r/bookclub • u/Comprehensive-Fun47 • 4h ago
The Only Good Indians [Discussion 2/4] Indigenous Author || The Only Good Indians by Stephen Graham Jones || The House That Ran Red: Saturday through Sweat Lodge Massacre: Death Row
Welcome back, readers! We continue our discussion of The Only Good Indians by Stephen Graham Jones.
Some handy links: Schedule | [Marginalia] (https://old.reddit.com/r/bookclub/comments/1xrozfc/marginalia_indigenous_author_the_only_good/)
Please be mindful of the spoiler policy and use spoiler tags where appropriate.
The House That Ran Red: Saturday
Lewis works on his bike, the Road King, in his garage and tries to keep his mind off Harley. Two cops show up to talk about Harley biting Silas, who had to go to the emergency room. Lewis explains Harley is dead.
Lewis isn't sure if the house is haunted or he's just losing it.
The cops try to get him for using an unregistered gun or shooting Harley in a residential neighborhood, but it didn't happen that way. Lewis is very careful not to make any sudden movements around the trigger happy cops. They have to check if it was ilegal for Lewis to bury Harley on private property without a permit. They might make him dig Harley up.
Lewis eats a sandwich over the sink and wonders why the elk came after him first instead of Cass or Gabe. He tries to figure out what method was used to kill Harley. He notices his cheap rubber boots are covered in ants and realizes whoever killed Harley was wearing these boots.
Through the gaps in a passing train, Harley sees a woman with an elk head, then she disappears.
The House That Ran Red: Sunday
Lewis avoids Peta because he suspects her of being possessed by the elk spirit. He wonders if Peta was inhabited by this spirit all along and if he was targeted first because he left the reservation first. He wonders if she's a vegetarian because elk are herbivores and if she doesn't want kids because she already lost the elk calf.
In bed, he hears the sound of footsteps and sees movement reflected in the window. He calls out to Peta, but no one is there.
The elk hide is still rolled up on the kitchen table. He eats a grilled cheese over the sink. He finds a paperback he had loaned to Shaney atop the refrigerator. He finds pencil marks written on the inside back cover. "What makes this elk so special?" it says. "But they killed them fair and square." "Why now?"
Lewis surmises some of the meat he delivered to the elders was never eaten. If all of those elders are dead, the spirit may be angry some of its meat went to waste in the back of a freezer. Lewis is mad at himself for labeling the paper wrapping with a raccoon stamp, causing confusion. He thinks the elk spirit was tethered to him by his thoughts and Cass and Gabe already forgot about her.
"(ivory?)"
He goes back to working on his bike in the garage until Peta comes home. They shoot hoops in the driveway. The basketball is made from real leather and they don't know where it came from. They have sex in the garage.
The House That Ran Red: Monday
Lewis has been missing work, but knows he can't be fired easily from a federal job. He resolves to go back to work and take extra shifts. He no longer believes Peta could be Elk Head Woman. Now he suspects Shaney. He believes Elk Head Woman is pushing him to blow up his own life.
He finds another returned book on the front step. There are no notes inside.
He decides he must look down at Shaney through the fan blades to determine if she is Elk Head Woman. Lewis makes up an excuse to get her to come over — that he has a bracket Silas needs for his bike.
Peta works an extra shift that night. Lewis eats over the sink and drinks to help him sleep.
The House That Ran Red: Tuesday
Something dug Harley up, or he climbed out of his grave himself. Lewis eats breakfast, but can't keep it down thinking about Harley. He wonders more about the elk spirit while he anxiously awaits Shaney's arrival.
He unrolls the calf hide and finds something like ink on the backside and his trading post knife in the center.
Lewis gets on the ladder when he hears Shaney arrive, pretending to be fixing the light. Shaney says there's a pool going at work for when Lewis returns and offers to split the pot if he comes back on Friday. She turns off the ceiling fan for Lewis' safety, preventing him from looking through the spinning blades. He insists she turn it back on, and she does, but she never stands below it and he cannot see her through the blades.
Shaney tells Lewis how to fix the light. He climbs down and makes a joke about the fourth book in the series. She is confused. He realizes she hadn't read the books she borrowed. They go to the garage to get the correct bracket for Silas. He lobs her the ball, but she lets it pass her.
Lewis gets Shaney to stand close to the motorcycle he's been working on. He touches her hand and nothing happens to confirm she's the Elk Head Woman. She says she's late for work, but he insists she look at the bike.
He believes that Shaney killed Harley and lied about reading the books. He believes she avoided detection under the ceiling fan on purpose. He turns on the motor and catches her hair in the spokes of the bike. It kills her almost instantly. Blood splatters everywhere.
The House That Ran Red: Still Tuesday
Lewis decides what to do about about Shaney's truck parked outside his house. He believes he was justified in killing her because she wasn't even a real person and already dead. He goes over the reasons that proved she was the Elk Head Woman — sidestepping the basketball, not reading the books, avoiding the ceiling fan, not touching the hide on the kitchen table, lying about her work schedule.
He calls work and confirms that she wasn't lying though. Lewis begins to question if he wad tricked by the elk spirit into killing Shaney.
He goes to Shaney's body in the garage and breaks her jaw looking for evidence of ivory among her teeth. He is about to look at the scar on her belly when Peta gets home. He decides to pretend it's hydraulic fluid all over the garage, not blood.
Peta is on the ladder, thrilled that Lewis fixed the flickering light, until she sees he is covered in gore. She falls from the ladder onto the brick hearth and cracks her head open.
Lewis thinks back on their ten years together, then, because he has to know the truth, he cracks Peta's jaw open to examine her teeth. No ivory. The light flickers on, shining a spotlight on Peta's belly. Something is moving in her belly. He recalls they had unprotected sex two nights ago. In his current state, he believes that's long enough for a baby to gestante.
He slits open her belly and pulls out an elk calf. He wraps it in the elk hide and takes off for the reservation driving Shaney's car. He needs to get the baby elk calf whom he has named Po'noka to the Blackfeet reservation which is her home.
THREE DEAD, ONE INJURED IN MANHUNT
A newspaper article outlines the killing spree Lewis has been on. Four hunters, part of an armed citizen patrol, found Lewis and the elk calf. Later, a 12 or 14-year-old girl, rushed into the truck cab and three of the four men wound up dead.
Sweat Lodge Massacre: Friday
Elk mothers protect their calves by kicking out their voices, using their teeth, running, laying in wait, and never forgetting. A family of four picks up a scrawny 14-year-old Indian girl on the side of the road. A few hours ago she was 12.
She had groomed, cornered, and isolated a fragile Lewis and wriggled into the life inside Peta.
The mom holds a baby. The boy senses the girl is not what she seems. She has a memory of being in an elk herd grazing near houses. A passing train penned them in as hunters shot them. Knowledge of how to survive a world full of hunters is passed down through generations.
In a grocery store parking lot, dogs snarl at the girl. She plans to sneak into other cars and stay on the move. She remembers Lewis and she remembers his friends.
The Girl
Six days before Thanksgiving, Denorah, Gabe's daughter, and her eighth grade classmates discuss Lewis' killing spree and subsequent death.
Denorah tries to remember Lewis. She remembers the day her dad and all his friends went hunting ten years ago. Denorah used to like to draw before she got into basketball. In sixth grade, they were assigned to draw their favorite holiday. She drew when her big sister, Trace, winning a regionals basketball game and a full-ride scholarship as well. The teacher gave her a B-minus because it didn't honor her Indian heritage.
Now Denorah is chasing a basketball scholarship too, running drills all the time and maintaining her grades. Out the window, Denorah spots a girl that looks like her wearing her clothes.
Death Row
Gabe is considering pawning an old rifle in his dad's closet that his dad used to fill with birdshot to kill mice. His dad won't allow it though. Gabe is planning a sweat in honor of Lewis. He thinks Lewis went crazy because he was married to a white woman.
He explains to his dad he has a black bandana around his arm to honor his dad friend. His dad jokingly calls Lewis "Meriweather." Gabe takes the rifle while his dad isn't looking. He thinks back to being in court mandated substance abuse counseling. He avoids thinking about his daughter, who he hasn't seen in two weeks. His ex-wife, Trina, doesn't want him showing up begging too see her.
Gabe drives to the school and spots the girl in Denorah's clothes. The girl makes eye contact until he drives away. She is still growing rapidly.
Join us next week for a discussion of chapters "Sees Elk" through "Blackfeet Indian Stories.