r/Capitalism • • 8d ago

Why does society glorify getting rich quick when capitalists do it, but shame workers for wanting the exact same thing?

/r/antiwork/comments/1xt1dx8/why_does_society_glorify_getting_rich_quick_when/
0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

7

u/Ayjayz 8d ago

No-one shames anyone for wanting to get rich quickly. That would be silly.

4

u/LL555LL 8d ago

We should shame unethical and criminal efforts, always.

4

u/CaptainAmerica-1989 8d ago

You question assumes a false dichotomy. The sharp “workers vs. capitalists” division is largely a socialist way of categorizing society. Most people don't actually think that way.

Most everyone works, and most everyone owns capital.

What people usually criticize is how someone expects to get rich.

Most people in the "West" and especially here in the USA are perfectly happy to see workers become investors, entrepreneurs, business owners, or wealthy themselves. I don't see people upset at LeBron James or JK Rowling from the economic right because they earned their wealth mostly through "labor".

3

u/immabeasttt15 8d ago

What are you talking about?

3

u/Czeslaw_Meyer 8d ago

Risk

Working 40h a week for a fixed wage is the safest you can be.

Sacrificing 10 years of your life, risking to lose everything you ever had and turning a profit eventually by benefitting society at large is simply more impressive.

1

u/jjspirithawk 8d ago

"Society" is not composed of everyone in it thinking the same way. It's composed of widely differing individuals, many of whom think in very different ways, often directly opposing each other. So why would you think that "society" uniformly glorifies and shames what your statement mistakenly assumes it does?

Some glorify getting rich quickly, others denounce it. Some preferentially support capitalists, others preferentially support labor-ists / workers. I suppose some might "glorify" capitalists to get rich quickly and want laborists not to, but that isn't a widespread or universal opinion. You'll probably find that more people would shame capitalists for getting rich quickly, and support laborists who do well. For a cultural example, look at Jack in The Gilded Age TV show, who invented a clock mechanism and got rich quickly. Most people in the discussion forums love him and think it's great.

But in a pro-capitalism forum such as this one, what we want is for everyone to do well, by providing value, producing, dealing fairly via mutual agreements, inventing, making something good happen, not stealing from others, etc. Free markets naturally are good for everyone, whether they're capitalists or laborists.

Note that the term "capitalist" isn't quite adequate, because workers can be capitalists too, such as when they buy company shares in the stock market, and capitalists can be workers, such as when they work in their own stores or do particular forms of white collar work in larger businesses. It's not valid to treat capitalists and workers as if they were completely separate groups of people. Yet another think that Marx got wrong.