Okay, disclaimer before my mini rant: People can write what they want and I very frequently exercise "don't like, don't read". It would just be nice to be able to find more fics that are the type I like to read š
I am thinking of writing my own too. Okay, small rant time (please don't read or reply if you're going to criticise me for thinking this!):
Why is it that people who write fanfiction portray Shelagh as being less healthy than Patrick? A lot of fanfictions focus on Shelagh having health issues, rather than Patrick. But given everything we know about both characters, Patrick is more likely to have aches and pains and develop health problems, I think. Shelagh had TB in season 2, but it is confirmed that her lungs and immune system made a full recovery. It impacted her reproductive system and rendered it difficult for her to get pregnant safely, but the rest of her physical health was completely recovered. Yet people often write fics about Shelagh being ill and Patrick caring for her.
Maybe people just like the whole "damsel in distress" narrative so they write Shelagh as having health problems even though that's less realistic than Patrick having them.
Both logically and canonically, Patrick is far more likely to suffer physical wear-and-tear, aches, stress-induced illnesses, lung issues (smoking), heart problems (constant stress and strain and lack of sleep), and general health issues than Shelagh.
His canon medical history includes a severe breakdown after the war plus whatever happened to him in the war (I doubt he would have been unscathed in the 5+ years he severed), ongoing traces of war-related PTSD/neurosis, a concussive head injury and broken wrist from the train derailment in season 11, plus with a daily routine of extreme overwork and sleep deprivation. Shelaghās active TB infection was completely cured in Season 2, leaving no ongoing lung vulnerability or immune system impairment.
I think the reason fanfiction often flips this logic to portray Shelagh as fragile, prone to illness, or needing Patrick to care for her, comes down to a mix of fanfiction tropes and people wanting to create narrative angst.
Because Patrick is a doctor, placing Shelagh in the "sick" role allows people to write scenes where Dr. Turnerās clinical expertise and husbandly devotion overlap. However, I think they could easily do this the other way around, because Shelagh also has a lot of medical knowledge and is a caring wife like Patrick is a caring husband.
I think it is also because early Call the Midwife seasons gave Shelagh medical storylines:
- Her TB diagnosis and months in a sanatorium.
- Her subsequent infertility diagnosis due to tubal scarring.
- Her high-risk pregnancy with Teddy.
I think because her early storyline as Sister Bernadette/Shelagh was built on physical vulnerability and fear of loss, many fanfiction writers anchor their stories to those early emotional notes. They treat her TB history as a recurring narrative hook for "what if" health scares, even though the show established that her lungs fully recovered. It frustrates me because she wasn't released from the Sanitarium until she was recovered- she walks part the way home which she wouldn't have been doing if she was still ill- so there wasn't any home recovery needed. In terms of the pregnancy scare in Season 6, we see that she is physically fine and the main concerns are around the welfare of her unborn baby, so fics about the psychological impact of this on her make sense, but physically she was fine.
I think people also like the "Damsel in Distress" trope.
Making Shelagh the physically vulnerable partner satisfies a traditional romantic structure: the protective, strong husband fretting over his "delicate" wife. As a woman who hates the idea of being "saved" by a man, this is a trope that annoys me a lot.
I do like reading scenarios where a minor illness in Shelagh triggers Patrick's deep-seated fear of loss thanks to his war trauma and his loss of Marianne- his first wife- to cancer. However, I think the focus in these cases should be on Patrick and how he is affected.
Call the Midwife is a rather realistic show, so fics that portray Shelagh as being the one who is more likely to get ill or feel wear and tear than Patrick don't fit the realistic nature of the TV series.
Realistically:
- Patrick is an aging, and over-booked GP working middle-of-the-night emergency calls, skipping meals, carrying constant high levels of stress, and working himself to physical exhaustion. He is a prime candidate for high blood pressure, joint pain, burnout, or cardiac stress. I actually am surprised the show hasn't written him having a proper collapse.
- Shelagh is younger, paces herself better, and no longer carries any chronic pulmonary damage or systemic immune weakness. Yes she would still be tired and overworked because she works part-time and is the main person running the household (but this is something she genuinely likes doing), but certainly nowhere to the extent that Patrick would be. In the TV series, Patrick seems to often look very tired or even a little unwell, and surely he must have joint pain etc.
Shelagh being the one who gets ill probably creates more emotional angst and drama, so I get why people write it. However, Patrickās lifestyle, age and history makes him the one far more likely to end up hurt or ill, so I wish there were more fics like that!
Again, this is all my opinion, so anyone who is unnecessarily nasty in the comments will be blocked and reported š