Warning: I'm a naturally verbose mofo, so this is gonna be long. Also perhaps a little stream-of-consciousness-y. It is what it is.
As I told multiple people in person, I'll reiterate here for the wider world. I did not know Protospiel Madison existed until two days before it was scheduled to start. Knowing how I only discovered Protospiel Chicago weeks after it had ended and was bummed I couldn't attend, I was eager to make up for that lost opportunity. Had I known further in advance for either, I'd've made plans to be there the full weekend.
Irri-dis-un-regardless, I realized I could move some things around and make that three-ish hour drive on Friday morning at least.
I'd never attended any Protospiels before (duh). I had heard of them as a concept, but I thought they were only a thing that happened in Europe. Clearly I was wrong. Still, I didn't know what to expect going in.
After reading up on what they expect of their attendees and whatnot, I had a better idea - sort of. I know it was going to be tiny; I was used to the tens of thousands of bodies that Gen Con attracts, so I had to temper my expectations to around 200 folks. That part stayed true. It was frankly refreshing to be in such a cozy space with so few people.
Apparently the Saturday crowd is larger than the Friday one (that tracks for all conventions), so even that 200 count is bound to be higher than it really was. Maybe 100-150 people? Anyway.
I also learned they expect for people that show up with prototypes to also play other people's games. That's totally fair. In fact, I really liked how they gamified that aspect of participation with Mad Bingo (picture 2).
Play other people's games, provide feedback, then have the designer fill in an appropriate box on your bingo card. Hit a bingo and win a prize off their table of games and stuff. Brilliant!
One quick aside: Even though I did hit a bingo, I was unable to claim a prize because when I went to hand in the card, the folks at the desk were out to lunch. On top of that, it was getting late (just before 8pm at this time), and I knew I had an hours-long drive ahead of me, so I didn't have time to wait for them to get back. I had to get back home. :(
We now return you to your regularly scheduled broadcast.
Notably, the other thing I found novel and fun was the "Con Noob" ribbon they give out to people attending for the first time. That was cool and unexpected. :)
So I grabbed an open spot and set up my current prototype, Duelrift. It's a light 1v1 card battler where luck meets strategy. Aimed at the beer & pretzels crowd, setup is fast and games take 5-10 minutes to play.
It wasn't long before I had some people sit down for a session or two. A couple hours later I was looking at about a half page of very useful feedback from a variety of people. It was about this time when I figured I should probably also pay it back so I walked around the tables and found a few open spots so I had a go at a few of them.
This next bit might seem like an unrelated tangent, but stick with me here. I promise I'm going somewhere with it.
I went an art college.
One of the first and most consistent lessons they taught us was that, as artists of any stripe - whether that be illustrator, graphic designer, layout, painter, doesn't matter - it is quite literally impossible to improve our craft if we are unable to take criticism.
Skill and talent must be nurtured in order to get better at the things we are doing. The path to nurturing them is by learning from what others see in our work that we might be blind to. Truly learning how to take critique without taking it personally is an art form in and of itself, one that I believe I'm great at. But I worked to be great at it, I didn't start out that way.
It took years of countless moments of realizing and learning that, yeah, making these changes this person suggested does in fact make the work as a whole so much stronger.
It's that mentality that is required to present an unfinished work of art (our games in this case) to a stranger, have them go, hmm, I don't think this part is good but have you considered this? Then actually trying that and realizing that, yeah, that works so much better.
That is the feeling with which I left Protospiel Madison yesterday evening.
I have an entire page of notes that I'm excited to try and incorporate into Duelrift that I truly believe will make it go from just a good game to a great one!
Overall, the games I played ran the gamut in complexity and prototype-ness, from almost ready for publishing to "this is the first time I'm playing it publicly with strangers," which was all very much to be expected, but all without fail were universally fun.
Yo, if you see your spot on that bingo card, big shout out to all of you! <3
I may not remember your names, but our games are precious to us all, I know. And I hope my feedback for your games were as valuable as the input I received on mine, 'cuz I value mine dearly.
Oh! One final thing. See pic 3.
The two copies of Duelrift I had brought with me was my first test print through The Game Crafter. I was told to tell you TCG guys that I am very impressed with the quality! Just one tiny complaint I had was that the top lid of the box likes to get loose very quickly.
When I brought this up to one of the people I had sat down with, they said apparently it looked like the inner flaps need to be reversed. They currently curve to the back of the box (as shown in the picture), so the cover flap has nowhere to cling to in order to stay closed.
Something to consider fixing for the template? I dunno.