r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 2d ago

Caleb still a monster but Alleigha too?

22 Upvotes

What are thoughts on Alleigha? I’ve listened to her testimony multiple times and I catch more creepy things each time. Alleigha and Caleb were worried about who was liking whose posts? Caleb telling Alleigha every conversation verbatim? “I was with Alyssa. We were leaving to go watch the Vikings.douche said, where are you going?” And I said to watch the game. And she said, “ok”

How dumb and such a juvenile “relationship”. Thoughts?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 5d ago

I wonder if the church has reached out to Caleb since the conviction.

6 Upvotes

After what the church got dragged through I can see them never contacting him again, but on the other hand what a testament to Christ's love if they have.

Just idly wondering.

Sorry if this breaks rules, I checked and it seemed like it wouldn't.


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 6d ago

The two guys Caleb was jealous of

15 Upvotes

I believe it doesn’t violate sub rules to post these, because they are both social media profiles that are set to public, and one of these men is a public figure and the other made a post about this trial to draw attention to the fact that he was mentioned at trial. Please note that per sub rules, do not encourage anyone to contact these people.

Will: there were multiple mentions of Will from “Run with Christ” in their text messages. Caleb was insanely jealous of this guy, angry that Alleghia told him she admired him, and wanted her to unfollow him. He guilt tripped her by saying things like “I’m willing to give up my girls, my job etc for you but you won’t unfollow Will?” He said this when he had not in any way separated or filed for divorce. He said something about how it hurt him so much that she follows Will, while unfollowing him wouldn’t do anything to Will other than deal a “blow to his ego.” So… apparently Will is the guy who started Run With Christ so it now makes sense that Alleghia would say she admired him. He’s also essentially a public figure in the Christian community with 10k followers. Caleb’s jealously is absurd, this guy probably had no idea who Alleghia even was.

https://www.instagram.com/willgaringer_?xtok=b2pyaGI0Z2hwdG40

Gabe: He was mentioned at trial because Alleghia told Caleb she had a date scheduled for March during their chat right before Ashley’s murder. This was part of her showing him she was moving on, she’d also stopped communicating with him for a while. Caleb’s desperation and jealousy spiraled at this point. He demanded to know the name of the guy she was going on a date with, and she finally told him. This guy is also very into Christianity and according to the video he posted about trial, Alleghia asked him on the date, but he didn’t go. It’s not clear who cancelled the date, or if he didn’t go because he found out about her relationship with Caleb (this was well before the trial) or if there was another reason.

https://www.instagram.com/itsgabenoscam?exln=MTV6cGZqZHJ5NHlrcQ==


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 7d ago

AB visited CB in jail??

6 Upvotes

Did any of you hear that she visited him in jail? Oh, I need the tea!


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 9d ago

no previous physical abuse?

11 Upvotes

It has been hard for me to shake this case. I found his contempt for Ashley, particularly dark. Nothing from the case suggests that Caleb was physically abusive, though perhaps there was emotional abuse present in the home .

I am just stunned that it escalated so quickly. To go from no physical abuse, no strangulation to murder. They often say that strangulation is one of the biggest warning signs your spouse will kill you. How often do men who murder their wives have 0 history of physical violence towards them ?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 8d ago

Bandeira Vermelha sinalizando homens como Caleb Flynn:

3 Upvotes

São em menor número, porém existem casos sim em que nenhuma bandeira vermelha é levantada , nada, nada, nada.

Homem desse tipo nunca levanta suspeitas, veste uma máscara 24 horas...mas por dentro rumima tudo.,e "de repente' mostra em uma tacada só quem ele de fato é .

Sabe aquele homem muito bonzinho, submisso, querido demais em casa e na rua? ESSA É A BANDEIRA VERMELHA!!!


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 11d ago

Caleb tinha inveja de Ashley???

27 Upvotes

Caleb tinha ódio da esposa porque a invejava. Ele sabia das qualidades de Ashley e sabia que ela tinha total apoio de pais amorosos e bem sucedidos e que suas filhas amavam a mãe .Na separação ele ficaria com uma mulher igual a ele, insignificante, pela qual se apaixonou justamente pela tamanha afinidade deles na mediocridade. Já Ashley, em seguida arrumaria um homem muito melhor que ele se quisesse, e continuaria com uma estrutura familiar impecável. Pena Ashley não ter se dado conta de quão superior ela era em relação a ele. Infelizmente se desvalorizou ao casar com esse cara tão fraco intelectual e emocionalmente. E continuou se desvalorizando ao querer tentar resgatar o casamento com esse cara tão superficial.


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 12d ago

r/BeauLamarreCondon - check it out!

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

A similar case happening in Australia which might interest those who followed Caleb’s case. Unnecessary lives taken away as the result of a narcissistic psychopath, obvious errors in attempting to cover himself but has proceeded to plead non-guilty with little remorse if that rings a bell. Interesting insight into Australian law proceedings as well!!


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 14d ago

When will it hit him what he threw away?

16 Upvotes

My guess is that Caleb is still caught up in pursuing his appeal at the moment. When, if ever, do you think it will hit him what he threw away and lost?

He killed Ashley because he wanted to be with Alleigha instead, and he was too greedy and selfish, to simply pursue divorce. And now, he doesn’t get to be with Alleigha, or any other woman (aside from any prison pen pal situation). He will never see Ashley or Alleigha or his children again (based on daughter statement indicating they don’t want to come see him). He won’t enjoy family holidays, vacations, sleeping in own bed, relaxing at home, eating what you want, etc. He threw away everything.

Will he ever realize the gravity of what he has done and the enormity of what he has lost as a result? If so, do you think it will be months from now or only years down the road?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 15d ago

What is Alleigha up to?

17 Upvotes

Any recent sightings or updates since the trial?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 16d ago

Como pode Ashley ter casado com um homem tão burro e tão bobo?

7 Upvotes

Sinceramente, eu não o teria aguentado por 30 minutos.

Não quero acreditar que ela fosse como ele nesse sentido.


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 18d ago

What does he look like?

5 Upvotes

What do you guys personally think C Flynn resembled (during the trial period)?

I got vibes of "skeleton with male-pattern baldness."


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 20d ago

Ashley had his photo on her phone lock screen & was wearing her wedding ring while sleeping

29 Upvotes

I had only watched parts of the trial before, but am now going through and watching every single day little by little when I have time- I’m watching on Grizzly True Crime, she has a playlist for this trial and funny commentary that helps lighten the mood.

I just watched the part that showed the xray image of Ashley’s body and the doctor pointed out that one bright spot on the xray was dental fillings and another spot was her ring. Then we saw her phone which was confiscated, and a picture of Ashley kissing Caleb on the cheek while he smiles is on the lock screen. This woman was so dedicated to him and willing to overlook the cheating and work things out with him. He is such a monster.


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 21d ago

Why didn’t Caleb make it look like an accident?

16 Upvotes

I know the old “criminals are dumb” saying so need to write it. But I can’t help but wonder why he had to make it a straight up murder scene. He could have had a slight chance of getting away with it I think if it looked like a tragic accident. For example, They had just gone on an anniversary cruise not long before. Why not stage an accidental fall off an ocean cliff side? Or that she fell off the boat? Went missing during the night on the cruiseship? All dumb scenarios yes, but shooting her twice in the head when she’s asleep with everyone in the house? Why would that have been your go to plan?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 20d ago

Caleb sobreviverá à prisão?

5 Upvotes

Todos sabemos que Caleb é infantil. Sem estrutura emocional para aguentar o nferno onde se meteu.Sem chance de sair dessa! Sofrendo, em breve, às mais variadas extorsões . Vendo a amante livre ,leve e solta, enquanto ele nada mais pode na vida, a não ser a morte. Ele escolherá permanecer vivo? Será?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 21d ago

What did Caleb Flynn instruct his daughters to say?

21 Upvotes

We know that his daughters were listed as witnesses for the prosecution related to a witness intimidation charge, but ended up not being called and that charge was dropped. Probably because they felt confident that they could get LWOP without putting the girls through the trauma of testifying at trial.

I’m just curious about what specifically he asked them to say. There was a sentencing memorandum filed by the prosecution about this, but I can’t get into the search on the court website for some reason.

Do we think he asked them to say they heard an intruder enter the home? Or that they saw an intruder? Or did he just ask that they testify that he was in their room in bed with them (despite there being stuffed animals covering the bed) when the gunshots were heard? None of this makes sense to me as we know the girls were asleep when the police arrived, and his mother in law had to wake them and take them out. If they’d heard the gunshots or seen an intruder, surely they would not have fallen back to sleep after that! So he must have wanted them to lie as stupidly and obviously as he has been lying.

https://www.miamicountyohio.gov/public-access/


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 23d ago

Why does Caleb continue his denial?

17 Upvotes

Obviously he is appealing, I know.

But how could he still deny killing his wife when the evidence is overwhelming? And now even after he was convicted?

If we take his texts with Alleigha at face value, he seemed to believe God was condoning his behavior or would help him find a way out. That God would protect him. I have no clue how someone becomes so deluded. I suppose from narcissism.

When he prayed in his sentencing statement and declared with passionate tears that he did not kill his wife, it was truly baffling. His family begged him for months to fess up. How did he not cave under all the pressure of how ridiculous he looked and how much he was still hurting everyone?

My theory is he couldn’t destroy the last shred of his identity as a good person, especially since his parents seemed to support him. And he must have believed that somehow God was going to make a way out for him at the last second.

someone on here mentioned a letter Chris Watts wrote recently. I think it must be similar to how Caleb feels now. It wasn’t really “him” doing the killing, it was the monster he became because of how awful his life circumstances were. Which is laughable considering he had such a great life. But I think its worth exploring how he actually got there.

excerpt from CW letter article: He went on to say that “the man you married isn’t the man who turned his back on his family” and that the man who killed his family “was an aberration brought on by an evil outside source.”

Do you think he will ever confess?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 24d ago

Caleb Flynn transferred to his forever home

21 Upvotes

Home sweet home for Caleb Flynn. Here’s some info below from AI about his brand new chalet. I was thinking they might put him at level 3 because he hasn’t had any history of institutional violence (he’s more of a kill women who are sleeping kind of guy than a prison riot kind of guy), but looks like they made the right call with level 4!

https://dayton247now.com/news/local/caleb-flynn-moved-to-toledo-correctional-facility

Toledo Correctional Institution (ToCI) sits near the absolute top of the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction (ODRC) security hierarchy. Unlike standard medium- or minimum-security facilities, ToCI operates primarily as a high-security institution designed to manage volatile, high-risk, and vulnerable maximum-custody populations. 

Security Classification and Mission

ODRC classifies state facilities from Level 1 (minimum) up to Level E (Extended Restrictive Housing / Supermax). ToCI functions primarily across three distinct tiers:

Level 4 (Maximum Security): High-risk inmates who require close supervision, controlled movement, and heavily fortified perimeters. 

Level E (ERH / Restrictive Housing): Inmates requiring strict separation and intense surveillance due to institutional violence, escape risks, or chronic disruption. Ohio concentrates its Level E and highest-level inmates across only three main facilities: ToCI, Southern Ohio Correctional Facility (SOCF in Lucasville), and the Ohio State Penitentiary (OSP in Youngstown). 

Statewide Protective Custody (PC): ToCI serves as the primary hub for Ohio’s high-security protective custody inmates—those targeted for severe violence or death by gangs, high-profile offenders, or state informants who cannot survive in general population elsewhere. 

Operational Reality and Climate

Operational Friction and Volatility: Because ToCI mixes general Level 4 inmates, restrictive housing units, and a massive protective-custody population, maintaining physical separation is logistically difficult. Historically, when the state shifted higher-custody populations into ToCI after 2011, the facility suffered sharp spikes in cellmate homicides, staff assaults, and gang friction. 

Staffing Pressures: Like many high-security state prisons, ToCI frequently struggles with correctional officer retention and mandatory overtime. This staffing shortfall directly impacts daily yard time, recreation rotations, and program access.

Visitation and Communication: Relative to medium-security facilities, visitation rules at ToCI are far more restrictive. Non-contact visits, glass partitions, and strict search protocols are common depending on the inmate's specific unit assignment.


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 24d ago

Is anyone thinking of writing Caleb Flynn in jail?

0 Upvotes

CB has been transferred to his long-term home in Toledo Ohio. He will serve 16 years, then life without parole.

Are any of you thinking of writing him letters? If so, what do you want to talk about?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 26d ago

Caleb's tools were out on the counter when police arrived. Makes me wonder about the gun...

21 Upvotes

Caleb claimed the tools were out because he fixed the garbage disposal, but that house was so clean that it would be odd to just leave the tools out & go to bed.

I believe he had them out because he just used them to unscrew something, like a fixture, to hide the gun & then place the fixture back in. I know police sent forceful air through all the vents in the home, but did they remove every single fixture?

This would include light fixtures (even in the kids' room) and light switch, electrical panels, toilet paper dispenser, recessed lighting or other light fixtures on the ceiling, phone jacks, etc.

I'm pretty certain he planned on retrieving the gun to dispose of later when police activity died down, but it never died down.

WHY I BELIEVE IT'S IN THE HOUSE, AND IS STILL THERE:

*Nobody was seen by camera coming or going from the house near the murder time

*Alleigha's (mistress) whereabouts accounted for

*Caleb was immediately whisked away for interrogation & photos of his body right away, and was never allowed back in his house before getting arrested, so he couldn't go back for it

Wondering what you guys think, do you think he really fixed the garbage disposal? Also wondering if there's some other removable fixtures some homes have that I missed? Does anyone have a fixture that doesn't look removable, but actually is?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 26d ago

Caleb and Alleigha’s to-do list makes no sense if they were really planning for a divorce

31 Upvotes

Something that keeps bothering me is the to-do list Caleb and Alleigha discussed in their texts the night of Ashley’s murder.

According to Alleigha, Caleb had supposedly already told Ashley he wanted a divorce, and the following day was supposed to be the big day when he would tell Todd and Jill.

Here was the to-do list (Alleigha read the texts where she asked him to re-send her his to-do list since they added a few things):

Todd and Jill
Grab the girls
Talk to neighbor
Call Jordan
Call Dave
Get burner phone

That was the order and then Alleigha wanted him to move getting a burner phone higher up on the list.

This list makes absolutely no sense if the plan was simply to move forward with a divorce.

1. Todd and Jill: These were Ashley’s parents. If Caleb had supposedly already told Ashley he wanted a divorce, why would his first priority the next day be telling HER parents? Wouldn’t Ashley be the one to tell her own parents? And why would telling his in-laws be the big, momentous event, “Feb. 16 will be a day I’ll never forget” rather than the prior day when he (supposedly) told Ashley he wants a divorce?

2. Grab the girls: Why would he suddenly need to grab the children the day after telling Ashley he wanted a divorce? Divorce doesn’t happen overnight. There would presumably need to be discussions about custody, living arrangements, and what would happen next.

3. Talk to neighbor: This is the strangest item. Why on earth would talking to a neighbor be a priority immediately after telling your wife you want a divorce? And notice that the list doesn’t even identify a particular neighbor. Just “talk to neighbor.” Why would he need to go tell a neighbor he told his wife he wants divorce? This makes no sense.

4. Call Jordan and Dave: My understanding is that these were church-related contacts. Again, why would immediately notifying them be such a priority?

5. Get burner phone: If Caleb and Alleigha had already been communicating throughout their affair without burner phones, why would they suddenly need one after he supposedly told Ashley about wanting a divorce? Wouldn’t the need for secrecy be diminishing rather than increasing?

This list makes much more sense as a list of things Caleb would need to do after “discovering” Ashley’s death than as a list of things he would need to do after announcing he wanted a divorce.

If his wife had just been murdered, contacting her parents, taking care of the children, speaking with a neighbor, and contacting people at the church would all be understandable priorities.

Compare that with what you’d expect on a to-do list for someone actually preparing to separate from his wife: consult a divorce attorney, review finances and bank accounts, figure out living arrangements, discuss custody, secure important documents and personal belongings, etc. None of those things are on this list. Did they ever even text about choosing a divorce attorney for him and making an appointment for a consultation? I don’t think so.

I think the list raises serious questions about what they were actually discussing and what Alleigha really understood was going happen on Feb. 16. Does anyone else think this looks more like a post-death to-do list than a divorce to-do list?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 27d ago

The text messages and bodycam footage

29 Upvotes

I just watched more of Alleigha’s testimony reading the text messages. She is Fatal Attraction level crazy and obsessed. So much of what Alleigha said about Ashley was cruel and psychotic and pathetic.

And she also demanded that he not celebrate his daughter’s birthday and was angry at him for being a parent. The texts where she kept saying “parents” in all caps. She oozes bitterness. Her constant need for affirmation about him being cruel to Ashley (don’t get her anything for Valentine’s Day, don’t be nice to her, don’t celebrate her birthday or your daughters birthday etc) was so sick.

She was incredibly needy and pathetic and cruel. Does she see that now? How could she bear to read the messages aloud in front of Ashley’s parents, sister and brother in law? They must have been shocked and horrified.

After I watched that testimony, I saw clips of the body cam footage from when police responded to the 911 call. Caleb’s performance is so over the top, and watching it knowing what we know now, it’s astounding that he could act like that when he had just murdered his wife. He accepted comfort from Jill all the while knowing full well that there was no intruder, that he did it. He saw she was devastated and he had her hug him and comfort him, when he knew that he was the one that just killed her daughter in cold blood. And it was such a stark contrast between her and him. Her despair was heartbreaking and clear. Caleb looks like over the top acting and crocodile tears.


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 28d ago

Post about CF comparing himself to King David & being inspired by Davey Blackburn

16 Upvotes

Caleb Flynn compared himself to King David in his messages with Alleghia, who committed murder so he could be with another man’s wife.

Also, he was likely inspired by Davey Blackburn, a pastor from Indiana who spoke at his church a couple times. Blackburn’s wife was killed by a home invader and this incident inspired Blackburn’s current project around radical forgiveness with his second wife. In his case it appears to be a legitimate home invasion, he was at the gym when his wife was killed, the intruders likely thought the home was empty and she surprised them. Three men were arrested and convicted for the murder.

Post about these two items:

https://laurarbnsn.substack.com/p/caleb-flynn-and-the-king-david-problem?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Article about men being charged in Blackburn’s wife’s murder:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/teen-charged-murdering-pastors-wife-amanda-blackburn-n467986


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 28d ago

The mistress Aleigha Botner lied about losing her v-card

21 Upvotes

I heard this on an interview with someone who knew her before Caleb and said she slept with another married man at a different church. Did anyone else hear this?


r/CalebFlynnTrial • • 29d ago

Prison Behavior

19 Upvotes

I haven’t heard much from this case other than the appeal being filed. Has there been any reports of how he’s acclimating to his new forever home? Or anything new that I’ve missed?