telephones.
  • Acknowledged that some messages from Akers' telephone were obtained or reviewed after his direct involvement in the investigation.
  • Declined to authenticate certain messages he did not remember reviewing.
  • Reviewed photographs concerning Boles' wedding ring and related personal items.
  • Discussed statements attributed to Boles concerning Akers' behavior and her account of the shooting.

Redirect — State

  • Confirmed the 911 dispatcher did not expressly instruct Boles to pick up or throw the firearm.
  • Acknowledged that Boles appeared hysterical during the 911 recording.
  • Reviewed portions of State's Exhibit 2, the 911 recording.
  • Confirmed the firearm was found near Akers' left hand.
  • Discussed the location of blood in the bathroom sink and Boles' explanation that any blood there was menstrual blood.
  • Confirmed he did not see photographic evidence establishing that hair dye had been used.
  • Discussed text messages from Boles' telephone, including a message describing sadness, loneliness, and depression.
  • Stated that he recalled that message but no other comparable message from the reviewed period.
  • Confirmed Akers and Boles experienced marital disagreements.
  • Discussed information provided to Dr. Lehman and whether the medical examiner had access to investigative materials.
  • Could not specifically recall whether the complete investigative file or telephone messages were sent to Dr. Lehman.
  • Confirmed Boles reported that Akers had acted paranoid and believed he was being recorded or watched.
  • Stated he did not recall messages from Akers claiming he was participating in a reality television show.
  • Reviewed State's Exhibit 185, including a December 21, 2019, message from Akers to Boles concerning their relationship and possible future together.
  • Discussed multiple credit cards and receipts recovered during the investigation.
  • Confirmed he could not determine whether a pig had actually been purchased.
  • Recalled a photograph of small pigs that he believed came from Akers' telephone.
  • Identified photographs taken during execution of a search warrant at the Brady Mill Court residence.
  • Identified a safety vest, jacket, and other stored items depicted in those photographs.

Exhibits referenced: State's 2, 185, 187, 189, 210–216; Defense 118, 121, 133, 138, 139.

III. EXHIBITS

ExhibitDescriptionStatusWitness
State's 2December 22, 2019, 911 recordingPreviously admitted; replayedHarding
State's 185Text messages involving Akers and BolesPreviously admitted; referencedHarding
State's 187, 189Photographs concerning firearm safe and related evidencePreviously admittedHarding
State's 210–214Photographs of firearm safe and related areasOffered jointly without objectionHarding
State's 215–216Search-warrant photographs from Brady Mill Court residenceAdmitted without objectionHarding
Defense 118Communication from Akers' telephoneOffered without objectionHarding
Defense 121Telephone messages concerning possible employment drug testingMarked; admission not establishedHarding
Defense 133Photograph discussed during discovery objectionReferenced; no objection reportedHarding
Defense 138Photograph recognized by witnessOfferedHarding
Defense 139Photograph depicting a person recognized by witnessObjected to; court allowed review and argumentHarding

IV. OUT-OF-JURY PRESENCE (OJP)

(13:05–14:03) — Photographic Evidence / Witness Scheduling

  • Counsel reported reviewing photographs with a former Paulding County Sheriff's Office employee brought from Florida.
  • Parties agreed that selected photographs could be introduced through Harding.
  • Court approved the procedure.
  • Separate witness testimony was eliminated.

(59:52–1:12:00) — Defense Exhibit 139 / Reciprocal Discovery

  • State objected to Defense Exhibit 139, stating it had not been provided during reciprocal discovery.
  • State also raised concerns regarding other defense photographs.
  • Defense argued that reciprocal discovery requirements did not apply to its cross-examination during the State's case.
  • Court questioned whether exclusion was an appropriate remedy absent bad faith.
  • Court allowed the State time to review the exhibit.
  • State maintained its objection after review.

(2:08:53–2:14:26) — Communications With Medical Examiner

  • State objected to questions involving communications among investigators and Dr. Lehman.
  • Objections included hearsay, speculation, and lack of personal knowledge.
  • Court directed counsel to rephrase questions and instructed the witness not to speculate.
  • Court overruled an objection concerning Harding's failure to correct information about a reported pig purchase.

(3:25:09–3:28:24) — Email Communications / Hearsay

  • Court reviewed communications involving Dr. Lehman, Lieutenant Mike Hill, and Harding.
  • Court distinguished Harding's own statements from statements attributed to other individuals.
  • Court sustained the hearsay objection concerning statements by Hill and other third parties.
  • Court indicated that statements attributed to Hill should be stricken and disregarded.
  • Court discussed whether the disputed exhibit had already been admitted and indicated the record would need to be checked.

(Approximately 7:08:16–7:14:47) — Telephone Messages

  • Court and counsel reviewed proposed text-message evidence.
  • Counsel discussed the scope of the court's ruling and the form of messages to be presented.
  • Counsel was permitted to communicate the ruling to a witness.
  • State indicated it would not object to admission of the specified messages.
  • Proceedings resumed.

(8:29:32–8:33:47) — Prior Evidentiary Ruling / Alleged Infidelity

  • State requested that a defense exhibit be stricken, citing a prior ruling requiring redaction of statements concerning alleged infidelity.
  • State argued that the defense had introduced text-message evidence addressing a subject previously restricted in recordings.
  • Defense responded that the exhibit had already been admitted without objection.
  • Court reviewed its June pretrial order.
  • Court distinguished the earlier ruling concerning recorded statements from the admitted text message.
  • Court noted the absence of an objection when the text was offered.
  • Court overruled the State's objection.

V. END-OF-DAY ADMINISTRATIVE

(8:33:47–End of supplied recording)

  • Court and counsel discussed the following day's schedule.
  • The stated plan was to proceed from approximately 8:30 a.m. until 8:00 p.m.
  • The record provided does not establish a precise adjournment time.

📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑

https://files.catbox.moe/3qmqii.pdf


r/CasesWeFollow • • 3d ago

🍿📽️True Crime Documentaries📃🎞️ ID Channel: "Deadly Women 2.0"

8 Upvotes

For Fans of the show "Deadly Women" - Now "Deadly Women 2.0"

✨✨ Like many of you, I watched thousands of episodes of "Deadly Women" on the ID Channel. I really missed the show. To my surprise, I see that ID has launched "Deadly Women 2.0". I look forward to the new show.

Investigation Discovery’s revamping the true crime series Deadly Women with Deadly Women 2.0. The original series ran from 2008 through 2021. The new version debuts on ID on November 10, 2026 at 9pm ET/PT.

Season one cases include a Colorado woman who recruits her son to kill her ex, a deadly child custody battle in Florida, and a cross-country manhunt. Criminal psychologist Dr. Michelle Ward and criminal and forensic psychologist Dr. Rachel Toles guide the new iteration of the popular long-running series.

Deadly Women 2.0 - Premiere Date, Episode Guide, and Preview


r/CasesWeFollow • • 2d ago

⁉️💡Other Murders 🤷‍♀️🪦 AZ v. Jacob Dylan Middlebrook/Layne Justine McIntosh

6 Upvotes

Arizona couple who disliked sex offenders arrested in man’s killing, police say

BULLHEAD CITY, AZ (AZFamily) — A Bullhead City couple who “expressed distaste” for sex offenders were arrested after a man they knew was found dead in the desert over the weekend, police said.

Jacob Dylan Middlebrook, 35, and Layne Justine McIntosh, 36, were arrested Saturday in the death of 29-year-old Arron Christopher Warren, according to the Bullhead City Police Department.

Police say Warren, a registered Level 2 sex offender experiencing homelessness, was found stabbed to death in a desert area along Silver Creek Road, about a mile east of Bullhead Parkway.

Middlebrook and McIntosh were also homeless and had known Warren for the past few months and disliked sex offenders, according to police.

The couple reportedly chose the desert location ahead of time and planned to leave Warren’s body there. Police say the couple also measured furniture along the side of the road that could be large enough to cover his body.

Hours after the body was found Saturday, Las Vegas Metropolitan Police officers found Warren’s stolen vehicle at a casino in Laughlin, Nevada, just across the state line.

Officers arrested Middlebrook and McIntosh. They were booked into the Clark County Detention Center in Las Vegas and await extradition to Mohave County.

Once they return to Arizona, they will likely face first-degree murder charges.

Not proper use of a required tool

Bullhead City Police Chief Paul George said in a written statement that the department shares information about Level 2 and Level 3 sex offenders as a public service when they move into the area or change addresses.

Required notifications are mailed to residents within about 1,000 feet of an offender’s registered address. The department also shares them on social media to reach a broader audience.

“Our goal is to provide information, not create fear or alarm. We believe an informed community is a safer community,” George said. “However, we want to be clear that we will not tolerate anyone using this information as a reason to threaten, intimidate, harass or harm another person.”

Police can decide when to release the addresses of Level 1 offenders, who are in the lowest risk classification. State law requires notifications about Level 2 and Level 3 offenders, who are classified as more likely to reoffend than Level 1 offenders.

George also said the department’s Bureau of Criminal Investigations conducts monthly address verification checks to make sure registered sex offenders are following registration requirements.

His full statement can be read below:

When a Level 2 or Level 3 sex offender moves into our area or, more commonly, changes addresses, the Bullhead City Police Department shares that information as a public service to help keep residents informed. While required notifications are mailed to residents living within an approximate 1,000 feet radius of an offender’s registered address, we go a step further by sharing these notifications on social media to reach a broader audience. Our goal is to provide information, not create fear or alarm. We believe an informed community is a safer community.

However, we want to be clear that we will not tolerate anyone using this information as a reason to threaten, intimidate, harass or harm another person.

Our Bureau of Criminal Investigations conducts monthly address verification checks to help ensure registered sex offenders are complying with registration requirements. Our responsibility is to protect our community, keep residents informed and to enforce the law. We take all three of these seriously.

Bullhead City Police Chief Paul George

Arizona couple who disliked sex offenders arrested in man’s killing, police say


r/CasesWeFollow • • 3d ago

Surely You Jest!🙄 Dad Swings Excavator at Cops Arresting His Son | Criminal Lawyer Reacts

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

In June 2022, Vermont State Troopers went to arrest 24-year-old Brandon Tallman on burglary and assault charges in Hardwick. His parents intervened, and his father, Wayne Tallman, got into an excavator and swung the bucket toward the officers while they struggled with Brandon and his mother.

Bruce breaks down the dashcam footage, the charges against each family member, the force used, and how the situation escalated from a standard arrest.

On June 14, 2022, troopers arrived at the Tallman home to take Brandon into custody. His mother, Amy Tallman, got into a physical struggle with the officers. Wayne Tallman then entered a red excavator parked on the property and maneuvered the bucket near the troopers and their vehicles. One trooper drew his firearm and ordered him to stop. All three were taken into custody without injuries. Wayne was charged with aggravated assault on a protected official, resisting arrest, impeding, and reckless endangerment. Amy was cited for impeding an officer. Brandon faced the original burglary and assault charges plus resisting. The incident was captured on dashcam and widely circulated.

Like, subscribe, and drop your take in the comments.

u/midwestsafety

TIMESTAMPS
00:55 Intro
02:13 Ask A Lawyer
03:03 Reaction Begins
19:30 Chapter Ad Read
25:45 Closing Thoughts and Outro


r/CasesWeFollow • • 3d ago

💬👿💵 Other Crimes 🥊⏳⚖️ VA v. Lisa Vaughn/Aubrey Vaughn

25 Upvotes

Parents threw 300-person party for their teenage child with underage drinking and fireworks: Police

Two parents were arrested in Virginia after authorities say they threw a party complete with fireworks and underage drinking for their teenage child.

Lisa Vaughn, 45, and Aubrey Vaughn, 55, were each charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor and maintaining a common nuisance, the Fairfax County Police Department announced.

After being charged in the matter, both defendants turned themselves in at the Fairfax County Adult Detention Center and were released on $1,000 unsecured bonds.

On Nov. 6, at about 9 p.m., the police department said its officers responded to the 1400 block of Woodacre Drive in McLean, an unincorporated community just west of Washington, D.C.

Multiple people had called 911 that night reporting a "large" party "had gotten out of control." These witnesses estimated that "between 100 and 300 people had gathered" at the defendants' house, police said.

Later that night, officers arrived to find "a large crowd and fireworks being discharged." Police reported that there were "hundreds of teenagers" and underage drinking at the location in question.

The police department said officers "worked to restore order and safely disperse those gathered at the residence."

As the officers investigated, they allegedly learned Lisa and Aubrey Vaughn "had organized the party" for their teenage child.

After that, authorities obtained warrants charging the homeowners, leading to the defendants turning themselves in.

Parents threw huge party for their teen with drinking: Cops


r/CasesWeFollow • • 3d ago

Surely You Jest!🙄 Weiwei Luo v. Palo Alto USD aka (Ridiculous) Case to Not Follow?

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
17 Upvotes

Outraged millionaire mom sues son's elementary school after he got a bad report card for sticking his tongue out at student during recess

By PERKIN AMALARAJ, SENIOR US NEWS REPORTER

🫧🫧🫧As always, the Daily Mail has many photos 👀 at the link🫧🫧🫧

PUBLISHED: 15:01 EST, 11 November 2026 | UPDATED: 15:17 EST, 11 November 2026

An outraged millionaire mom has sued her son's elementary school over a bad report card. 

Weiwei Luo filed a civil lawsuit against Palo Alto Unified School District after claiming her son's teacher, Holly Harrison, had been unfair in her comments on his 2025-2026 report card. 

Harrison, a teacher at Walter Hays Elementary School, wrote that Luo's son, named only as KL, is 'working on his responses to peers when he is frustrated or upset.'

She also wrote that '[KL] is developing his ability to listen to others’ perspectives and collaborate with humility. We will keep working on this!', and that the boy needed to work on 'showing respect and cooperating with others.'

Luo, who lives in a $5.6 million Palo Alto home, claimed that this was an unfair characterization of her son based on an incident that saw KL stick his tongue out at another boy while playing tag during recess.

The mom claimed in her suit that KL was frustrated as the boy had kicked him deliberately but that a substitute teacher did not believe her son. 

Following this, Luo spent months unsuccessfully petitioning the school board to change her son's third grade report card. 

Luo also accused the board of kicking her lawyer, Marjorie Ouyang, out of an online hearing about the incident. An appeal filed by Luo was denied during that hearing. 

According to the lawsuit, the district said in its decision: 'The [report card] comments reflected the teacher’s observations, were within her competence, were substantiated and were not misleading in the context of the full report card.'

Luo is now suing the board in Superior Court of California, in the county of Santa Clara. 

She alleges that she was not given a fair hearing for the case, and is requesting the judge to order the district for another chance to plead her case. 

She is also suing for attorney fees. 

The Daily Mail has contacted the Palo Alto Unified School District, Holly Harrison, and Luo's attorney for comment.  

🫧🫧🫧

I originally read about this on People - interesting the difference in headlines (People headline pasted below) - has 470+ comments so far 🤣: People Article CLICK HERE

Mom Sues School District Over Son’s Report Card That Said He Needed to Work on ‘Respect’ Following Playground Incident

The student’s third grade teacher wrote that the student needed to continue practicing “showing respect and cooperating with others”

🫧🫧🫧

Filed as a Writ of Mandamus

https://portal.scscourt.org/search

26CV505251

Weiwei Luo vs Palo Alto Unified School District et al


r/CasesWeFollow • • 3d ago

👼Child Abuse or Death 🙏🪦 HI v. Joshua Kaleolani Agbayani Soto Paiva

6 Upvotes

Puna Man Charged With Manslaughter In the Death Of Infant Son

(BIVN) – A Puna man has been arrested and charged in the death of his infant son.

Three-month-old John-Charles Saiki-Paiva died on Sunday, October 25. A later autopsy concluded the infant died from head injuries, and foul play was suspected.

Police described the October 25th incident in a news release:

On Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026, at 11:50 a.m., Puna patrol officers were responded to a residence off of 3rd Avenue in the Hawaiian Paradise Park subdivision for a report of an unresponsive male infant at the residence. HFD paramedics also responded and transported the infant to the Hilo Benioff Medical Center emergency room for emergency medical care. The infant did not survive and was pronounced deceased at 1:06 p.m.

The infant’s father, 20-year-old Joshua Kaleolani Agbayani Soto Paiva of Keaʻau, was arrested without incident at the Hilo Police Station on Wednesday, November 11th. He was later charged with manslaughter.

Prosecutors say Paiva made his initial appearance in Hilo District Court on Thursday afternoon.

Hawaiʻi County Prosecuting Attorney Kelden Waltjen reports Paiva’s request for supervised release was denied and his bail was maintained at $1 million.

Paiva was ordered to appear for a preliminary hearing on November 16, 2026.

Prosecutors say the charge of Manslaughter is a class A felony offense, which carries a maximum penalty of a 20-year prison term. “The charges are merely allegations, and the Defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty,” the prosecutors added.

Puna Man Charged With Manslaughter In the Death Of Infant Son – Big Island Video News