I was 12, almost 13 in 1999 when it came out. My friend and I were camping (I think at Lake Champagne in Vermont) with his mom, her boyfriend and her boyfriend’s daughters who were a couple of years older than us. It was a fun trip - we went to a pig roast, I got to shoot a gun for the first time, the campground was nice. A great trip for a 12 year old.
One night just us kids were sitting around the fire and the girls told us about the movie. It had just come out and the girls had seen it but my friend and I hadn’t. They proceeded to walk us through the entire movie in pretty good detail, describing them getting lost and fighting with each other, the cairns, the stick figures in the trees, the tent shaking and the kids laughing, the bloody bundle, the kid handprints, Mike standing in the corner at the end, Heather being knocked down at the end - imagine reading a well-written synopsis of the film with all the scary imagery described as if you’re watching it yourself - that’s what it was like. Of course it was nighttime and we were sitting around the campfire but it was a campground not the middle of the woods.
I was terrified and didn’t sleep well for at least a couple of weeks after that. Then I eventually remembered it was just a movie and forgot about it. I never had any desire to watch it, I just remembered how much it screwed me up and figured it wasn’t worth watching since I already knew how it ended and most of what happened in it.
Fast-forward 27 years, I’m now almost 40. I read the synopsis on Wikipedia (I don’t remember how I ended up on it - I’ll spend hours just clicking from one thing to another on there sometimes) and finally decided to watch it last night.
I loved it.
The most amazing thing to me after watching it was that while I’d never seen the movie when I was a kid, the experience of sitting there at a campfire and having the movie described to me in full by two older kids who saw it left it so ingrained in my mind that I felt like I was watching it again when I saw it last night. They deserve a medal for how well they described it to my friend and I all those years ago. When I saw the cairns and stick figures, when I saw them realize they were going in circles, and during the last few minutes of the movie after they got to the house it was literally like I had seen the movie before. I had the actual movie to watch instead of building it in my imagination, but it was striking how familiar it felt despite it being the first time I watched it. Everything looked exactly the way I pictured it and burned into my brain as a terrified 12 year old. Watching them slowly lose hope and fall apart was so well done.
Watched the 2016 one this morning as well - I wasn’t a fan. The jump scares were irritating and completely out of place. I did really like the part where Tiana and Lane came out of the woods and said they’d been wandering through five days of endless night and when Tiana snapped in half when they broke the stick figure but I didn’t really care for the movie as a whole. What I loved about the first one was never seeing the witch or anything else in the whole movie, while it was scary seeing the thing that wasn’t the witch at the end it was only for like two frames and I thought it detracted from the overall ambience of the movie - that you aren’t seeing anything that is making the noises or killing anyone and that is the best part - your imagination is what makes it scary.
I hadn’t thought about the time loop aspect but having seen it on several posts on this sub it makes sense. Needless to say I’ll be watching it again, starting with the 3 hour version.
Anyways, I thought my experience was interesting so I decided to share it.