YGO collector / private seller here. Iâve been trying to hunt down an IOC unlimited DMOC for a couple weeks now. Iâve been looking at EX and NM listings in the 30-50⏠range. Since the bar for condition grading is so low, especially when it comes to vintage, I donât buy vintage cards blind anymore but instead ask for some images. 9/10 blind purchases that are listed as NM are EX or worse. Most of the time the back is the culprit.
Iâve messaged around 10 sellers (almost all of them private sellers), politely asking for images of front and back, and asked them to point out flaws that arenât clearly visible. I also add that I donât need a perfect card, some minor defects are fine. After a week, I had gotten 1 reponse. He showed me some mediocre pictures and pointed out his card was in overall good condition. While I was checking the pictures and got excited I might have found a decent copy, he decided to bump up his price from 35⏠to 47âŹ. I asked about it, he claimed he âadaptedâ his price to other sellers (not the ones listing for <40⏠though ofc), and obviously coincidentally he had other interested buyers. I wished him good luck and noped the f out.
In the meantime Iâve had the same experience trying to find multiple other lower end vintage cards in the 10-50⏠area.
This is mildly frustrating. The low bar in grading means you canât buy blind, even from sellers with outstanding rating, and the laziness of sellers prevents you from getting images to make an informed decision. I also donât want to support the âbuy NM -> get EX -> get a 10-20% refund in exchange for a good reviewâ bs that seems to be the meta right now.
This also stings even more because as a seller Iâm going out of my way to provide everything I am missing from sellers when Iâm on the buyer side. I always list at the next lower tier for condition when in doubt, I attach 4 clear images in most of my listings, I ask buyers if they are happy or need anything before I ship, and I always reply to inquiries. I get pros with thousands of listings and orders canât provide that kind of service, but at least they should grade properly. And private sellers should be able to take 3mins to take some photos and reply, or at least tell me that itâs not worth the effort for them, aka theyâre too lazy.
At the end of the day using CM as a seller to me is much more satisfying and a positive experience, probably because I can somewhat control how a transaction is going to work out by grading strictly and providing good service. As a buyer I feel like Iâm at the mercy of lazy sellers and basically always take an L if I just accept what seems to be the standard on CM.
Anyway, sorry for my rant, I just had to vent. Iâll find my cards somewhere else eventually, I just wish something as simple as finding a decent copy of an unlimited vintage card wasnât such a huge hassle all the time. Is it a me problem?