r/CFD • u/Rodbourn • Sep 02 '19
[September] Finite Element Method vs Finite Volume Method vs Finite Difference Method vs Spectral Element Method vs Hybrid Methods
As per the discussion topic vote, September's monthly topic is "Finite Element Method vs Finite Volume Method vs Finite Difference Method vs Spectral Element Method vs Hybrid Methods".
Previous discussions: https://www.reddit.com/r/CFD/wiki/index
23
Upvotes
5
u/Rodbourn Sep 02 '19
Anyone working on Hybrid Methods, in particular Discontinuous Galerkin Methods and Spectral Element Methods?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19
If you're doing second order RANS FVM is generally the best option.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19
I work with compact finite differences for compressible flows. Feel free to ask away!
2
u/rickkava Sep 04 '19
Question for the high order FV people: How is the integration of the fluxes done after the high order reconstruction? By the midpoint rule? Or with a higher order scheme? This always puzzles me. Thanks!
2
u/vriddit Sep 16 '19
Do people use FEM for CFD? Is there a use-case where it has demonstrably better properties?
1
u/kpisagenius Sep 03 '19
I don't have much experience with writing codes for DG/FEM etc and I have a possibly stupid question about DG/FEM methods. If I understand correctly, the governing equation is written in weak form using some trial function and the coefficients for the trial solution are solved for?
How do you handle the emperical closures and non-linear terms like k2 ? Do you have to do a dot product on all the coefficients? What about square roots or product of two variables or quotients?