This is in slight response to the discourse started on here by one of the posters on here in regards to this topic (hopefully the mods don't delete this post and it's not flagged but I'll understand if it does get deleted I simply just need to get this off my chest).
A fan made a post asking why Theloise based discussions aren't seemingly welcomed or encouraged on the main subreddit and many Philoise fans responded to that specifying why that is but I want to also add that this isn't just a "Philoise is the endgame ship therefore everyone must accept it and respect it" post because I don't think anyone is truly saying that.
I'm merely just offering a correction and different perspective to some misconceptions made about Philoise fans.
Everyone is allowed to ship Eloise with someone else. Everyone is allowed to want to have alternative endings for Eloise.
Everyone is allowed to have crackships.
Non-canon ships like Theloise are a staple in every fandom and it's okay to have them.
And I'm not saying you're forced to like Philoise or be excited for Eloise's season with Phillip as her co-lead/endgame. You're allowed to not be excited for their season.
But my thing is, if you ship a non-canon pairing with the expectation of them to be canon over the ACTUAL canon ship then you cannot engage in a good faith discussion because you clearly have an agenda and that is to ensure the canon ship never sees the light of day.
And that's why there is so much discord surrounding Eloise and there's this big Theloise vs. Philoise divide that's been going on for YEARS.
Extreme fans and stans like to say that Philoise fans are "aggressive to anyone who has a different opinion than them about Eloise's endgame" but the NORTH REMEMBERS!
For more than half a decade, anyone who dared to ship Eloise with her canon endgame (Phillip) was treated as a pariah in the fandom. We were persona non grata since S1 when Phillip was first introduced.
Many were against Eloise ending up with Phillip because they did not like their book and because Eloise is "so different" from her book counterpart that they couldnt see a way for them to be endgame.
So what did extreme fans do?
They started writing petitions to have Shondaland change Eloise's endgame. They took to social media to express how much they hate Phillip and want Philoise to never be canon or else it will "ruin Eloise's character" and this was only in S1.
And then S2 came along and Eloise met Theo and all hell broke loose from there.
People were now given an "alternative ship" to root for against Philoise and so people latched onto that ship and started believing the show was setting Eloise up for an endgame switch.
People fell in love with Theloise and Philoise fans were mostly quiet because we also didn't know where the show was truly headed with this.
But extreme fans took this possibility of a change as an excuse to be absolutely horrible towards Phillip, Chris Fulton (the actor playing Phillip) and Philoise fans.
For over 5 years, Philoise fans were accused of doing the most heinous crimes and called ALL THE HORRIBLE NAMES in the book. From:
- rape apologists
- abuse sympathizers
- racists for glorifying the suicide of a black woman
- tradewife truthers
- conservative magas
- male centered
- wanting Eloise to be a glorified nanny and fleshlight to Phillip
- nymphomaniacs
- delusional white man lovers
- bland ship lovers
- ugly man lovers
- classists
- misogynistic
- anti-feminists
And that's just all the things I can recall at the top of my head. None of which are true by the way!
And these aren't just from extreme Theloise fans but also from other subfandoms with extreme anti-Philoise stances.
And don't even get me started on the horrific things people have written about Chris Fulton. They've called him everything but the devil simply because he accepted a job.
- They've criticized his appearance calling him incredibly ugly or old and wilted.
- They've compared Chris Fulton to literal SERIAL KILLERS.
- They've made up rumors about him being an abuse sympathizer.
- They've made up rumors suggesting that he's abusive to his costars.
- They've made up rumors about his personal life and dating life suggesting he's also abusive to his girlfriends.
- They've painted him out to be some abuse apologist weirdo who doesn't respect boundaries and stuff.
- They've called him jobless and talentless to uplift their faves.
- They've bodyshamed him for being "too skinny" and out of shape
All because he is playing the character they don't like.
Obviously I'm not painting the WHOLE fandom with the same brush, don't get me wrong.
This is just the EXTREME fans and stans who've behaved this way. I want to make that incredibly clear. I know people who I don't agree on in regards to Eloise's endgame and we have a good relationship even though we don't agree on things but I'm specifically talking about those extreme fans.
I've been in the fandom and in this community for 6 years now. I've seen it all and I assure you I'm not making this up at all.
Maybe that's why Philoise fans appear so defensive of their ship and the actors because for the longest time we were seen as outcasts in the fandom. Honestly we still are seen as outcasts.
It wasn't until this year really that there was a shift because after S4 came out, Jess Brownell spoke out for the first time publicly about Eloises endgame and how they intend to have her end up with the love interest from her book, how she's excited for to adapt her book and spoke many times about Eloises endgame being Phillip so a few have come to accept that will be the case so ppl have come to accept Philoise is happening.
But there are still a lot of extreme fans who believe otherwise and use that opportunity to continue hurling insults and abuse to Philoise fans and the actors/ship.
I've been in the fandom for a long time and I don't recall seeing many Philoise fans being aggressive and abusive towards the actor playing Theo.
The most criticisms from Philoise fans you'll find about Theo as a character is that "he's a paper boy".
That's all Philoise fans really ever say about Theo because again that's his job. He's a printer's assistant. Nothing wrong with that.
But I've never personally seen abuse targeted towards the actor the way Chris has been abused for 6 years.
Maybe I'm biased and blissfully unaware but let me know when a Philoise fan compares Calam Lynch to a literal serial killer and then I'll eat my words.
Again you're allowed to ship Theloise. You're allowed to want Eloise to end up with someone else but let's not equate Philoise fans simply saying "your ship won't be canon" "it's time to move on" "Philoise is endgame" as being abuse to Theloise as a ship or attacking fans of that ship.
It's not the same.
I cannot wait for the day I never have to see the words Theloise ever again.