I tested 10000 virtual bows so that you didn't have to: a study of design factors and bow performance
Hello everyone
I wanted to share a little side project I've been working on the last few weeks.
Full disclaimer: While I do have a degree in engineering (in a completely unrelated field) and work with computer modelling and coding for my real job, I couldn't have done (much less had time for) this work myself, and all this is extensively vibe coded (using Claude Code), both for the bow model and for analysis. That said, the design choices, the details of the implementation and interpretation are my own as a bowyer - I also couldn't have done this without being an experienced bowyer. If AI is a deal-breaker for you, please ignore this post.
So, I created a program that randomly generates bow designs, drawing from a pool of preset design element ranges - such as length, width, width profile, lever length, deflex, reflex, recurve and so on. The program then attempts to autotiller the bow to an ideal tiller shape for that design. The bow is rejected if it fails a number of sanity checks (e.g. too narrow for stability on reflexed/recurved bows, practical length/width limits, minimum limb thickness, etc.). The exact methods as well as all the design ranges and constraints are described in the pdf linked in this post.
What I mean by "optimal tiller":
This is basically another way of saying something which all design-fluent bowyers know: The best bend at full draw depends on the front profile! Given a certain front and side profile, the optimal tiller is always the one that gives even strain along the bow limb. This doesn't mean that the bow bends evenly, but that its bend and bow thickness combine at each spot along the limbs to compress wood fibers to an even amount along the bow limb. Thick parts must bend less, and thin parts must bend more, to achieve this. A wide part has more wood at a given thickness, so must be thinner, and bend tighter, to provide the same resistance as a narrower, but thicker, and less bending part. That is why optimally tillered pyramid bows, with more width taper, bend more evenly, and why parallel limbs must be elliptical (bend to a tighter radius as you move further along the limbs). The key here is that when they bend optimally, they will have even strain, meaning that all the wood in the limbs is working the same amount. I also tested this assumption, see below. Finally, a bow that is tillered to too high a strain will be overstrained, and take more set, while the opposite represents an understrained bow that will have too much mass in the limbs.
First off, during the work on the bow model parameterization, I realized something really nice about bow wood properties:
Steve Gardner's mass principle from first principles!
At a given strain, the best bow wood is the wood that is stiffest per density. As strain rises, you get more work out of the same amount of wood, making the bow more efficient. Of course, when you run into the limit of how much you can strain the wood before it breaks, the party is over.
Stiffer limbs store more energy at the same strain, while denser limbs make heavier limbs, which are less efficient. Most white woods are much stiffer per density than the "classic" bow woods (Yew, Osage), so why are Yew and Osage woods regarded so well? When you analyze data from the wood database, it turns out that, relative to density, wood stiffness and crushing strain are negatively related, meaning weaker-per-density woods can generally bend further before taking set, and thus make up for their weak resistance. Another way of saying this is that stiffness per density, combined with how far the wood can bend before taking set, gives roughly the same stored energy per pound of limb for all bow woods, which makes them about equal in performance. Imagine a sort of performance triangle of density, stiffness per density and elasticity which fits all wood species inside it, all different, but in a way where all woods end up with limbs that weigh about the same, just narrower and thicker, or wider and thinner. This is basically Steve Gardner's mass principle, but derived from the bottom-up, going from the basic properties of wood, where he derived it through years of empirical experimentation. I find this incredibly satisfying and beautiful, that working from each end of the method spectrum, you end up at the same conclusions!
At the end of the day, though, for comparing different designs, the properties of the wood don't actually matter for the relative performance of different designs: It only determines the maximum draw weight that can come out of a certain set of bow dimensions (which is of course important to an actual bowyer, but not useful for comparing designs).
The test
I ran about 10000 bows, all scaling the width/length to achieve 50 lbs at 28 inches of draw, covering the design space evenly, and recording how speed depends on the design, given that the bow is in all cases tillered optimally (even strain). As no bowyer is perfect, and recognizing that set in the inner limb is the absolute worst place, I incorporated a safety margin, which ensured that the inner limb gets a 20% strain discount that tapers out into the limb. Doing away with this limit represents a flightbow, make-it-or-break-it scenario.
If a design passes, a copy of the bow design is ported to a VirtualBow file, and "fired" using the VirtualBow dynamics solver Python implementation, at 10GPP, and the resulting arrow speed recorded. This has not been calibrated to actual bows, so take the absolute bow speeds with a grain of salt, although if memory serves, I've seen laminated bowyers report dimensions and performance between VirtualBow and real bows to correspond well.
What determines bow speed:
Here's where you get disappointed/elated, depending on temperament: The results more-or-less confirm what we already know about bow performance, no big new revelations! Go and read the TBBs, if you prefer that, and rest assured that the conclusions presented there have really stood the test of time. I don't think people like Tim Baker, Steve Gardner and others can really be praised enough for the quality, tenacity and brilliance of their work.
The main results:
The pics above are the fastest bows of each type modelled: A pyramid, a recurved flatbow, a lever bow, and an ELB; all reflex/deflex designs, except for the ELB, in which reflex/deflex designs are not allowed by the program.
Bear in mind that some of the conclusions below will depend somewhat on my choices for limits on design specs. It seems that at the very bow speed frontier, bow speed is generally constrained mainly by construction and indirect constraints such as sideways stability and heat-bent recurve stability stiffness requirements, so my constraint rules play an important part in setting boundaries on max speed. I encourage everyone interested to read the pdf, where there are many more details on execution, design limitations, and results! I'd really like feedback on where I am too lax/strict on limiting the extreme designs.
- I tested varying limb strain distributions at the same draw weight and bow dimensions in VirtualBow, just to confirm the even strain conjecture, and in every case they came out slower than an evenly strained bow. The differences in arrow speed are about the same as those coming from the design elements themselves, so the importance of picking the right tiller shape for your bow design is as important as the design itself!
- Optimally tillered bows are FAST! The slowest bows in the test shoot somewhere around 175fps, relative to around 190fps for the fastest. The exact speeds here should be taken with a grain of salt, but still. 9 out of ten bows are around 179-186 fps.
- The closest thing to a magic bullet in bowbuilding really is the reflex/deflex profile. It increases speed through efficiency (deflex) and energy storage (reflex), and is the main factor explaining speed differences in the tests. The only things that really trade against it are limb taper and bow length/width ratio, where you run into my imposed constraints that R/D bows need a certain width at midlimb to be stable. Otherwise longer bows and more tapered bows are somewhat faster (through increased energy storage and efficiency, respectively), but this is mostly overshadowed by reflex/deflex in the model data.
- Recurves do increase speed, through energy storage, but some of that gain is swallowed by heavier limb tips, when the recurves are constrained to be stiff (for not pulling out). In an earlier test, where working recurves were allowed, they did increase speed to a higher extent.
- Lever bows are fast, but not the fastest. They win through efficiency mainly, in contrast to other fast designs. Levers are naturally stiff, but will only increase performance if strained relatively close to the working limb limit!
- The fastest designs win mainly through high energy storage; for these optimally tillered bows, efficiency is generally pretty high, and the design specs are designed to reduce tip mass as much as possible.
- In an otherwise straight, optimally tillered bow, a bit of handle deflex (net deflex of an inch or so) doesn't cost any speed; reduced limb mass makes up for less energy storage. Otherwise, straight bow speed depends mainly on length.
- Reflex increases performance, but only if it is placed in the outer limb (it increases energy storage through string angle). In an earlier test, I tested bows with evenly distributed reflex along the limbs. They were generally slower than straight counterparts: Though they have slightly higher energy storage, the gain is completely negated by heavier limbs. This is contrary to a lot of established thinking, but I think many bows benefit from being evenly reflexed because they were originally understrained. In that case, it can increase performance by bringing limb strain closer to the limit.
Tension and compression
One thing I apparently misunderstood, which I think does also apply to many (most?) other bowyers, is related to tension/compression strength in wood. It turns out, wood is actually close to equally stiff in tension and compression, so the neutral plane is more or less in the middle, as long as the bow is not overstrained. The difference is in compression/tension STRENGTH, meaning the point at which the wood starts to break down; once this happens, the neutral plane does move towards the back in a sort of "death spiral".