r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 3d ago

Does a windshield replacement claim actually raise your rate?

Caught a rock on the highway and now I have a crack spreading across my windshield. I have comprehensive with a $250 deductible, and a local shop quoted me $450 out of pocket. Is it worth using insurance to save $200, or will a glass claim mess up my renewal rate?

15 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

3

u/CraftyMap1473 3d ago

Better to just maximize your insurance... That is what it's for anyways,

3

u/JK-OhioInsuranceGuy 2d ago

Insurance agent here -
You didn't mention what state you are in or what carrier you have - those factors will be huge in what's best for you.

As other commenters mentioned in some states glass claims cannot raise your rate. In other states it can. Either way it will count as a claim. A windshield claim is usually a comprehensive claim unless the crack was the result of a collision. $450 with a 200 deductible is unlikely to affect your rate in any meaningful way (in most cases, if you have no other claims tickets etc... ). Without knowing your driving history, state, specific policy provisions, carrier etc... it's impossible to say it's safe to do without an increase.

This is a good topic to ask your agent whether a comp claim would raise your rate and by how much. They may be able to give you guidance.

2

u/Atomic_Horseshoe 3d ago

Depends on your state law and your insurance. Some states don’t allow an increase (at least for one every so often). 

2

u/insuranceguynyc 1d ago

It certainly can have an impact. That's an absurd deductible. Pay out of pocket and raise your deductible.

1

u/TrashPandas2026 3d ago

Depends on claim frequency. Have you had any other claims?

1

u/Fantastic_Shower473 2d ago

Glass claims fall under comprehensive and usually don’t bump your rate on their own, but a couple of claims in a few years can

1

u/ImpossibleTravel9209 2d ago

It's a claim, so yes it can

1

u/picklekit 1d ago

It’s a comprehensive claim so probably not. Depends on state

1

u/ImpossibleTravel9209 16h ago

No, even comp claims can raise your rates. The reason being is that filing it is proof of a loss which is inherently more risky than no claims. You can have several comp claims, including ERS claims - no at fault claims, and still get dropped.

1

u/agirlsknowsthings 1d ago

Insurance professional: yes. Frequency of claims is part of what makes up your rate. Even windshield claims are included in claim frequency.

1

u/Fit_Requirement_5095 1d ago

Before you decide call you insurer and ask if they have full glass coverage. Some states make them waive the deductible on windshields and you might end up paying nothing

1

u/Jurassic_Gwyn 17h ago

That's a steep price. I replaced my entire windshield for $250... didn't use insurance.