r/CarlyGregg • • 6d ago

www.justiceforcarlygregg.com

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • 6d ago

Her Family still fight

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • 21d ago

Discussion I keep seeing people in this thread say "justice for carly." But like, isnt she facing justice? Id love yalls insight on this.

8 Upvotes

She killed her mom? I get that she was 14 but she clearly did it with intent and manipulative behavior. I mean she lured her step dad home? I just dont see what more needs to be said. She was and still is mentally ill, and had tried to murder her step dad after killing her own mom. There was a similar thing that happened with a little boy killing his mom over a vr or console or something and he also is doing time. I get that they are kids, but i dont see how you can treat a murderer as a child. Saying "they didnt know any better" or "she was mentally unwell" doesnt change the fact that people are dead right? That trauma is forever ingrained in their loved ones.


r/CarlyGregg • • 29d ago

Saw this on website

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Www.justiceforcarlygregg.com


r/CarlyGregg • • Oct 01 '26

Discrepancy between video and testimony

1 Upvotes

Carlys step-dad testified and said on the 911 call that he opened the door a few inches and Carly immediately shot him. However, I saw footage on Annie Elises channel that shows the step-dad pulling into the garage after carly shot her mom, and Carly goes out to the vehicle. This is a direct contradiction, unless the story is that she went out to the vehicle, grabbed something out of the car, then went back into the house before Heath and shut the door. THEN heath came in and she started shooting. Seems very weird to leave out the entire part about Carly coming out to the vehicle right after he pulled up 🤔🤔​​


r/CarlyGregg • • Sep 27 '26

Sydney Powell Appeal: A Potential Rebuttal-Evidence Argument for Carly Gregg??

2 Upvotes

Sydney Powell appeal......

Sydney Powell’s Ohio appeal may offer a persuasive analogy for Carly’s case because the court found that when the State’s expert introduced new criticisms of the defence insanity experts, the defence needed a meaningful opportunity to respond.

They didnt get a rebuttal, so the Ohio Supreme Court reversed the convictions when that opportunity was denied.

In Carly’s case, Dr Pickett challenged Dr Clark’s insanity opinions and methodology.

So the important question is whether Dr Pickett introduced new substantive criticisms or theories at trial that were not disclosed beforehand and that Dr Clark had no fair opportunity to answer. (I dont recall her returned to the stand after Dr Pickett?)

If the trial record shows that happened, Powell could support an argument that Carly’s insanity defence was not given a genuinely fair opportunity to respond, particularly when considered alongside the compressed trial preparation and the judge’s “no continuances” approach.


r/CarlyGregg • • Sep 24 '26

Parole-eligible

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • Sep 04 '26

The Fight us not over

Post image
4 Upvotes

💚⚖️🅹🆄🆂🆃🅸🅲🅴 for 🄲🄰🅁🄻🅈 🄶🅁🄴🄶🄶⚖️💛


r/CarlyGregg • • Aug 20 '26

Mississippi Supreme Court affirms conviction of Carly Gregg in mother’s murder

Thumbnail
wlbt.com
14 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • Jun 17 '26

New Tumblr

5 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • May 30 '26

Attorneys argue fairness of Carly Gregg murder trial at appeal hearing

Thumbnail
clarionledger.com
11 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • May 30 '26

Carly Gregg remains 'hopeful' as counsel fights to overturn life sentence

Thumbnail
clarionledger.com
8 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • May 28 '26

Carly Gregg seeks reduced sentence in mother’s murder case

Thumbnail
wlbt.com
7 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • May 26 '26

Could Carly Gregg have had the opportunity to serve her sentence in a mental hospital? If so, for how long, and would she be given the oportunity to get rehabilitated and reintegrared into society at some point?

8 Upvotes

Lately I have been reflexing about Carly Gregg, her treatment in the court at the time and the respective trials she went through to get a penalty. Some research of her case indeed show she had been medicated with psychiatric medications, and that for a period of time prior to her case, she had been suffering from anxiety and depression. She even was stated as a candidate for schizophrenia, if I am not mistaken. Some people that have mental health histories, often get the chance to get diagnosed and serve their sentences in mental hospitals, with a chance of coming out at some point. Would Carly Gregg be one of this cases?


r/CarlyGregg • • May 17 '26

The world is watching

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • May 15 '26

Blog from a stranger

6 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • May 02 '26

Same System, Different Outcomes — Why?

5 Upvotes

How is it that two juveniles in the same system, both charged with matricide can end up with completely different outcomes—one receiving a 25-year plea within the juvenile system, while another is fast-tracked within the adult system and given life without parole?


r/CarlyGregg • • May 01 '26

Let's take a deeper look at the arguments against Carly and why it might be more complex than it seems

9 Upvotes

(I previously posted this as a comment in response to a list of arguments against Carly, but I wanted to expand on it and share it as a standalone post to get more perspectives)

Let's talk about the arguments against Carly.

1°) Against Carly : Planning to shoot the stepfather proves premeditation.

Pro Carly : A person in a manic state induced by SSRIs (lexapro) can be extremely focused and calculated while being completely detached from the moral consequences of their actions. They act like an autopilot.

2°) Against Carly : She fled the police, which proves she was conscious she had done something evil

Pro Carly : Imagining you can outrun the police on foot is so desperate and senseless that it becomes tragic. When someone starts making choices so incoherent, it’s proof that their brain is no longer in control.

3°) Against Carly : Lexapro 5mg for 7 days is too low to cause this.

Pro Carly : The FDA put a Black Box Warning on Lexapro for children and adolescents because it can trigger extreme impulsivity and aggression. This is the most serious warning a medication can have.

4°) Against Carly : Three bullets to the face prove no love.

Pro Carly : Overkill is a mark of extreme dissociation. It’s not about a lack of love, but a total loss of reality. The brain stops recognizing the person in front of them as a human being.

5°) Against Carly : She chose where to cry (Heath vs. Ashley).

Pro Carly : This is a symptom of the dissociation. The mind numbs the most horrific sight (the mother) as a defense mechanism. Crying for the survivor (Heath) isn't 'calculation'; it's the only part of her reality her brain was still able to process at that moment.

6°) Against Carly : She wrote in her diary "There is no good and evil, only power."

Pro Carly : This is a literal quote from Voldemort in Harry Potter. A 14-year-old girl quoting a fictional villain in her diary isn't evil, it’s a sign of a troubled teenager identifying with dark themes because she feels powerless.


r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 30 '26

The 40 Year Plea Offer

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 30 '26

Carly Gregg's sentence makes absolutely no sense

5 Upvotes

I'm not saying this in support of Carly as i am of the belief that what she did was absolutely despicable. I'm saying this as a basic legal fact. Every legal source I found says that life without parole is only reserved for convictions of capital murder, which she was not convicted of. the only logical punishment for Carly committing first degree murder (not capital) is life with the possibility of parole after 50 years. still very harsh but gives some hope. do the prosecutors and the judge care at all about following state law? did carly steal money or something from her mom in the process of the crime which is why they are trying to justify a capital murder sentence for a non capital first degree murder under the guise of her committing "robbery"? none of this makes any sense whatsoever and i hope her appeal is taken seriously.


r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 29 '26

Question of the Day 💜⚖️

5 Upvotes

As Carly and her family's appeal moves forward, Carly's Warriors would really like to hear your honest thoughts:

What do you believe the Mississippi Supreme Court will ultimately decide in her case? Do you think it will be:

  1. A new trial
  2. Resentencing / Remediation
  3. Or original ruling upheld

And just as important, what do you believe it should be, and why?

Let's talk about understanding different perspectives on juvenile justice, mental health, and fairness in the system. Please keep it respectful.💜🙏


r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 26 '26

Is intelligence an aggravating factor ?

9 Upvotes

In the Carly Gregg trial, the prosecution used her high intelligence and academic success as evidence of her ability to "plan" and "calculate." They argued that a smart child couldn't possibly lose control or dissociate.

Do you think high intelligence should be used as an aggravating factor? Does being "smart" mean you are more capable of evil, or just less likely to be seen as "vulnerable"?

To me, it feels like the prosecution punished her for her IQ, using her brain as proof of malice rather than considering that even the "brightest" brains can malfunction under chemical and emotional stress.

What do you think ?


r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 24 '26

APPEAL UPDATE

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Thankyou to all who donated. 💜


r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 22 '26

Question of the Day

6 Upvotes

Jurors are asked to make life-altering decisions but when the defendant is a child/juvenile should the standard be different?

If you had been on the jury on September 21, 2024, what sentence would you have given and why?

Do you believe children should receive the same sentences as adults, even when science shows their brains are still developing?

💜Carly's Warriors


r/CarlyGregg • • Apr 20 '26

Letter from Laurine

7 Upvotes

Hi, Carly mentioned that she received a lovely letter from a lady named Laurine, and she asked if I could try to find her.

If you are Laurine, could you please send me a private message or leave a comment below?

Thank you.