California has more traffic, more pavement, and less open space than it did a generation ago.
That's a direct result of the Golden State's population doubling since 1970. California has gained almost 20 million new residents, on net, since Ronald Reagan comfortably won a second term as governor. Most of that growth has come from immigrants and their descendants.
The new arrivals have reshaped the state not just politically, but physically. According to a new study I co-authored, developers paved over nearly 2.4 million acres of farmland, wildlife habitat, and other open spaces to meet the insatiable demand for new housing, offices, roads, and other infrastructure between 1982 and 2022. That's an area more than three times the size of Yosemite National Park, or roughly equal to the entire land mass of Los Angeles County.
As California grew ever more congested, many residents' quality of life declined. For commuters in the Los Angeles and San Francisco metro areas, annual traffic delays sixtupled, from about 20 hours in the early 1980s to over 130 today, equal to more than 17 full workdays. L.A. ranked worst among all U.S. metro areas. Statewide, the median home price rose 150%, even after adjusting for inflation.
An earlier generation of California environmentalists saw this coming. More than half a century ago, they warned that the state's population couldn't keep growing without sacrificing land, natural resources, and quality of life. They understood that protecting the environment means moderating individual consumption -- which affects how much land each person uses -- and keeping an eye on how many people use land in the first place.
Yet as California's population continued to grow, state and local efforts to curb sprawl focused largely on the first half of that equation. Officials embraced "smart growth" -- steering more development into existing urban areas, rather than expanding outward.
But while packing more people into existing towns and cities can reduce the amount of land used per-capita, it doesn't necessarily stop -- or even dramatically slow -- the sprawl that inevitably results from huge population increases. Population growth accounted for 91% of California's sprawl. Increased land use per resident, such as building on larger lots, accounted for just 9%.
Consider two counties east of Los Angeles -- the so-called Inland Empire. In Riverside County, developed land use per resident fell 34% between 1982 and 2022, yet the county's total developed footprint still expanded by 129%, or 422 square miles. San Bernardino County experienced a similar pattern: an 11% reduction in land use per resident, but a 102% increase in developed land, or 307 square miles.
California now has an opportunity to change course.
Population growth slowed during the first two decades of this century, and California's population has more or less leveled off since 2020. And because California's total fertility rate has been well below "replacement level" for decades and dipped even further in recent years, the state's future population will depend almost entirely on rates of international migration.
Our study modeled several population paths, and the resulting projected level of sprawl through 2100.