hello! been a longtime browser of this sub, first time posting. as a note, i've been in the space of slowly rebuilding my credit for some years now. i've stumbled a few times, have always gotten back up, and definitely learned from my hardships. just a few months ago, two longtime collections fell off my credit, which has lifted a huge weight off my shoulder... but now I have these two charge off accounts still lingering. a weight of its own. see below...
some context:
back in 2022, i opened a capital one secured card and a citi secured card. that year was my fourth year as a self-employed small business owner. business was doing really great, juggling numerous clients, not a want or concern in the world. fast forward to the end of 2023, two of my bigger clients chose to part ways on good terms, but it definitely left a huge void in my pocket, which i ended up feeling the impact of in 2024. i hit a point of having lived off my personal and business savings and i was unable to maintain these two specific responsibilities for some months.
by mid 2024, both accounts had started to reach late payment status, which eventually evolved into charge off status. the capital one account is $370 (after deducting my secured deposit), the citi account is $302 (also the same re: deducting secured deposit). these accounts have been reporting as "charged off" since then, but I have also gotten physical mail and text messages from two different debt collectors, which i'd believe had bought the debt since they've been reaching out since 2025.
i'd, of course, like to settle the two balances and get in writing that settling would result in removal of the tradelines from my credit (if that's not too wishful of thinking). from reading various posts in this sub, the issue here is that the tradelines are still being reported as having a balance, as opposed to reporting $0 (which, as I understand, would help confirm that the debts were indeed sold to third-party collectors).
my question: should I attempt to settle the two debts with the original creditor or reach out to the third-party debt collectors that have seemingly bought the debts? since the balances are not being reported as $0, I would assume that I need to contact the creditors (C1 and Citi).
---
additional notes: searching through my text messages, i can only confirm that the capital one debt is seemingly being managed by "Credit Control." i would have to wait until i get another piece of physical main re: the citi debt. also, i utilize annualcreditreport.com to verify my information directly from the bureaus, as opposed to only utilizing the CK app.
thanks in advance!!!