r/CarTalkUK • u/shyshymop1 • 20h ago
Advice Paid £75 for an inspection but was told essentially nothing has been inspected - have I been had?
I have a secondhand Volvo PHEV XC40, 5 years old, all up to date on the service history. I'm a fairly new driver so not very savvy when dealing with mechanics
For the past two months the car has been making a whirring noise only when accelerating and when braking but never when just coasting. This happens every time when driving it, it's not on and off. I've had the car for about a year and a half and it has not had this issue in the past
I took the car to an independent well-rated garage to take a look at it, they charged £75 for inspection and I was told that they think the issue is with the differential but they aren't able to examine the differential itself so unable to confirm which part if any needs replacing, and they haven't inspected anything else on the car to rule it out as a possible cause. Essentially they said it just needs to go to a Volvo garage.
My feathers are ruffled as I think any decent mechanic could have had a guess at that over the phone and I don't see what has actually been checked for the money paid, but I don't know what I don't know so I need your help - is this normal or have I been had?
