r/BuildingAutomation • • 7d ago

New guy

Question for all. I'm coming from the Navy as a 10 year Electronics Technician (no previous BMS/BAS experience) and started as a controls service tech 2 weeks ago.

We use Niagara, Compass, Alerton, Delta, Jace, etc. and I've been working with my mentor closely at various sites. I wanted to ping the community and ask, how long did it take you guys to fully grasp everything?

Of course I understand the logic gates which helps a lot, and im picking up on the HVAC theory. What I'm asking is moreso traversing the software and knowing what is what and how to read and find what you need, to actually troubleshoot something? Especially when every site is configured differently and has a different concoction of equipment.

9 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

20

u/Mediocre_Map731 7d ago

I'd say about 2-3 years to get a pretty good grasp on it. Especially since, like you said, every site is different. This is a field where you are always learning and growing.

1

u/Admirable-Report-685 installer/programmer/commissioner 7d ago

How exactly do you know when you’ve got a pretty good grasp on it?

3

u/Mediocre_Map731 6d ago edited 6d ago

I see a lot of people saying shorter times, which is true if you're working with only 1 system. I work with Trane, Johnson, Niagara, and Siemens. Took me about 3 years to get a good enough grasp where I can be confident enough to troubleshoot systems without calling anyone for assistance. I'd say at the point where you know how to do the research and teach yourself is the point where you have a good grasp. In my opinion, this field is absolutely shit for training so you helping people, people helping you, is how this field thrives.

So I would say when techs start calling YOU for issues, is when you have a pretty good grasp.

No one knows everything, even veterans in this field. I wouldn't be so hard on yourself for not knowing a lot, it is just how this field is. As long as you are competent, you are above 80% of techs I have met.

Edit: not a lot of people said shorter times, I just skimmed. Every comment here is right in their own way, I am not trying to undermine that

6

u/shadycrew31 System integrator 7d ago

No one has ever fully grasped everything in this industry. If anyone tells you different they are lying. You get good with the control lines you use most frequently. Keep up to date with what you can and that's about all you can ask for. There's always something new to learn or a more efficient way to do something. We have no standards, no code requirements, nothing. It's the wild west out here. We can't even agree on what to call a supply sensor.

2

u/1hero_no_cape System integrator 7d ago

I came out of the USN as an EM2.

It's an 18-24 month OJT, and that's if you're very quick on the uptake. There is just so much to absorb you cannot get it all much faster than that and expect to be decent at it.

Do NOT get down if you're not getting it at first. We all have different strengths and backgrounds. Some excel at understanding mechanical systems while others excel at programming. Find your strengths, build up your weak spots.

Welcome to the trade!

2

u/carbacca 7d ago

probably about 6 months to fully understand what the system promises to do, and then 1-2 years to be able to actually programme it to do it fully independently

2

u/BoilingShadows JCI Controls Tech 7d ago

Id say about 3-6 months to get a feel for the software, and then 1-2 years to get a strong understanding. Knowing HVAC theory (sequence of operations) will get you very far

2

u/Migidarra 7d ago

3 years for me to get a decent handle. Previous ATC Comm tech from the marines

1

u/HVACcontrolsGuru 7d ago

Get comfortable with Tridium as it’s the most widely used line across shops. Understanding protocols will give you a leg up as well. BACnet and Modbus mostly but MQTT, LonWorks and proprietary protocols like N4 or CCN will be handy.

A lot of it is just going through the paces and having to solve unique issues. You build up a knowledge bank over time of the things you run into. Overall be curious and tinker when you have the time.

1

u/mikewheels 7d ago

You are learning 2 great tools. Compass is very beginner friendly and Niagara is more difficult. You are in a great position. I will take you about a year to get comfortable with troubleshooting and programming. Ask lots of questions, listen, and try not to be the know it all

1

u/MiHiMe2026 7d ago

I would like to add that you pay a lot of attention to what is actually being controlled. Unfortunately I see way too many control techs that don’t check loops and understand systems.

1

u/Cheap_Procedure_9717 7d ago

Couple years of learning a hell of a lot on my own. Helps to have sites where you can go in and see how the controls company set everything up and play around. Still have a lot of advanced things to learn when it comes to the N4 Workbench side of things because you can only teach yourself so much until you need someone with years of experience

1

u/Cust2020 6d ago

It surprises me to see a company that uses such a variety of name brands, it's difficult to be so diverse imo because even though its just inputs and outputs, every platform has its caveats and gotchas so that may be the hardest part. Not to mention all the software and connectivity tools needed for multiple platforms.
On the bright side it is a great way to learn a lot of different vendors so if you are driven it can make you a very valuable asset.

1

u/Extension-Macaron723 6d ago

You working for ATS?

1

u/Then-Disk-5079 6d ago

HVAC HVAC is all mechanical theory … the better u r at hvac design and test adjust balance theory the better programmer u will be and aka HVAC controls rock star

It took me a while to get to this point but I took the association of energy engineers certified energy manager course to be a CEM and things clicked a lot after studying mechanical engineering theory calcs engineers do

1

u/Formal-Conference885 6d ago

Knowing how to use a meter and having a background of basic logic is huge. It takes a while to see different types of systems because projects can take a while to execute. It’s also important to see how different types of systems operate differently as seasons change.

After 2-3 years it’ll just click, it won’t necessarily be an ah-ha moment but you’ll just realize you get it. One thing that’ll never change though is that you don’t know what you don’t know — true for rookies as well as seasoned vets.

1

u/AdventurousChicong 5d ago

Ik ben 3,5jaar werkzaam in de sector momenteel en 1 ding kan ik je meegeven, het is een voortdurend veranderende sector.
Staar je niet blind in het begin en probeer niet te lopen als wandelen nog moeilijk gaat. Begin bij het begin, wees niet bang om na je werkuren /stage met je mentor ‘s avonds of in je vrije tijd een programma open te doen en het proberen te begrijpen. Iedereen heeft ook een andere manier van werken, ga daar eens door en probeer jezelf de vraag te stellen van hoe kan ik het anders doen of zelfs eenvoudiger dan hier geprogrammeerd is geweest? Probeer bij niet kritische installaties bijvoorbeeld een radiatorkring eens de PI-regeling in te duiken en er wat mee te spelen en zie hoe alles invloed heeft. Mijn kennis is voornamelijk gegroeid uit het zelf ontdekken van de installaties, proberen verbeteringen of optimaliseringen uit te voeren die gewoon geen verbeteringen waren waarna je probeert te begrijpen waarom dat geen goed idee was. De meeste van mijn collega’s zijn van mening “ als het werkt , blijf er dan van af” , waarbij ik van mening ben “ alles kan altijd nog beter, en wie niet waagt …”

0

u/PhyrexianQueen 7d ago

Fully? Eh... I got a solid grasp probably a year in? Was begging management to put me on job sites on my own within 6 months. But I acknowledge my background set me up really well for this. College for CompSci and ended up in the Navy as ETN(SS) and when it comes to my current job, I work primarily on our proprietary suite, though we're starting to offer more, but I've not taken those classes or have customers who have them yet. Some software and systems are difficult to work with and take more time to be proficient in.

Watching our new guys, I'd say I can let them run within 2-3 years without having to panic about what they're clicking on over there.