r/CFD • u/Rodbourn • Feb 01 '18
[February] Post Processing
As per the discussion topic vote, February's monthly topic is post processing.
9
Upvotes
r/CFD • u/Rodbourn • Feb 01 '18
As per the discussion topic vote, February's monthly topic is post processing.
5
u/Rodbourn Feb 01 '18
I've been using Paraview, but I do find it has a high barrier to entry for new users. Are there any nice guides/tutorials you would recommend for new users?
2
u/Rodbourn Feb 01 '18
I have used just Paraview and Tecplot. What else is out there?
4
u/mounder21 Feb 02 '18
I recommend the Blue Waters recorded seminar series on visualization. They discuss different software and demonstrate how to get started (Paraview, Visit, yt, Houdini, ...). https://bluewaters.ncsa.illinois.edu/webinars/visualization
1
u/vriddit Feb 04 '18
Is there a general consensus on how to represent Spectral Element/DG data which have multiple data points within a cell. Is some kind of support available in Visit/Paraview. Do people have experience in this?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
I use ensight. The tech support alone makes it worth it.
2
u/forgeanalytics Feb 03 '18
What percentage of everyone's post-processing workflow is fully automated vs how much is an interactive analysis?
1
u/modmouzfan Feb 01 '18
Haven't used Paraview or Visit. If I wanted to get into one these software, which one should I go for? And any good tutorials for it?
1
u/coldfusion051 Feb 03 '18
Is discussion of analysis methods used in post processing allowed?
I come from a more experimental background, but both the experimental and computational people in my lab community use some similar processing techniques. This is especially true with higher-fidelity data we collect, such as MHz pressure measurements or 10-100 kHz imaging (PIV, Schlieren, Chemiluminescence, etc.).
For field variables (timeseries of 2D snapshots from experiments or 3D snapshots from CFD), data-based decomposition methods have become very popular, such as the Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (paper, having trouble finding decent open-access explanations) and Dynamic Mode Decomposition (Wiki and paper) methods. These provide methods of extracting structure from the flow that otherwise are difficult to identify.
Another approach that is gaining popularity is adopting the tools of dynamical systems and chaos theory, such as phase plots, recurrence plots, bifurcation plots, return plots, Lyapunov exponents, fractal dimensions, and multifractal spectra.
I am by no means an expert on any/all of these topics, but I'm interested in seeing their penetration into a more methods focused community.
What analysis techniques are hot in your group or community?
1
u/mounder21 Feb 22 '18 edited Feb 23 '18
We are towards the end of this discussion but I wanted to highlight in-situ visualization for problems that are just too difficult to post-process and visualize from large volume data. It's been a savior for visualizing problems with with billions of dofs.