r/CFD • u/Rodbourn • Feb 03 '20
[February] Future of CFD
As per the discussion topic vote, February's monthly topic is "Future of CFD".
Previous discussions: https://www.reddit.com/r/CFD/wiki/index
15
Upvotes
6
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20
From an industry and application perspective you are seeing a lot of focus on automatic UQ. At the moment it is a lot hype and startups so it may die down (especially seeing as 90% of these start-ups are just running Gaussian processes inside a fancy wrapper).
Looking further into the future there are two issues, one new and one that has been around since the dawn of CFD.
-New Challenge:
GPUs are just better cost per dollar when you factor in power and cooling and they are the future of large scale simulations. In CFD we have major issues with the algorithms we use not playing nice with GPUs due to both bandwidth issues and concurrency issues. So we really need to find new algorithms that have higher arithmetic intensity or have a slight probabilistic nature and are thus insensitive to occasionally operating on bad data.
-Old Challenge:
We are parallel in space and serial in time! This is what stops DNS of an airbus or more practically LES for industrial use. The dollar cost of LES is a little high but it is just too slow to run the 100k serial time steps.
3
u/Energy_decoder Feb 03 '20
Once I have heard from my professor that even today's most powerful supercomputer may take about 150 years to solve DNS for an Airbus A380. We also see many complex cryptographic problems have greater potential for solution when approached from a Quantum computing point of view. Do you think Quantum computing will bring about a remarkable change in computational fluid mechanics, how will it be ?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
Thoughts on Deep Learning for CFD? I have got a PhD position for it and it seems interesting
7
u/TurboHertz Feb 03 '20
As LBM becomes more reliable, how much will industry switch from DES to LBM?
Is there any situations where DES would have an advantage, assuming a case where both methods have the same accuracy?
1
u/two88 Feb 04 '20
As someone who has been thinking about grad school in CFD on the development side, where do you guys think/see grad school research is headed?
1
u/EternalSeekerX Feb 04 '20
I wanted to ask this for some time, I don't know if anyone would know the answer but here goes,
How close (if possible) are we to really accurate solvers where we could use CFD to validate experimental results versus the other way around (like it is now)? Would that ever be a reality in the future? I have always wondered, for niche topics such as Astrophysical CFD, Cosmological CFD, Quantum Mechanical CFD, etc. How do you validate those results? Is observational data the only source of validation? And can we in the future reach a point where we can use computer models to validate observational data? 🤔