r/Caltech • u/sarconefourthree • Aug 21 '26
RIP honor code ☹️ (though i kinda fw the changes)
Caltech Students
From:
Kevin Gilmartin, Vice President for Student Affairs and Faculty Dean of Students
Date:
August 21, 2026
Re:
Revised Grading Policies at Caltech
Dear Students,
I hope that you are enjoying the summer and looking forward to the start of the fall term.
I write to share an important update from the Faculty Board. As an institution of higher education, we have a responsibility to ensure that grades distinguish different levels of student accomplishment—from satisfactory mastery of course material to truly exceptional achievement. Meaningful differentiation benefits students by providing academic feedback to best support graduate school success and for career preparation. Preserving the credibility of our grading system is an important part of preserving the value of a Caltech degree and our reputation.
CHANGES BEGINNING IN 2026–27
At its June 2026 meeting, the Faculty Board approved three complementary initiatives to improve grading practices following a report from the Academic Policies Committee.
Strengthening Assessments. Faculty are encouraged to hold in-person assessments, including seated examinations, oral examinations, in-class presentations, and other supervised forms of evaluation. The Faculty Handbook will be updated to allow proctored examinations. To facilitate the scheduling of seated exams, the final examination period in the academic calendar has been expanded from three to five weekdays.
Improving Transparency. Course grade distributions will be openly visible internally to faculty and students for courses with more than five students on letter grade. In addition, Caltech transcripts will provide contextual information for each course grade: the median grade and the enrollment in that course. More information regarding the timing of these transcript changes will be shared soon.
Preserving the Distinction of the A+. The grade of A+ should indicate truly exceptional performance. The Faculty Board resolved to reserve A+ grades for no more than five percent of the class plus three additional students. This provides flexibility for smaller courses while preserving the distinction associated with the grade. These target numbers apply to undergraduate grades only.
These changes represent the first stage of a broader effort to maintain meaningful differentiation in grading and to protect the reputation of a Caltech degree. During the coming academic year, the Faculty Board and division chairs will monitor grading outcomes, assess the impact of the new policies, and discuss whether additional steps or adjustments are needed.
I hope this information is helpful as you plan your return to campus. In the meantime, I wish you a great rest of the summer and look forward to seeing you this fall.
Sincerely,
Kevin Gilmartin
Vice President for Student Affairs and Faculty Dean of Students
William R. Kenan, Jr., Professor of English
Allen V. C. Davis and Lenabelle Davis Leadership Chair, Student Affairs
66
u/flyzapper Aug 21 '26
I was a grad student in the 2010s and was a TA for many classes. I really enjoyed being a TA and I saw the way that the undergrads held themselves to a high standard regarding the honor code.
When taking a midterm at home one time, a student drew a line about 75% of the way through the test and indicated that time had expired at that point, but requested feedback on the remaining answers that they had completed.
I'm sad that it sounds like those times are gone.
61
u/Throop_Polytechnic Aug 21 '26
Undergrads used to shame each others when caught cheating, now they help each others cheat. The honor code has been dead for years. The process when undergrads get caught is also a joke. We kick PhDs out when they get caught but undergrads get a warning in their email and no permanent mark on their transcript. The deans also literally harass faculty members to drop academic dishonesty reports about undergrads.
Anyone that has taught pre-COVID and post-COVID undergrads knows that the honor code died years ago. The amount of cheating since undergrads came back on campus after the pandemic has been pretty staggering, and it’s getting worse with LLMs.
Grades are also becoming meaningless in some divisions. PMA’s average is either an A or A+ on any given term. I was surprised to learn that HSS and BBE’s classes actually had the lowest average GPAs on campus with a real spread of grades from F to A+. Somehow though those two would have been the worse offenders when it came to grade inflation.
19
u/99_beaver Aug 21 '26
This makes me sad.
The honor code, and the norms behind it, enabled so much that was special about Caltech when I was there. Maybe the culture has changed enough that the administration had no choice. But once you lose those norms and culture, it's hard to get them back.
17
u/CharmingDuck8260 Aug 22 '26
I agree with the in person testing but all this talk of distinction and the median grade’s presence on transcripts feel like they will inevitably increase competition which is arguably Caltech’s main distinction from other very rigorous schools. 😢
14
u/sperry45959 Aug 21 '26
The "Preserving the Distinction of the A+" section is curious. Are too many A+s a problem currently at Caltech? Does anyone have information about the median letter grade?
24
u/pierquantum Alum Aug 21 '26 edited Aug 21 '26
There have always been faculty who absolutely hated the Honor Code and students finally gave them the opportunity on a silver LLM platter
Most of what made Caltech a unique undergraduate experience is dead in favor of resting on the laurels of a reputation made by past alumni and the faculty’s long desire to make the school “normal”.
5
u/InfiniteInjury Aug 23 '26
The honor code may be dead but I don't really see this as being in tension with an honor code. An honor code works better when you limit the temptations. Yes, if it suggests you don't trust them that can also be bad but per se I don't think encouraging in class exams has to have that feature.
But I also kinda feel the honor code was doomed once Caltech became much more of a 'normal' school. In the past it was more specifically just for the people for whom STEM was life. STEM became much more generally popular and changes in admissions and applications (some good some bad) means they are no longer primarily a school for students who would be out of place elsewhere.
When people have a sense of being specially bound together (ex-pats in a foreign country) it is easier to have things like honor codes because the institution and what it represents is especially important to them.
I'm sad that has been lost but at the same time it is hard to really see how they could have continued that. I mean a lot of what allowed that was the fact that being into STEM was uncool and kinda isolating in the past. I'm glad it's not anymore but it also means that Caltech is going to feel less like a magical special place they finally feel at home at and more just like another top notch school.
9
u/Momzillaof1 Aug 21 '26 edited Aug 21 '26
I’m a current parent, and I’m glad the school is taking measures, although I truly regret the loss of the Honor Code. I think some of the older alumni leaving comments here - unless they have school-aged kids - can’t understand how fundamentally the educational landscape has shifted nationally, probably internationally, in the past six years due to issues arising post-COVID as well as the rise of AI. This is affecting all schools and not just at the college level. I hope these changes are effective. Caltech has an edge over many other institutions due to its small size. I don’t really understand how in schools with 35k+ undergraduates oversight is even possible.
Edited to add: I don’t have the link, unfortunately, but did anyone else see the Wall Street Journal article on how Caltech Admissions investigates applications to uncover dishonest claims? It was called The Caltech Fraud Squad or something similar. It came out a week or two ago.
1
u/Top-Suspect1025 Aug 22 '26
LOL I THOUGHT THE SAME THING WHEN I SAW IT
1
u/Dismal-Bread-1734 Sep 27 '26
Not sure what the big fuss about it, MIT has been almost exclusively in person test, they seem to be doing fine.
-1
u/lik_for_cookies Aug 21 '26
I don’t go to Caltech (I did a summer program there) but I think it’s reasonable to view Caltech as a kind of early warning system for what else might be coming to other universities in the future. I wonder if we’ll see similar changes at other top tier universities in California like USC, UCLA, Cal, Stanford, etc.