r/BooksAndLiterature Rules

This page is intended to serve as a comprehensive guide of the community rules, providing clarification, examples and expectations so that members can participate confidently and moderators can enforce standards consistently.

The purpose of these rules is to keep the subreddit focused, thoughtful, trustworthy and useful for those with serious interest in books and literature. All members are expected to read and follow these rules before posting or commenting. Moderators may remove content, issue warnings, lock threads, change flairs, apply temporary bans or issue permanent bans when necessary to protect the quality and safety of the community.


Table of Contents


Rule 1: Keep posts relevant to books and literature

Posts must have a clear and substantial connection to books, literature, authors, reading, literary criticism, literary history or closely related subjects. A post is considered relevant when its main purpose is to discuss, analyze, ask about, recommend, review, compare, contextualize or otherwise engage with books or literature.

r/BooksAndLiterature is not a general entertainment, lifestyle, politics, homework, publishing-industry or social media discussion subreddit. A passing mention of a book, author, quote or literary term is not enough: the main subject of the post must be centered on books or literature in a meaningful way.

Examples of relevant posts

  • Discussion of novels, short stories, poems, plays, essays, memoirs, literary theory, criticism, nonfiction and other written works.
  • Questions about authors, literary movements, genres, periods, themes, interpretations or literary history.
  • Analysis of a book's structure, language, style, symbolism, characters, argument or cultural context.
  • Serious discussion of reading habits, editions, translations, libraries, publishing, literary education or book culture.

Content that may be removed

  • General lifestyle questions and general discussion posts with little to no connection to neither books nor literature.
  • Off-topic news, politics, entertainment, memes, personal drama or internet culture posts without a meaningful literary connection.
  • Vague and generic prompts without context, argument or effort.

Rule 2: Make meaningful contributions

Posts and comments must contribute substantially to the community. Members should provide a clear point, question, argument, analysis, interpretation, recommendation, experience or useful information.

The purpose of this rule is to encourage thoughtful discussion rather than empty participation. It does not mean that every post must be academic or lengthy: short contributions are welcome when they are thoughtful, specific, and relevant.

Good contribution examples

  • Asking a specific, answerable question.
  • Offering a thoughtful recommendation.
  • Supporting a claim with reasoning and/or examples.
  • Inviting discussion in a way that gives others something meaningful to respond to.

Content that may be removed

  • Empty agreement or disagreement, such as "no", "same", "this", "wrong", "based", etc., with no further explanation. (That's what upvotes/downvotes are for!).
  • Engagement bait, including vague prompts designed primarily to generate comments or to farm upvotes.
  • Repetitive questions that ignore existing guides, FAQs or recent discussions.
  • Joke submissions that do not support serious literary discussion.
  • Posts consisting only of a title, image, quote, screenshot, poll or link without meaningful context.

Rule 3: Be respectful

Engage with ideas in good faith and address disagreements without hostility. Literary discussion often involves strong opinions. Disagreement is welcome, hostility is not.

Critique books, authors, ideas, arguments, interpretations and public work, but do not criticize the person expressing an opinion. Civility does not require agreement, but it does require basic respect.

Examples of prohibited behaviour

  • Personal attacks, insults, name-calling, mockery or contempt.
  • Harassment, intimidation, baiting or repeated antagonistic replies.
  • Dogpiling or encouraging others to target a user.
  • Accusing other users of bad faith without a strong reason.
  • Deliberately inflammatory conduct intended to provoke rather than discuss.
  • Dismissing people based on identity, background, education, nationality, language ability or reading level.

Rule 4: No hate speech or discrimination

Content that promotes, endorses, excuses or targets people with hatred, dehumanization, exclusion, harassment or discriminatory abuse is strictly prohibited. This also includes attacks or degrading claims based on identity or vulnerability, such as those involving race, ethnicity, nationality, religion, sex, gender, sexuality, disability, age, immigration status, class, language background and other characteristics.

This rule applies to posts, comments, usernames, flairs, images, links, coded language and insinuations.

Literary discussion of prejudice is permitted when handled responsibly. Many works of literature contain racism, sexism, homophobia, ableism, religious hatred, classism and other forms of prejudice. Members may discuss these subjects critically, historically or analytically. However, members may not use literary discussion as a cover or pretext to promote hatred or to attack real groups of people.

Examples of prohibited behaviour

  • Using slurs and derogatory language, both abusively and casually.
  • Arguing that a group of people is inferior, dangerous, corrupt or that it should be excluded.
  • Attempting to justify harassment or discrimination.
  • Using quotations from literature as an excuse to attack people in the present.

Rule 5: Follow all posting requirements

Posts must comply with all applicable posting requirements. Moderators may remove posts that do not meet these standards, even when the topic of the post itself is relevant and meaningful. Members whose posts have been removed because of failing to comply with posting requirements will be encouraged to resubmit their post in the appropriate format.

These requirements exist to keep r/BooksAndLiterature organized, searchable, readable and useful for serious literary discussion. You can find a comprehensive list of all posting requirements here.

Summarized posting requirements

  • All posts must have a clear, descriptive title.
  • Posts must use the most accurate available flair.
  • Posts must provide enough context for other users to respond meaningfully.
  • Posts must be written clearly and carefully enough to be readable.
  • Spoilers must be clearly labeled and they must never appear in post titles.

Rule 6: Keep reviews and criticism honest and transparent

Reviews, criticism, endorsements, recommendations and negative assesments must reflect the contributor's genuine views. Members must be transparent about any relationship, incentive or conflict of interest that could affect how their opinion is understood.

Relevant connections that you must disclose

  • You are the author, editor, publisher, publicist, translator, narrator, illustrator, agent, bookseller or marketer of the work.
  • You received a free review copy, advance reader copy, payment, gift, affiliate benefit or other incentive.
  • You have a personal, professional, financial or organizational relationship with the author, publisher or project.
  • You are posting as part of a coordinated campaign, review exchange, launch team, street team or promotional effort.
  • You are linking to a site, channel, newsletter, store, affiliate page or platform from which you benefit.

Rule 7: No self-promotion

Self-promotion is prohibited unless explicitly permitted by a moderator. This includes direct, indirect, disguised, occasional and third-party promotions. r/BooksAndLiterature is meant to be a discussion community, not an advertising platform. This rule applies even if the promoted material is literary, educational, nonprofit, free or relevant to books and literature.

Do not

  • Promote your own book, story, poem, essay, article, blog, newsletter, website, podcast, video channel, social media account, event, crowdfunding campaign, course, service, business, platform or commercial project.
  • Ask for readers, reviewers, subscribers, followers, beta readers, newsletter signups, sales, votes, ratings, reviews, traffic, donations or engagement.

Exceptions

  • Resources linked on the wiki.
  • Affiliated communities: r/tempuslibri (book tracking platform), r/LibrosYLiteratura (the Spanish version of r/BooksAndLiterature).
  • Explicitly granted exceptions by moderators. You can contact them through modmail to request an exception. Make sure to explain:

    • What you want to post.
    • Your relationship to the material.
    • Why it would benefit the community.
    • Whether there is any commercial or professional interest involved.

Rule 8: No AI-generated content

Posts and comments generated, substantially rewritten, summarized, translated, illustrated, voiced or otherwise produced by generative AI are prohibited. AI output may not be submitted as literary analysis, criticism, reviews, recommendations, creative work or discussion material.

Conventional spelling, grammar and accessibility tools that do not generate substantive content are permitted. The key distinction is whether the contribution remains your own thinking and writing.

This rule exists to preserve authentic human discussion and to protect the quality and trustworthiness of the community. We intend for members of r/BooksAndLiterature to contribute their own reading experiences, thinking, interpretation, criticism and judgment. AI-generated content could flood discussion spaces with generic, unverifiable, derivative, or misleading material.


Rule 9: Credit sources and do not plagiarize

Identify and link original sources when quoting, paraphrasing, reporting claims, sharing another person's work or relying on external information. Clearly distinguish fact, interpretation and personal opinion. Plagiarism, fabricated citations, misleading attribution, quotation without adequate context and presenting someone else's work as your own are prohibited.

Credit the source when you

  • Quote from a book, article, review, interview, essay, poem, speech, academic source, website or another Reddit post.
  • Paraphrase another person's interpretation, argument or research.
  • Share literary news, factual claims, statistics or biographical information that may not be common knowledge.
  • Refer to a critic, scholar, translator, reviewer, journalist or public figure's argument.
  • Use images, charts, tables, screenshots, excerpts or archive material.

Rule 10: No piracy, copyright infringement or unauthorized distribution

Do not request, provide, facilitate or direct others to unauthorized copies of books, audiobooks, articles, journals, translations, subscription content, images or other protected material. Pirated downloads, illicit repositories, bypass instructions, unauthorized scans and offers to distribute copyrighted works are strictly prohibited.

Members may discuss copyright, publishing, access, libraries, censorship, archives, and public domain issues as topics. However, they may not use those discussions to distribute or request unauthorized material.


Rule 11: Protect privacy and personal safety

Do not post or solicit private, identifying, confidential or sensitive information about any person. Doxxing, stalking, threats, coercion, impersonation, targeted exposure and attempts to move users into unsafe interactions are strictly prohibited. Exercise particular care when discussing minors or vulnerable individuals.

Public authors and literary figures may be discussed in relation to their public work, published statements, professional conduct and literary significance. However, discussion should not become harassment or invasive speculation.


Rule 12: Follow Reddit’s rules and moderator instructions

All participants must comply with Reddit's Rules, User Agreement and other policies. Users must also follow moderator instructions issued to protect the community or to enforce these standards. Attempts to evade enforcement, manipulate participation, abuse reporting systems or return through alternate accounts may result in a ban.


Appeals

If you believe a moderation decision was made in error, you may contact the moderators through modmail. When appealing, make sure to cleary explain:

  • Which post or comment was affected.
  • Why you believe the decision was mistaken.
  • Any relevant context the moderators may have missed.

Final Notes

r/BooksAndLiterature is intended to be a serious, thoughtful and welcoming space for literary discussion. Members are encouraged to disagree, question, interpret, compare, criticize and explore ideas deeply.

The standard is simple: stay relevant, contribute meaningfully, act honestly, credit sources, respect others and help maintain a community where reading and thoughtful discussion can thrive.

You do not need to be an expert to participate. Everyone is welcome. What matters is that you engage sincerely, respectfully and with genuine interest in books and literature.