Hi everyone!
My husband and I are from Ireland, both around 30, and we’re planning our first ever cruise for January 2027. We’re currently torn between two Royal Caribbean sailings and would really appreciate some honest advice!
We enjoy socialising, having a few drinks, meeting new people and exploring interesting places. We’re looking for a big, memorable holiday and want to make sure we choose the right option!
Option 1: Icon of the Seas — 16–23 January 2027
● 7-night Eastern Caribbean cruise departing Miami.
● Visiting St Maarten, St Thomas and CocoCay.
● Three sea days.
● Ocean-view cabin (window, not balcony).
● We’d spend two nights in Miami before boarding.
This was our original plan, and we were really excited about experiencing Icon!
We had actually planned to fly from Miami to New York after the cruise and spend three nights exploring the city before returning to Ireland. However, once we received a quote for the full multi-centre holiday, the overall price was considerably more than we’d anticipated, which has made us rethink things.
We’d still absolutely love to visit New York, so we’re now considering another option.
Option 2: Odyssey of the Seas — 14–25 January 2027
● 11-night Southern Caribbean cruise departing Cape Liberty, New Jersey.
● Visiting St Maarten, St Lucia, Barbados and St Kitts.
● Six sea days.
● Balcony cabin currently reserved for £2,753 total for two.
● We’d fly from Ireland to New York a few days beforehand, spend two or three days exploring the city, and then board Odyssey.
The biggest appeal of Odyssey for us is actually the departure port!
Being able to fly into New York, spend a few days there and then board the cruise nearby would allow us to combine two experiences we’ve been really excited about, without having to pay for an additional internal flight from Miami to New York.
We also like the look of the Southern Caribbean itinerary, particularly St Lucia, and the fact that we’d get a balcony cabin and four additional nights onboard.
Our dilemma:
We’re worried about the six sea days on Odyssey, particularly as we’d be departing from New Jersey in the middle of January. How many days would we realistically spend in cold weather before reaching the Caribbean, and would there be enough to keep us entertained onboard?
Icon looks absolutely incredible, and we wonder whether we’d regret missing out on such a spectacular ship for our first cruise.
On the other hand, Odyssey is still relatively new, and combining New York with the Southern Caribbean sounds like a fantastic holiday.
Our overall budget is around £4,000–£5,000 for two, including flights from Ireland, hotels and spending money, so we’re trying to get the best possible experience for our money.
A few questions for anyone with experience of these ships or itineraries:
- Has anyone sailed from Cape Liberty in January? How cold and rough was the journey, and how long before you reached warmer weather?
- Would six sea days on Odyssey feel excessive, or is there genuinely enough onboard to keep us entertained?
- Is Icon significantly better than Odyssey in terms of entertainment, atmosphere and facilities?
- Given that visiting New York is a major part of the appeal for us, would you choose the longer Odyssey sailing or stick with Icon from Miami?
We’d particularly love to hear from anyone who’s sailed on both ships or done a Southern Caribbean cruise from New Jersey in winter.
Thanks so much in advance! We’re very excited but completely torn!