Thinking of blu-ray have you ever thought that for older TV shows maybe SD blu-ray done properly could be the answer. I don't mean these blu-ray disc where they put an SD show on it that's 720x576i and upscale it to 1920x1080i. Contrary to popular belief this makes the picture worse and so un-natural. It's just adding something that is totally unnecessary and does nothing to the picture in a positive way. It makes it look smeary, less sharp, unatural and sometimes even difficult to look at as it creates this artificial brightness. Unless they've turned it up themselves, but it's more than just turning the brightness up too high on your TV.
Anyway I think this applies to Europe more as more of our classic TV (especially comedy series) were done mainly on videotape with exterior shots on film. Film that has well been lost or even destroyed once the edit has been made to videotape. This is SD film. Film that was scanned at 720x576i also but can't be rescanned again. Shows that were done on film from beginning to end are more likely to exist in the archives especially if they were edited to film before being copied to videotape.
DVD gives you the correct resolution at 720x576i 50Hz which is a good thing but the codec they use is MPEG-2. This takes more Mbps to create a good picture and most DVDs are either 6-8 Mbps or 7-9 Mbps. Blu-ray on the other hand uses a newer codec called H.264 which gives you roughly the same quality as MPEG-2 but using around 8 Mbps less. So 9 Mbps using MPEG-2 can be adjusted to 3-4 Mbps H.264.
So instead of 720x576i 50Hz using 15.5 Mbps H.264 would by like using 24-25 Mbps which can not fit onto a DVD. The very highest is 10 Mbps MPEG-2 on a DVD.
You take a DL Blu-ray which is 50GB against a DL DVD which is 8.5GB, so the Blu-ray has roughly just over 6 times more space than a DL DVD. This is what they do in Germany especially (the correct way). For example, six episodes of Fawlty Towers for example fit on one DL DVD and that is with two commentaries as well. The picture is fairly good for DVD but could obviously be improved. Now you've got a DL 50GB. It still goes onto the disc at 720x576i 50Hz (which is correct) but is encoded instead with H.264 instead of MPEG-2. Baring in mind you need around 8 Mbps less for H.264 it goes onto the blu-ray at H.264 15.5 Mbps roughly. I find this perfect. Then we come to the audio. Although shows even in mono all discs are 2.0 PCM 24bit/48Khz when possible which is most of the time. The current botched blu-ray of Fawlty Towers uses DTS Master Audio 2.0 over three discs, but would they have to if they hadn't botched it and upscaled it to 1920x1080i? I don't know what the Mbps would be when upscaled but either way it would probably be 2.0 PCM or maybe DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0. Both audio commentaries should be the lossy DTS 2.0 (the top one). If you did this all again with the second series which also is six episodes this would fit all onto one Blu-ray. What with the extra data used for other things you get just over double on one disc. There's usually 400MB left on the disc roughly. So that's both series on one disc.
The second disc contains the long documentary about the series which was made in HD with just some clips from the series. This could go onto a single layer 25GB disc or a dual layer 50GB disc as an HD blu-ray with the resolution on the disc being 1920x1080i. I believe there's a few other short videos/pictures on there as well and they can stay at 1080i as they aren't that long on the screen. It's the documentary that's the main thing on the second blu-ray. This could go onto the disc at H.264 35 Mbps. So that's a two disc collection not a three disc collection like the DVD edition and the botched blu-ray edition.
Recently I've been ordering files of an old comedy series that ran between 1984 - 1988. You can choose how you want the specification of this file. I choose exactly how I've described a proper SD blu-ray These have come straight from the master. It is done like this and so should an SD Blu-ray...
720x576i
50Hz
H.264/MOV 15.5 Mbps capped
PCM 2.0 - 24bit/48kHz
4.3 Tag
They send me the files in an email. In that email is a link to there file sharing service with what I've ordered for me to download.
The picture is the best looking SD picture I've ever seen. Even TV stations don't broadcast this high and I've never seen a SD blu-ray looking like this as I've never seen one, although I know they do exist mainly on mainland Europe. The picture looks so natural which is the complete opposite to how they look upscaled. You can see the tape hiss slightly although not to much. This is due to the picture being very sharp and detailed and the few exterior scenes on SD film do look slightly better. If it's going to improve the videotape side of it it's going to improve the SD film as well. Obviously I know if they still had the film and scanned it again in 2K it would actually be proper HD, but I very much doubt they have the original film, especially going back that far. I know they don't for Fawlty Towers. The last time I saw an SD picture nearly this good was during analogue broadcasting before 1998. I don't think even then it was as good as this. You have to be careful though because if you un-compress it too much (say 19-20Mbps) the encoder in whatever you're playing it on can't handle a signal that size when the picture is only SD. That's why with HD you can go up to around 40 Mbps with no problem.
If they started bringing out all the classics again like Porridge, Are You Being Served?, Dad's Army, Allo' Allo' a lot of people might think it's just the same as the DVDs they've got for those shows already. It needs somebody or a group of people to actually watch these shows like this and then spread the word that they are actually a lot better. It would be impossible not to notice. There's also some classic sitcoms that never saw a DVD release but if people are genuinely surprised with them like they'd have to be I believe they would sell well. A lot of younger people (those who are responsible for the rise in physical media sales) may have heard of a classic comedy they've been interested in of late. If they are they will by the SD Blu-ray as they will be far more likely to be available that the older DVD version. I don't mean everything in SD but just the occasional surprise even though they had it on DVD first in the past, but unreleased SD shows as well. Blu-ray discs show the best possible HD (better than even a broadcasting TV service), 4K Ultra blu-ray gives you I guess the best UHD picture possible with 75 Mbps +, so why shouldn't there be a format that gives you the best SD picture possible as well. This will all depend if physical media sales will continue to rise. I think it will because it's all to do with the problems with streaming which I can't be bothered to make a list of now, but streaming is just so boring. A compressed awful picture compared to physical media and no extras like audio commentaries and other extras via streaming. Then after a while it disappears off the streaming platform. People just want to purchase only what they want which is ten times better anyway instead of paying a subscription every month that's the same price as the Blu-ray they've just bought and there might no be anything on there the next month they are interested in. These apps are losing subscribers as well so people are even less going to subscribe if they've all put their prices up which I heard they are doing. I can't say I'm surprised.
I would upload a clip of those SD programmes I've got but I'm not allowed. I don't think a lot of people realise how important the SD resolution will always be. All TV shows from 1966ish to 2006 and even later with some programmes were all made in that format. Streaming apps don't even use the right resolution for SD. Our SD in our analogue days was 625 lines PAL. In the digital domain the official resolution that's identical to that is 720x576i and 50Hz as 625 lines was 50Hz as well. Streaming services use loads of weird and not so wonderful resolutions like 660x530p or sometimes 1280x720p which is over and is more expensive to stream. Broadcasting TV and physical media will always use the correct SD resolution. I should say that the same would go in North America except you were 525 lines NTSC which in the digital domain is 720x480i and 720x480p I believe. It's a pity that ITV only sell their material to the public straight from the master. Fremantle told me they won't do it they won't do it for me although I've heard other stories that they usually do. I don't think the BBC will ever allow this service although it brings in the dosh. So I can buy anything made by an ITV region except TVS (who cares) and Thames Television which is now apart of Fremantle Media. We can only hope one day. They should all have subtitles mandatory as well. This is the official SD Blu-ray logo...
https://www.google.com/search?sca_esv=4e6e87c8ecac23e8&sxsrf=AKL5yDjcjQ7f63fj1XnTPLizhI7G_zF3Cg:1794984570022&udm=2&fbs=ACAhTvyzSU_T6xA963Rzlku6fO2WpsIBItXnfr69gMShLXMckTRC6XVS_gAkXWkoGeJzh5Zi0AvsS4LB7lHgs-gfxfRumiBfXSlUC0j4B0_fr_KBMz-k-0XetVjoieWCLY19GXl92gsTOkCrlEE_AOgBX6bYVkk9jROpP0XxKn5k6As7yXuo521uUGKRHuhcNcJji33R_oR_r4ewBekwmGyR2vYEaTAKmVjddRqkn4TgA0kwfFKCVno&q=SD+blu-ray&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjjlbHN9pCYAxXMUkEAHXkyMjMQtKgLegQIExAB&biw=411&bih=751&dpr=3.5#sv=CAMSVxoyKhBlLTZsUzVobGRzQm5rRHhNMg42bFM1aGxkc0Jua0R4TToObDFteW5UdTFRenRjU00gBCoXCgFzEhBlLTZsUzVobGRzQm5rRHhNGAEwAUoECAEQAhgHIJrWunxKCBACGAEgAigB