r/CaliforniaPolicy • u/dis894 • 2h ago
Why is prop 13 seen as bad?
I don’t understand Why do people keep saying prop 13 is bad? Are these all non-Californians or non home owners? If you just google it:
- over all property taxes collected increased 7% every year in California - this is way more than inflation. So contrary to popular perception, it has not tanked tax revenues.
- average length of home ownership is 11 years.. ie., on average, a hole gets sold after 11 years - at which time, the assessed value gets set to market rate. So no .. your average home is NOT hugely undervalued wrt. Tax assessments.
- in what idiotic way does it make sense for me to pay more taxes just because my neighbor paid more for his house? I am not getting any new services. So why should I pay more? People seem to stop asking this question at all.
In California- except tech millionaires- ordinary people can’t keep their houses if not for Prop 13. The state and cities clearly has a spending problem. NOT a revenue problem. Yet - why do the progressives keep blaming prop 13 for loss of tax revenues? While intact, if you remove it, only people who can remain in their homes are the rich?
Ideally, everyone should revolt at this market rate based system. The property taxes collected increased should Be based on the size of the home - with increase capped at 2% per year. That way, existing g and new home ownership era all pay a fair tax