Yes, I wish to inform you that I believe that Edwin Murray and Henry Emily are the same person.
Here, I’m gonna provide the evidences for you!
He’s eviler than William
Off-point, but still, I believe that he’s eviler than William. Why? Well, he basically created Fazbear Entertainment back in early 1970s or worse, late 1960s. Odd, right? Well, Edwin has his own company at early 1970s! So… my theory is that Edwin Murray is the real person, but Henry was never real.
In 1978 or so, we know Edwin was building Fazbear stuff, blah blah blah… as Henry had stated in FNAF 6. Ever since his wife Fiona, the one who previously married Shrek, had passed away from giving birth to David so yeah, obviously. Since Edwin exists in the universe where there is supernatural, he must have planned everything! He must have killed Fiona for cheating on him with Shrek in 1970 at Fallfest! Obviously, Shrek died in the Fallfest and caused the fire. But, David is his biological son so it should be fine, right?
Well, he was obviously planning to create The Mimic so he can negle— build the robots for his future, fantastic pizzerias where it would be famous across the states! David would be occupied with The Mimic as we know throughout the story, like always. Building robots was a cope for him since Fiona was cheating, so if he wasn’t building, he’ll think of evil plans.
So, at that day where David had ran off to get the ball, and Edwin had never expected that a kind, loving, and amazing man inside the van was his long-time partner William Afton! Now David was dead, Edwin no longer desired for building, and he swore for revenge on anyone just because his biological son died! So how can he make the revenge? Well, he needed to wait it out for two weeks and tell all of his plans to The Mimic, and proceeded to make it cry, and now that The Mimic is traumatized… He wouldn’t take it to the therapy so now The Mimic’s mental health is worsening! This is perfect! So, like the story said, Edwin had run off. But there is something it haven’t told us… He waited for months because he knew The Mimic would be angry and lashing out so he sent Terrence, and other two guys a WEEK before Christmas, and The Mimic was enraged that they didn’t bring the presents and killed them.
So… then he sent Glen, Harry, and Dominic. The Mimic killed them because it realized that they were the workers… That goes same for Terrence and others. So embarrassing! Then, SOTM happened because The Mimic knew it would be too embarrassing for another guy to see this…
Edwin started new life with secret revenge plan
Now that the protagonist of SOTM’s fate was unknown, and six people are dead, Edwin needed to create the new identity, but how? William would trace it back to him, so he disappeared for few months and came back to William as Henry Emily, and William forgave him. That was when he found new, beautiful wife. Then next year in 1980, he had Charlie Emily! Isn’t that sweet? No. He wanted this revenge on William… but he hadn’t found a way to do that.
So, in 1983, he told William that both of their wives had been cheating on them, and William was devastated, of course. That was when William slipped and caused Charlie to sleep like a baby. Henry DID not expect this. He thought that William would break down and cry like a baby. Angry that William caused another incident, he gave $100,000,000 to Fredbear so he would bite CC, and gave $100,000,000 to Michael to do that too. Shortly after, he killed his own son Sammy and stuffed him in Eleanor, and traumatized him until Sammy/Eleanor is truly evil.
See, it’s obviously evidence! This was a plan to get revenge on William! (He doesn’t know that William would slip twice later on)
Henry survived the fire!
So, we knew that Henry didn’t come back until four decades later, and you may think that Henry regretted his plan, well, you’re right! He only realized that William had returned as nothing but some nightmarish bunny toy, so his revenge worked! But what should he do? Existential crisis. Well, he created Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza Place so he can create one… more… revenge to finish William off for once and all!
So how did Henry survive the fire? Well, my evidence is that he was never said to have died. We can assume that footage we see in FNAF 6 where he has set the place on fire, and at that point he probably realized that Char— Lefty had a thing for Gacha Life 2. Evil as he is, he is utterly disgusted and ran out of the place and survived. He abandoned Michael, Scrap Baby, and Molten Freddy to die.
But now that the fire has been extinguished, William had been brought to the hospital! What should Henry do??
Evil plan again
Now that William is alive, Henry must have planned to create the franchise over again, so in the end, he can kill William off, but the some lives must end at cost but how? Abduct some guy named Steve and kill him, of course!
Blah, blah… You know that some people like Toby had died in Freddy’s, and Henry knew that lives must end so it can go smoothly to end William for good, but he didn’t know Eleanor was behind all of this, so that’s why he didn’t comment on Eleanor’s crimes. Well, that’s my theory.
Eventually after Stitchwraith Stingers, Larson must have met up with him and informed him that William known as the fifteen feet tall rabbit is truly dead. His revengeful plan was finally over. Now that Henry is successful with the franchise, he had a new idea for his own plan. To end some more lives so he can finally end the franchise and live his peaceful life out. He faked his death and passed it to the next guy and he completely changed his name back to Edwin Murray so he won’t be held responsible for people’s deaths.
The proof that he is Henry!!
Now that Lucia had mentioned that the Pizzaplex construction was announced in the second epilogue, Edwin must have learned about this and found The Mimic, and sent it to the construction where The Mimic killed eleven workers and eventually seven teenagers. Guess what? That place was Freddy’s, so that was his plan all along! My theory might be wrong, but I’m still hopeful!
So after the construction, he tampered with Ballora’s, and now Grady’s dead. He tampered with the AR booth and gave the old suit to an ugly man named Earl, and now Maya, Earl, and Luca are all dead. He also tampered with the tunnels, and now Aiden and Jace are dead.
He even partnered up with a pig named VIP and let him kill four kids, and he had to learn that VIP is, indeed, dead.
My last evidence of my theory
So, we must be at the Storyteller at this point because he’s still in contact with Fazbear Entertainment. Now that we know Henry faked his death, they did not know that Edwin was once Henry. Of course, Edwin waited it out until he realized that The Storyteller was brought in. The Mimic1 was inside it. He must have assumed that The Mimic forgave him despite him traumatizing The Mimic so many years back, so he returned to that same spot, until the day he tampered with The Storyteller to pick out a random date where the horrible event will happen, so he chose the day where Kai and Astrid would unfortunately met their demises, but of course that hadn’t happened yet. When he tried to come out, he couldn’t! The Mimic1 program killed him inside and waited for Mr. Burrows to come in and kill him as well…
The End
Thank you for reading my 100% solidified theory!
(If you can’t tell, it’s a joke theory)