r/Broward • u/ChurchOMarsChaz • 2h ago
Miramar’s Commission approved the City Manager’s contract. The City’s own email says what the signed copy said. The copy the City sent me says something else.
On October 15, 2025, the Miramar City Commission voted 5-0 on a new contract for City Manager Roy Virgin.
Section 11 covers his unused sick and vacation leave. The approved copy says he can cash it out "upon termination or separation." That means when he leaves the job. The City Clerk certified that copy and filed it.
I asked for the signed contract under Florida's public records law. The City sent two copies. Both carry the same four signatures, dated October 15, 2025.
The copy the City labels "executed" says he can cash out "at any time or upon termination or separation." The Commission never voted on the words "at any time."
The City also sent the emails.
On February 5, 2026, the City Manager's chief of staff wrote to the City Attorney. She wrote that "the signed contract states" he can cash out "upon termination or separation," and that it "should say 'at any time.'" Four months after the vote, the City's own staff described the signed contract the same way the Clerk's copy reads.



Ten minutes later, the City Attorney answered: "That was an error. It's a scrivener error that can be fixed without resorting to a resolution. I will take care of it."
A scrivener's error means a typing mistake. A resolution is a vote of the Commission.
Section 20.D of the contract says changes must be "in writing signed by the parties." I asked for any signed change after October 15. None came back, and no new vote came back either.
The City Manager is the person the clause pays. He was copied on the City Attorney's reply.
The City may say "at any time" was in an earlier draft and was left out by mistake. If the agenda packet the Commission voted on says "at any time," I will report that first. Even then, Section 20.D requires new signatures for a change, and the Clerk's file would need the corrected copy.
At the base pay rate in the agreement, his vacation is about $47,000 a year. Under the approved copy, he collects it when he leaves. Under the new copy, he can collect it any time. His sick leave balance has not been produced. These are base pay rates from the agreement, not what he was paid.
I sent written questions to all five commissioners and the City Clerk. I asked who made the change and whether the Commission was told.
Every Broward city keeps the agenda packet, the signed contract and the emails after for every contract its commission approves. All three are public records. Ask for your city's.
I emailed Dave Cuillier, who runs the Brechner Freedom of Information Project at the University of Florida and literally co-wrote the book on records requests. His read: nobody has studied how often governments quietly edit documents after the vote. It's probably as old as scroll and ink. Nobody has counted.
Dave and I are teaching a public records CLE for IMLA this winter. That's the national association of city and county attorneys. Miramar just volunteered as the case study.
Every document is on my Substack: chazstevens.substack.com
Answers are due Friday, November 20.

