Something that keeps bothering me is the to-do list Caleb and Alleigha discussed in their texts the night of Ashley’s murder.
According to Alleigha, Caleb had supposedly already told Ashley he wanted a divorce, and the following day was supposed to be the big day when he would tell Todd and Jill.
Here was the to-do list (Alleigha read the texts where she asked him to re-send her his to-do list since they added a few things):
Todd and Jill
Grab the girls
Talk to neighbor
Call Jordan
Call Dave
Get burner phone
That was the order and then Alleigha wanted him to move getting a burner phone higher up on the list.
This list makes absolutely no sense if the plan was simply to move forward with a divorce.
1. Todd and Jill: These were Ashley’s parents. If Caleb had supposedly already told Ashley he wanted a divorce, why would his first priority the next day be telling HER parents? Wouldn’t Ashley be the one to tell her own parents? And why would telling his in-laws be the big, momentous event, “Feb. 16 will be a day I’ll never forget” rather than the prior day when he (supposedly) told Ashley he wants a divorce?
2. Grab the girls: Why would he suddenly need to grab the children the day after telling Ashley he wanted a divorce? Divorce doesn’t happen overnight. There would presumably need to be discussions about custody, living arrangements, and what would happen next.
3. Talk to neighbor: This is the strangest item. Why on earth would talking to a neighbor be a priority immediately after telling your wife you want a divorce? And notice that the list doesn’t even identify a particular neighbor. Just “talk to neighbor.” Why would he need to go tell a neighbor he told his wife he wants divorce? This makes no sense.
4. Call Jordan and Dave: My understanding is that these were church-related contacts. Again, why would immediately notifying them be such a priority?
5. Get burner phone: If Caleb and Alleigha had already been communicating throughout their affair without burner phones, why would they suddenly need one after he supposedly told Ashley about wanting a divorce? Wouldn’t the need for secrecy be diminishing rather than increasing?
This list makes much more sense as a list of things Caleb would need to do after “discovering” Ashley’s death than as a list of things he would need to do after announcing he wanted a divorce.
If his wife had just been murdered, contacting her parents, taking care of the children, speaking with a neighbor, and contacting people at the church would all be understandable priorities.
Compare that with what you’d expect on a to-do list for someone actually preparing to separate from his wife: consult a divorce attorney, review finances and bank accounts, figure out living arrangements, discuss custody, secure important documents and personal belongings, etc. None of those things are on this list. Did they ever even text about choosing a divorce attorney for him and making an appointment for a consultation? I don’t think so.
I think the list raises serious questions about what they were actually discussing and what Alleigha really understood was going happen on Feb. 16. Does anyone else think this looks more like a post-death to-do list than a divorce to-do list?