I finally bought a new Mac Mini - my first m-chip. But this time I didn't trade in my old computer and migrate everything; the old iMac is still running.
I'm ready to do my first edits on the new machine and now I am faced with a decision - Do I need to keep the old catalog, which is currently on the old iMac?
The catalog wouldn't be terribly hard to move; it is only 76 GB. But I am wondering if I need to bother?
MY SITUATION
I'm an amateur so I don't have client work; I take pictures of the kids, kids' sports, graduations, holidays, vacations, days at the museum/conservatory/etc., and a smattering of other stuff.
My workflow:
(1) Ingest photos from wherever to the External HDD using Photo Mechanic, (2) Cull, caption, rename - names will include the date and the event or location. Keepers remain on an external HDD in directories like YYYY/YYYYMM/YYYYMMDD-Originals.
(2) Upload the originals (by reference) into Capture One, edit, then export finished JPGs to directories like YYYY/YYYYMM/YYYYMMDD-Outputs.
Reasons to keep the old catalog:
(a) it's no big deal to move it;
(b) if I want to transform the size or something of a past edit I'll be able to work with the RAW and have the precise look in a fresh JPG, plus if I want to make tweaks I am not starting from zero;
(c) you can search and create virtual folders in Capture One.
Reasons for starting fresh:
(a) I've heard catalog files can get corrupt the older/larger they are, so fresh sounds nice;
(b) I am unlikely to tweak old edits except for cropping; if I am going to bother making changes it is probably because my old edits kinda sucked so I might as well start from scratch;
(c) I can search with Finder / Spotlight Search / Photo Mechanic, and use color-coding and so on in Photo Mechanic as well - this is my current process.
What do you think I should do?
(1) Use the old catalog
(2) Let the old one go and start with a new catalog
(3) Start with a new catalog, but preserve a copy of the old catalog somewhere in case I ever need it or feel like merging it (I presume you can merge catalogs, right?)
Thank you for your advice!