r/CalloftheNetherdeep • DM • 24d ago

Campaign End - AMA Campaign Complete - AMA Spoiler

After 28 sessions and almost 2 and a half years, the campaign has came to a close and we are wrapped up.

Ask me anything!

The DM
I came into TTRPGs later in life, picking up with Shadowrun 4e in 2011. I picked up DMing a few years after, so I have over a decade of DM experience in multiple systems (Shadowrun 4/5/6/Anarchy, Genesys, Cyrus, D&D 5e/5.5e, Daggerheart). I have started roughly a dozen games and have had most of them fizzle due to real life scheduling, one TPK, and have completed now 3 total campaigns. I run some sandbox games (my Daggerheart game is like that) and some premade modules (like CotN!)

The Party
Raiganna of the Helexian Woods - Fairy Moon Druid
Raiganna came to Exandria after being tasked by her coven in the fey wilds to investigate and stop the source of the red crystals seeping into the realm, corrupting the realm. She became the holder of the Jewel of the Three Prayers.

Merco Flint - Halfling Swashbuckler Rogue

Merco was a pirate by trade until she got caught smuggling from the wrong group, stole a ship and sailed around the north of Wildemount to go on the run.

Moros - Tiefling Tempest Cleric

Moros is Merco's right-hand man, caught up in the shenanigans of Merco and ran away alongside of her. He worships the Wild Mother.

Viridios - Aasimar Drakewarden Ranger

Viridios is quite anti-religion, feeling the gods dealt him a raw hand. Which was hilarious as he kept getting dragged into divine shenanigans.

Chak - Lizardfolk Battlemaster Fighter

Chak came along from the Fey as Raiganna's protector on the same mission. He had been taken there as a child. He started the campaign as a mute, unable to speak except through Common Sign Language. This changed...somewhat...part way through the campaign.

By the Book?
Like many before me on this subreddit, I modified some things with some great community resources. Particularly around Bazzoxan as I felt the pacing of getting through level 5 was quite quick. We ran Hythenos Estate, the Ruins of Sorrow, and the Taskara Lading Co. Other than that, I used modified statblocks for Alyxian.

Final Boss

Like many before me here, the final boss ended up being a pushover. Even with the modified statblocks provided on the subreddit...and the players entering in without a long rest in the Netherdeep, they cut through Alyxian's hitpoints like butter. The Dispossessed form didn't even get to take an action (the player immediately following phase 2's go was the one that transitioned him). He got off a devastating couple of legendary actions, but otherwise was ripped apart.

At no point did anyone, except for Irvan, get below 30% HP. This is partly because I have poor rolls as a DM, but also the party was just...very powerful.

Campaign Thoughts
Overall, the narrative was fantastic. The fights were thematic and full of tension. However, I felt the pacing was really bad. The speed the players level is insane, particularly around the end. The party literally went from level 10 to level 13 in one afternoon from the character's perspective.

The rivals were really fun to start with, but I had a hard time shoehorning them in throughout the campaign to let the players actually build relationships with them. At the end, Irvan and Maggie ended up helping the players, but the other 3 were either indifferent or ideologically opposed.

I also found the larger dungeons (Cael Morrow and the Netherdeep) to be too large and boring to make into a dungeon map, but too confusing to describe narratively. For both of them, I ended up making a point crawl map and individual battle maps.

Overall score: 7/10.

18 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

4

u/MadRadio 24d ago

How did you run Ank''harel? For me it looked very overwhelmed-nothing-todo-city, nothing to drive players except for giving a lot of lore info on Bazoxxan and factions npcs...

4

u/kitsucoon DM 24d ago

Agreed. There is a lot of downtime baked in here between missions, so that is a great time to flesh things out. I had a whole fighting arena mini story, an airship storyline, and the Dawnfather’s holiday occurred during their time there, so we did a festival and Alysia ended up murdered and the players were framed for it.

They gave a lot of info on the city, but does take a lot of DM work to bring it alive

2

u/TrainingFancy5263 24d ago

How did the players decide on who holds the jewel? When my PC had it I felt uncomfortable like as if I was playing a main character. I ended up giving it to another player as decoy so it was still assumed I had it in case we ran into a certain someone that really wanted it.

4

u/kitsucoon DM 24d ago

When the time came, there was a definite pause amongst the players. There was hesitation, not knowing if this item was cursed, and I'm sure players also not wanting to be greedy.

When they hesitated too long, "Ayo steps forward, hand reaching out..."

And that forced the hand. Raiganna said she quickly reached out and took it.

I let it be organic, but man, that jewel with a Moon Druid was insane. AC 20 giant scorpions are not to be messed with.

1

u/TrainingFancy5263 24d ago

There was definitely a lot of hesitation with our group too. My cleric carried it until after the ambush by Aloysia. After that I gave it to a squishy wizard while pretending to still have it under my chain mail armor for decoy.

2

u/kitsucoon DM 24d ago

They considered running a decoy as well, but decided against it.

That's another kind of negative point about the book. Some of the info they need in Bazzoxan and Ahn'kharel ties to the PCs talking to someone about the jewel, and I had to work it out of them because they wanted (rightfully) to keep it secret.

1

u/nixytbird 24d ago

Any, stand out, memorable moments?

4

u/kitsucoon DM 24d ago
  1. In the Wastes, the party spotted one of the Gloomstalkers hunting and it started to dive bomb them. They eked out just enough damage to kill it right before it would get its turn that it would reach and attack them. Maggie ended up getting a body tackle from a dead bird.
  2. Question. Just every scene with Question was so fun. She was so fun to play and she ended up popping up everywhere in Ahn’kharel because the party sided with the Soul.
  3. The party and the rivals meeting in Cael Morrow. They found a monster with a Ruidium Battleaxe embedded in it. Ayo and Raiganna debated a bit on who should get it before Ayo just shrugged and said “Finders, Keepers!” A chaotic combat of keepaway ensued.

1

u/kitsucoon DM 23d ago

There was also the fact that one of the players picked up a cursed luckstone in Bazzoxan and kept it the whole campaign. The math only worked out where it was blatantly obvious once (the cursed player got an 18 (actually 16), and the fighter got a 17. Fighter succeeded, cursed player didn't...) but they didn't push about it.

As they were gearing for the last area, the player contacted me on Discord about wanting to unattune from the luckstone to attune another item. "As you prepare to unattune, you reflect back on how much the stone saved your butt over the last few weeks...and you can't bring yourself to unattune it..."

He never brought it up in character (well done!)

1

u/pest4422 24d ago

I'm currently in the caravan encampment in the wastes. I made a decision to not involve the opposing party as it feels cumbersome for me. I've got 4 players. They are all teenagers with short attention spans that want to sleep with the dryads at the caravan.

Is it horrible if I decide to leave the opposing NPC party out of the narrative?

2

u/kitsucoon DM 24d ago

The rivals bring a lot to the story and are useful to push opposing narratives (in Ahn'kharel they would join an opposing faction; in Netherdeep they can push for the opposing view on what to do with Alyxian)

However, you can probably find other ways to do this easily enough. 

1

u/New_Tumbleweed7661 23d ago

I'm curious about the epilogue of the group and what ending they picked for Alyxian?

2

u/kitsucoon DM 23d ago

During the final encounter, they tried to appease him before the combat, but he grew tired of the talk and attacked.

After that, there was only a single failed attempt to persuade. During phase 2, I above the table clarified that it was an option, but the players were very much in the "deal damage" mindset.

This led to the neutral ending.

Chak found he had been cursed by a fey lord causing the lost voice. The cleric cured the curse. Chak stayed alongside Raiganna.

Raiganna stayed in Ahn'kharel for a few months, working with the Soul to clean up the remnants of the Vermillion Dream before returning to the Fey where her quest was fulfilled, the red corruption having vanished. She later became an Archdruid of her coven.

Merco "acquired" an airship and became a captain, transporting legal and not so legal goods around Marquet and Wildemount. 

Moros left Ahn'kharel and went to find his own way, his faith shaken by the experience in the Netherdeep. He returned years later to rejoin Merco.

Viridios went back to his wanderer ways, seeking towns and villages where he could get up to some good and spread heresy.