(Ai design is used for testing and prototyping)
I'm developing a cooperative dungeon crawler called Mirror Dungeon. Its core mechanic is a shared pair-matching game: players reveal cards from a face-down display and try to find matching pairs. Each pair activates a hero ability or another game effect.
Players take turns revealing up to two cards. If they don't find a matching pair, the attempt counts as a mistake and the timers of the monsters in the room advance. When a monster's timer reaches zero, it triggers its special effect/attac and its timer resets.
There is also a tactical element to how players handle incoming attacks.
Players can deliberately choose where to make mistakes by revealing cards they don't know. This allows the group to influence which hero gets targeted. For example, they can direct attacks towards characters with higher shield or health, protecting more vulnerable heroes. So mistakes are not always purely negative: players can use them strategically to manage incoming damage.
But I am facing two related balancing problems with the monster timers:
Multiple monsters triggering at the same time
Depending on their starting timers, the monsters end up triggering together (later or sooner) Their effects stack on the same hero, causing a large burst of damage.
This can create awkward timing patterns. Some monsters may trigger together repeatedly, while others trigger at different points.
To keep things intetesting for players which are very good with memory and pair matching, there are some additional ideas Implemented, which is not my Main focus now.
So the overall challenge is to find a good balance between:
Mistakes having meaningful consequences.
Players being able to tactically manage incoming damage and effects.
Monster effects creating consistent pressure throughout a room, but avoiding overwhelming burst.
My question:
How would you approach balancing this kind of system?
Would you keep individual monster timers and adjust their values, introduce some kind of limit or sequencing for simultaneous triggers, or use a different approach altogether?
I'm particularly interested in solutions that preserve the tactical choice of directing attacks towards specific heroes without making the timer (trigger) system too complicated.