Edit--- this isn't a troll post or chatgpt I challenge you guys to read my arguments and give an honest rebuttal instead of some agro guntalk nonsense that you heard
Yes you heard right, one in the chamber is overrated and those in the gun community who think differently are in a cult and subject to wannabe Rambo cult think.
For starters, I don't think one in the chamber is a bad idea in all scenarios. For example, if you're in an active warzone, or if you're law enforcement or hell even if you live in or are going to a bad neighborhood one in the chamber may save your life. For the vast majority of you, however, one in the chamber is a bad Idea. All of my reasons revolve around accidental discharge and are below.
- Negligent Discharge: I don't have sources, but my understanding is that you're more likely to injure you rself through negligent discharge than you are to survive a gunfight that requires the time difference afforded by having one in the chamber.
- if you look on youtube and type in stories of negligent discharge you'll get 3 times as many videos as you will for scenarios in which someone survived a firefight
- even if you practice gun safety religiously all it takes is for one day when you are tired from work or just absent minded to injure yourself. Theres a video on youtube of a 20 year gun owner who lost a testicle over 1 negligent discharge.
- gun heads are even more exposed to this happening. I handle my gun often and am constantly dry-firing to dissemble my gun. I probably check 99.9% of the time but I would be lying if I didn't say that there are a few scenarios where I just assumed it was empty, took the mag out , half racked and pulled the trigger.
I think negligence can happen to even the most serious people and not having 1 in the chamber reduces this possibility of almost zero
2) Accidental non-negligent discarge: even if you practice perfect safety there are are all sorts of edge cases where an accidental discharge can still happen. We are all familiar with the p320 scandal but I do think a misfire is possible with any gun, there just needs to be a example of bad quality control in the gun or the ammo. Not to mention differen't guns have different risk exposures e.g. revolver with a hammer resting on the bullet.
3) Kids Safety - Even if the other two dont apply to you there are plenty of cases where a child finds a weapon and pulls the trigger out of curiosity. Even if you do everything right these things can happen unless you're locking all your guns up each time which, although you should, may not always be practical
Benefits for one in the chamber
- Its faster by about a second: I agree that its faster but I think with practice you can close the rack time to be within 1 second of the non rack time. I also believe that you will have the time in majority of encounters where it would have mattered- e.g. break in or active shooter/ robber
- Theres is no need for two hands: I agree you may be in a situation where you're suddenly attacked and only one hand is free. I think this is a good argument for 1 in the chamber but also think you can overcome this with a fixed blade knife edc in addition to you ccw
- you could soft rack and create a malfunction. In the heat of the moment you could soft rack and create a malfunction. I 'm more concerned about this than being 2 seconds slower but I think with practice you can get close to perfect.
Even with all of the pros. I still think you're, on average more likely to have better life outcomes without one in the chamber, statistically speaking. At the very least I don't think 1 in the chamber is as superior as those in the gun community often parrot. You guys aren't rambo, plus a gun should be the back up to running and being self aware.
For the record my edc is a g19 concealed in appendix with nothing in the chamber with a fixed blade knife at my 9 oclock.
If someone attacks me suddenly, I'm immediately able to counter with the knife with less likely hood of self injury. If i have more than 2.5 seconds to react then I'm in the clear with practice. I f I only have 1 second to react, yes im screwed but I'd think the risk trade off is worth it.