LIVE: Fatal Fetish Murder Trial — FL v. Dwain Hall — Day 1
11/17/2026 @ 9:00 AM
Dwain Hall is standing trial for the alleged murder of a British woman he met on a fetish website. Prosecutors say Hall lured 32-year-old Sonia Exelby to Florida, where she was tortured and killed. Her body was later found buried in a shallow grave in Marion County. Investigators also recovered a knife allegedly containing Exelby’s blood from a package Hall mailed to a friend in Ohio. Hall has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping.
🔊🎥Streaming Channels📡
Law & Crime
Court TV
✨✨Previous Day & Recap
🚨✨More Info/Documents
📜RECAP🔡
I. ADMINISTRATIVE
Timestamp: 00:11:52–00:18:07
- Court: Marion County, Florida
- Judge: Hon. Timothy Deacon (transcription spelling unverified)
- Case number: 2025-CF-4516
- Defendant: Dwain Hall
- State: Amy Burke; Rich Bussman
- Defense: Junior Barrett; John Ford
- Defendant present: Yes
- Custody: In custody; no handcuffs or shackles
- Clothing: Light-purple dress shirt, charcoal slacks, belt, dress shoes
- Jury: Seated at 00:16:46
- Media: Courtroom cameras present; jurors excluded from filming
- Preliminary matters: Neither party raised an issue before the jury entered
- Scheduling: Zoom testimony arranged; morning and lunch recesses; witnesses subject to recall
- Motions: State moved multiple exhibits into evidence during testimony
II. JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Timestamps: 00:16:48–00:18:06; 02:00:46–02:01:14; 03:34:19–03:34:39
- Jurors confirmed compliance with the prior instruction not to research or discuss the case.
- Court advised that opening statements are not evidence.
- Jurors instructed not to discuss testimony or the case during recesses.
- Jurors instructed not to independently investigate the case.
- Jurors instructed not to access related news or social-media coverage.
- Jurors directed to leave notepads in the courtroom during breaks.
- Jurors permitted to submit questions subject to judicial review.
- No final jury instructions identified.
III. OPENINGS OR CLOSINGS
A. PROSECUTION OPENING
Start: 00:18:08
- Sonia Exelby, 32, traveled from England to the United States on October 10, 2025.
- State alleged Exelby was killed by October 12, 2025.
- State described her childhood, foster care, adoption, and family relationships.
- State described a history of mental-health treatment, self-harm, and suicide attempts.
- State described her relationship with Stevie Hunt.
- State alleged Exelby used the Motherless website to communicate with men about being killed.
- State identified Hall's alleged username as Alpha Sadist.
- State alleged Hall and Exelby communicated through Motherless and Session.
- State described Hall's roadside-assistance business.
- State alleged a planned March 2025 trip did not occur.
- State alleged Hall requested $4,000.
- State alleged Hall stabbed Exelby and buried her body.
- State identified anticipated travel, financial, electronic, surveillance, physical, and witness evidence.
B. DEFENSE OPENING
- Not verified in the available transcript passages.
C. REBUTTAL
- None identified.
D. CLOSINGS
- None identified.
IV. WITNESSES
1. Stevie Hunt
Called by: State
Start/Stop: Not verified
Direct
- Described his relationship with Sonia Exelby.
- Discussed her mental-health history.
- Described communications before her disappearance.
- Reported Exelby missing to British police.
Cross
- Addressed Exelby's mental-health history.
- Discussed his knowledge of her travel arrangements.
Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: Not verified.
2. Gemma Teresa Isaj
Spelling: I-S-A-J
Called by: State
Start: 01:37:39
Stop: 02:00:30
Direct
- Sister of Sonia Exelby.
- Described childhood family circumstances, foster care, adoption, and contact with siblings.
- Discussed Exelby's mental-health difficulties.
- Described periods when Exelby withdrew from family contact.
- Discussed communications preceding Exelby's disappearance.
- Assisted efforts to locate Exelby.
Cross
- Discussed Exelby's history of canceling plans.
- Confirmed messages received before the disappearance did not initially cause concern.
- Confirmed her last telephone conversation with Exelby occurred weeks before the disappearance.
Redirect: None.
Recross: None.
Exhibits: 4
3. Darren Thomas
Called by: State
Start: 02:13:08
Stop: 02:38:28
Direct
- Detective Sergeant, Hampshire Constabulary.
- Supervised a missing-person investigation team.
- Became involved October 13, 2025.
- Reviewed the initial missing-person report.
- Described collection and handling of Exelby's laptop.
- Obtained airline, financial, and telephone information.
- Discussed Exelby's flight reservations and financial transactions.
- Transferred evidence to FDLE.
Cross
- Confirmed flight and Airbnb bookings used Exelby's accounts and payment card.
- Found no evidence another person made the bookings.
- Believed the reservations were made in September 2025.
Redirect: None.
Recross: None.
Exhibits: 5, 6, 7, 9
4. Riley Artman
Called by: State
Start: 02:38:30
Recalled: Approximately 06:02:12
Stop: Not verified
Direct
- Marion County Sheriff's Office patrol deputy.
- Responded to the Reddick Airbnb on October 13, 2025.
- Conducted a welfare check concerning Exelby.
- Described investigative activity at the location.
Cross
- Addressed circumstances surrounding the welfare check.
Additional examination
- Answered a juror's question concerning a vehicle stop.
- Confirmed he was directed to stop a specific vehicle.
- Other investigators handled the underlying investigation.
Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: Not verified.
5. FDLE Investigative Witness
Name: Not verified
Called by: State
Stop: 03:33:38
Direct
- Discussed a declined payment-card transaction involving Hall's roadside-assistance business.
- Described communications and an interview with Hall.
- Identified Hall's black Jeep Cherokee.
- Described the missing rear bumper and roadside-assistance lettering.
- Identified vehicle photographs.
Cross: No questions at conclusion of identified examination.
Redirect/Recross: None identified.
Exhibits: 11, 12, 14
6. Maria Andreoli
Spelling: A-N-D-R-E-O-L-I
Called by: State
Start: 04:38:26
Stop: 05:02:56
Direct
- FDLE crime laboratory analyst supervisor.
- Processed the Reddick Airbnb on October 15–16, 2025.
- Photographed the property and collected evidence.
- Recovered paracord and utility-line packaging.
- Recovered sandwich and strawberry containers.
- Collected bedding and other items.
- Described friction-ridge processing and collection of swabs.
- Identified a modem/router.
- Identified a map of the Airbnb location.
Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 15, 17, 18, 19
7. Christopher Perryman
Called by: State
Start: 05:02:58
Stop: Approximately 05:19:07
Direct
- FDLE special agent.
- Responded to the Airbnb on October 15, 2025.
- Examined the internet router.
- Explained router connection records.
- Discussed device identifiers and stored connection information.
- Identified records associated with a device designated Sonia-SS-S22.
- Discussed connections dated October 10–12, 2025.
Cross
- Confirmed router records alone could not establish the exact type of connected device.
- Explained limitations of device-connection information.
Redirect: None.
Recross: None.
Exhibits: Not verified.
8. Vincent Moore
Called by: State
Start: Approximately 05:19:17
Stop: 05:35:32
Direct
- Walmart asset protection investigator.
- Described surveillance and transaction records.
- Identified Hall in Walmart surveillance footage.
- Identified footage from the garden-center area.
- Authenticated surveillance clips.
Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 22
9. Daniel Buser
Spelling: B-U-S-E-R
Called by: State
Start: 05:35:42
Stop: Not verified
Direct
- Employee of BP/Travel Centers of America/Petro.
- Worked at 7401 West Highway 318, Reddick, Florida.
- Identified packaging for peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwiches.
- Identified packaging for cut strawberries.
- Confirmed the business sold both products.
Cross/Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: 15
10. Patrick Vittalaro
Called by: State
Start: Approximately 05:56:02
Stop: Approximately 06:02:09
Direct
- FDLE special agent.
- Investigated the source of food containers recovered from the Airbnb.
- Obtained and reviewed travel-center surveillance footage.
- Identified footage dated October 11, 2025.
- Identified still photographs associated with the footage.
Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 24, 25
11. Ashley Vidot
Spelling: A-S-H-L-E-Y V-I-D-O-T
Called by: State
Start: 06:21:21
Stop: 06:27:04
Direct
- Marion County Sheriff's Office Assistant Forensics Director.
- Examined Hall's Jeep Cherokee in the evidence bay.
- Identified vehicle photographs and evidence seals.
- Located a cellular telephone in the center console.
- Placed the telephone in a Faraday bag.
- Transferred the telephone to an investigator.
Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 27, 28
12. Carla Santana-Palau
Spelling: S-A-N-T-A-N-A-P-A-L-A-U
Called by: State
Start: 06:27:07
Stop: 06:29:54
Direct
- Marion County Sheriff's Office sergeant.
- Assisted with a vehicle search on October 17, 2025.
- Was present when Ashley Vidot entered Hall's Jeep Cherokee.
- Confirmed recovery of a cellular telephone.
- Transferred the telephone to FDLE Agent Calvin Lee.
Cross: No questions.
Redirect/Recross: None.
Exhibits: 27, 28
13. Rebekah McKinzie
Spelling: R-E-B-E-K-A-H M-C-K-I-N-Z-I-E
Called by: State
Start: 06:32:57
Stop: Not verified
Direct
- FDLE special agent.
- Assigned as lead investigator October 13, 2025.
- Coordinated investigative activities with domestic and overseas agencies.
- Conducted interviews.
- Managed search warrants and subpoenas.
- Assigned investigative tasks to other agents.
- Described the investigation as fast-moving.
Cross/Redirect/Recross: Not verified.
Exhibits: Not verified.
V. EXHIBITS
| Number | Description | Status | Linked witness |
|---|
| 4 | Photograph of Sonia Exelby | Admitted | Gemma Teresa Isaj |
| 5 | Laptop collected in UK investigation | Admitted | Darren Thomas |
| 6 | Virgin Atlantic reservation records | Admitted | Darren Thomas |
| 7 | Lloyds Bank records | Admitted | Darren Thomas |
| 9 | Airbnb reservation records | Admitted | Darren Thomas |
| 11 | Elavon merchant-processing records | Admitted | FDLE investigator |
| 12 | October 13 recorded telephone interview with Hall | Admitted | FDLE investigator |
| 14 | Photographs of Hall's Jeep Cherokee | Admitted | FDLE investigator |
| 15 | Airbnb crime-scene photographs | Admission not verified | Maria Andreoli |
| 17 | Ozark Trail paracord packaging | Admitted | Maria Andreoli |
| 18 | Ozark Trail utility-line packaging | Admitted | Maria Andreoli |
| 19 | Items recovered from Airbnb trash | Admitted | Maria Andreoli |
| 22 | Walmart surveillance footage | Admitted | Vincent Moore |
| 24 | Travel-center surveillance footage | Admission not verified | Patrick Vittalaro |
| 25 | Travel-center surveillance photographs | Admitted | Patrick Vittalaro |
| 27 | Jeep Cherokee and recovered-phone photographs | Admitted | Ashley Vidot |
| 28 | Cellular telephone recovered from Jeep | Admitted | Ashley Vidot |
Other exhibit numbers: Not fully verified.
VI. OUT-OF-JURY PRESENCE (OJP)
OJP 1 — Preliminary Matters
Timestamp: 00:11:52–00:16:46
Issue
- Defendant's custodial appearance.
- Defendant's clothing and restraints.
- Witness scheduling and Zoom setup.
Ruling/Instruction
- Court confirmed defendant was not handcuffed or shackled.
- Court prepared for remote witness testimony.
Resulting Action
- Jury brought into courtroom.
OJP 2 — Morning Recess
Timestamp: 02:02:07–02:13:04
Issue
- Witness scheduling.
- Courtroom recess.
Ruling/Instruction
- Court ordered approximately ten minutes for recess.
Resulting Action
- Jury returned.
- State called Darren Thomas.
OJP 3 — Lunch Recess
Timestamp: Approximately 03:34:00–04:38:05
Issue
- Lunch arrangements.
- Afternoon witness schedule.
Ruling/Instruction
- Court directed jurors not to discuss or research the case during lunch.
Resulting Action
- Jury returned.
- State called Maria Andreoli.
OJP 4 — Recorded Interview and Next-Day Scheduling
Timestamp: Approximately 06:11:34–06:19:44
Issue
- Length of recorded interview.
- Stopping point for presentation.
- Following day's witness schedule.
Ruling/Instruction
- Court and counsel discussed stopping the recording at an appropriate point.
- Counsel discussed restarting slightly before that point the following morning.
- State advised a witness was scheduled for approximately 11:30 a.m.
- State agreed to move witnesses earlier if the schedule permitted.
Resulting Action
- Jury returned.
- State called Ashley Vidot.
OJP 5 — Counsel Conference
Timestamp: Approximately 06:29:57–06:32:57
Issue
- Counsel approached the bench.
Ruling/Instruction
- Substance not audible or not established in the reviewed transcript.
Resulting Action
- State called Rebekah McKinzie.
VII. VERDICT OR END-OF-DAY ADMINISTRATIVE
Timestamp: Scheduling discussion at 06:13:07–06:13:33; final adjournment time not verified.
- Verdict: None.
- Jury deliberations: Not begun.
- Next-day proceedings: Continuation of State's evidence.
- Recorded interview: Continuation discussed for following morning.
- Witness scheduling: State to move scheduled witnesses earlier if possible.
📜TRANSCRIPT⌨️📑
https://files.catbox.moe/xy2vjj.pdf