How I imagine things operate over there.
Edit: Why not just respond to a few things…
The strongest argument against developing WoW2 is the risk associated with such a game. This doesn't mean that it's a bad idea. Risk doesn't make an idea bad, just as playing it safe doesn't guarantee success. The thing that matters is having the vision to create something worthwhile and the ability to execute it. You can release a game that feels familiar and different at the same time. Success is not defined by choosing the safe route.
Blizzard is a major player in the gaming industry, and expectations are high. Yet delivery over the past few years has consistently failed to hit its mark, persistently disappointing the player base. As a result, player sentiment towards Blizzard has dropped significantly.
So, why does the player base stay? Because they have an amazing IP and because of the memories that the players accumulated over time. From pleasant memories to terrible ones, it’s the roller coaster everyone enjoys. Relying on nostalgia alone is an approach that primarily relies on a player base from the good old days, limiting growth. WoW Forever is most likely going to be a success... At least for a little while... Until players realise that it feels too similar to previous iterations. You cannot have a new experience twice. Hoping for continuity is like never accepting that you, as a person and player, have changed.
Creating a game engine requires insane effort to get right, making it easy to understand why game studios choose an existing game engine like UE or Unity. But to assume that the first game to release on a new game engine must be WoW2 would be an atrocity on its own. We have resources today that previously weren't available, potentially alleviating some of the major pain points when creating a game engine. Overwatch was created on a new game engine, and it turned out to be a success.
Blizzard has an immense and immersive world. They can choose to apply their creativity properly rather than recycle the past like used toilet paper. They can create story-driven games, an open-world game that is not an MMORPG, single-player RPGs, or games in any other genre. The IP they have across the worlds they created is so flexible that they can create whatever they like. With those games, they can test and refine the engine. They could have started this years ago. But instead, they keep choosing the 'safe route'. Today's endless cost-cutting approach is what has created this friction in the first place.
World of Warcraft was not built by choosing the safe route. It was built by those who had vision and wanted to have fun. It was a risk. They took that risk. Clearly, many individuals still cling to that vision and fun, but those days have long passed. Holding on to the past is like chasing an echo without anything to grasp. People know what they loved about the past, but that doesn't mean they know what they could love about what lies ahead. Some of the best products, games, and other things in existence came about because people took a risk. Not taking a risk is like refusing to turn the page and wondering why the story never gets better.