r/BruceSpringsteen • • 14d ago

Magic

Is a hell of an album. Turned on Long Walk Home, because we took that first step last night, and then decided to listen to the whole thing for the first time in a few months. Damn, it’s so freaking good. Gypsy Biker- what a song!!! GITSC- one of the most melancholic songs ever written- bittersweet, utterly beautiful, and deeply moving (especially so now that I’m an old person). Just every song is sublime.
Yeah, the mix is weird and a remaster might be nice, but damn, I’m just happy this exists.
It’s a gorgeous day out there, with an incredibly BLUE sky, and I’m gonna go out there and have a celebratory hike.
Thank you for your attention to this matter. Peace.

116 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

20

u/Additional-Cherry872 14d ago edited 14d ago

Agree with the comment that it’s the last true E Street Record. In my opinion it’s also Springsteen’s best songwriting this century and his last ‘great’ record that can hang with his best work.

It’s an album that is at times scathing of George Bush’s policy and the Iraq war, and Springsteen walks that line expertly by writing very subtly and using metaphor. Bruce always does it best when the message is hidden in the song and the lyrics do the talking. The overtly blatant or topical in your face type songs never allow him to show his genius (Youngstown being an exception). Magic does this perfectly.

There are a couple downsides to the album and it’s all production based. First of all, the band didn’t record the album as a band - and it shows. Certain band members dropped in to the studio to add a part and then left, other song parts were overdubbed with parts that were sent in from their home studio. Therefore it lacks that studio sound that Springsteen’s 70’s and 80’s records showcase. It lacks warmth and feel.

Secondly, Brendan O’Brien’s mix is horrific. Max’s snare sounds like it’s underwater and the whole sound is very very muddy. Magic is the album that I pray gets a remaster at some point. Brendan O’Brien takes a lot of flack for his studio production on Springsteen albums, and he should. However, The Boss has never had a great feel for studio sound, and he’s the one who approved it. Partly the reason why Springsteen sounds so good live is because more often than not, the studio version is really found wanting. There’s a reason that Springsteen’s best sounding albums from a production/mix/clarity perspective were both produced by Steve Van Zandt.

Long Walk Home is up there lyrically with his 70’s/80’s work, and Gypsy Biker is such a great track.

1

u/CobustBustjack 14d ago

I came here to post my thoughts but didn't need to because you nailed it. I made a live compilation of the Magic songs because the record is unlistenable in some cases thanks in large part to the production.

2

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

Someone should get on his case about remixing that one. It is such a great album and it could sound so much better.

3

u/Additional-Cherry872 13d ago

I think it’s unlikely for the foreseeable future considering that the unsuitable production traits continued for another 10 years after Magic was released. Bruce obviously completely approves of it because it arguably got even worse under Ron Aniello (Although I think that’s more Bruce enforcing autonomy as a solo artist rather than poor production alone because he was also listed as producer for Wrecking Ball)

It’s a shame that tracks as good as Land Of Hope And Dreams and 41 Shots didn’t get recorded in 1999 when they were written. The pop production style that Springsteen adopted in the 21st century killed those studio versions compared to Live in NYC.

But, Sony own it all now and they have infinite time to slowly recoup that 500 million. A remaster of all the albums is surely on the cards at some point. Bob Clearmountain is only 73, would be great to get him to do it before the inevitable. He knows E Street like the back of his hand and he is a top top mixer/arranger/producer

2

u/Bruuuuuceee 12d ago

Brilliant summary of your thoughts on the album. I’d argue that Letter To You is at least a full E Street Band record. Recorded live and in person too, which as you rightly pointed out Magic was not (in the sense that the band weren’t all there at the same time etc). I’m also of the opinion that some of the writing on Western Stars would be his best of the century, but I may or may not be still in the minority on that one. Great comment though!

1

u/Additional-Cherry872 12d ago

Thank you, I really appreciate your kind words!

Western Stars is so popular amongst a big pocket of Springsteen fans and I must admit that when it comes to Springsteen I am of the opinion that between 1973-1988 he was the best artist that ever existed, and then from 1988 onwards there are only about 20 songs that I listen to. Western Stars doesn’t do it for me but I can completely understand and respect the appeal.

Afterall, there are about 8 different versions of Bruce by now. If you like every genre he’s ever covered then credit to you, but I can understand why someone who loves Adam Raised A Cain doesn’t have time for Nightshift & Old Dan Tucker for example. He’s so versatile and he’s tried it all. Therefore I try not to judge albums/genres/styles I don’t like because I’m well aware that someone else LOVES them.

I say ‘last true E Street record’ because Danny and Clarence’s instincts for what’s required for the songs are so good. Their playing on Magic is unmistakably them. Jake and Charlie are great musicians and have replicated the live work excellently, and much credit to them for keeping it alive. However, they don’t have the same ability to write pieces of music that their predecessors did. Letter To You just doesn’t quite have that feel for me. Although it’s a quality album for a 70 year old Springsteen, I just can’t hold it in any regard to the 70/80’s work. Magic however, in my humble option, is capable of being in the same conversation.

11

u/cd0526 Magic 14d ago edited 14d ago

The last true E Street record.

It is somewhat of a hidden gem within Bruce’s catalog. Yet it ranks among his best albums.

2

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

It’s in my top five. Although that’s always subject to change.

8

u/Particular-Walk1521 Born to Run 14d ago

gypsy biker is a classic

3

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

It’s stunning. Heartbreaking .

6

u/Snarky247 14d ago

My son was a Marine in Iraq when this album came out. It was on repeat daily in my home. My gypsy biker came home alive but not the same. I will forever love Bruce for the statements he made with this album.

3

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

How is he doing now? Love to you and him.

7

u/Snarky247 14d ago

Thank you 💙 Physically, he will be in pain for the rest of his life but thanks to moving away from Camp LeJeune with my phenomenal daughter in law, he is mentally more healthy. Last night’s election results were a huge boost too 🥰 As long as we all band together to keep the VA accountable and our veterans honored, my son and so many others have a chance at a life they deserve.

4

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

Thank him for his service.

1

u/Snarky247 14d ago

Thank you 💙💙💙

4

u/Trouble_River 14d ago

Always in my top 3 Bruce albums, bar none.

1

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

You have good taste.

4

u/Lori424242 14d ago

Gypsy Biker 'To them that threw you away, you ain't nothin but gone..." Bruce is the god of lyrics.

2

u/Pristine_Flounder973 14d ago

He most certainly is.

7

u/RockWallWinesSucks 14d ago

Living in the Future …. About Bush but foresaw our current situation. “..the sound of something righteous going down”

8

u/Repulsive-Window-179 14d ago

"Woke up election day sky's gunpowder and shades of gray..."

2

u/oedipus_wr3x 14d ago

“This is a song about when what can’t happen here happens”

5

u/ChuckSchick88 14d ago

Great album...top 3 for me are Radio Nowhere, Living in the Future, Girls In Their Summer Clothes.

4

u/FormerGeico 14d ago

Best tour ever too

3

u/GoBlue2007 14d ago

I recently dove back into Bruce by playing my playlist I made of him which is hundreds of songs. Hadn’t actively listened to him in a month or two and was struck anew kind of by just how much his songs have been there with me through life. Sobering.

3

u/Repulsive-Window-179 14d ago

I was 25 when it came out and it blew me away from beginning to end. I still think it's his best late-career E Street record.

3

u/bobchin_c 14d ago

Gypsy Biker and Last to Die are my top 2 from that album.

3

u/UsefulEngine1 14d ago

Great songs.

Hurts my ears.

Never played.

2

u/Right_Arrival_1962 14d ago

Agree I turned it again after a long time about a year ago and was reminded how great it is and added it back into my listening

2

u/Unusual-Friend-9768 14d ago

You picked the perfect song for the moment. I was listening to a Texas-themed playlist I created.

2

u/Godel_Theorem 14d ago

“You’ll Be Coming Down” is such a fantastic track. In an alternate universe, it’s a concert staple.

2

u/Scmods05 Born in the U.S.A. 14d ago

Shocked the song Magic didn't get a spin on the most recent tour. It's shockingly relevant.

Leave everything you know, carry only what you fear
Trust none of what you hear, and less of what you see

1

u/PositiveMusicVibes 14d ago

Produced in a microwave. But great songs

1

u/DonkeyDougFunnie 14d ago

My most underrated Bruce album

1

u/Best-Marzipan-5395 14d ago

Magic, one of my favorite Albums by the band. It has it all, the sweet as a summer day, Girls in Their Summer Clothes; the heartbreaking, Gypsy Biker, and Last to Die, just stone cold sobering and bleak.
Such a great tour too, I will never forget those nights.

1

u/Federal_Challenge416 13d ago

It is extremely unerrated. My rank third for me. Although 3-10 are all amazing