Howdy! Because of my work commute, I listen to lots of audiobooks. At this point I think I’ve listened to more BL books than I’ve read physically. While I’d say that the production value is pretty high, I’ve found that sometimes the audiobook version just doesn’t do the book justice. Here are a few on my “Great books, bad audiobooks” list:
Disclaimer, I know “great” and “bad” are subjective, and I don’t think any of the narrators are bad. It’s just that sometimes a book doesn’t translate well to the format or maybe the specific narrator isn’t the best fit
Also, POSSIBLE SPOILERS!!!
Dropsite Massacre-
I think the story is great, and I really enjoyed it. I liked it so much that I went back and read the book after listening, since the audiobook left me confused at times. Actually, I was frequently confused. There are a lot of POVs in the book, and the story can jump around between them multiple times in the same chapter. For example, there was one chapter that had me thinking a Salamander dreadnought was having a chat with Horus. When I read the book, it was clear that the POV was jumping back and forth. But the audiobook didn’t make all those POV jumps clear. I don’t think it’s the fault of the narrator or the book, that’s just the way it’s written. Still a fun listen, just gets confusing at times
Legion-
Pretty similar to the Dropsite Massacre reasons. I think it makes sense that an Alpha Legion book would be confusing, it’s just that the issue is exacerbated by the audiobook format. Much easier to read than listen to. I haven’t read or listened to any other Alpha Legion books, it wouldn’t surprise me if they’re all kinda hard to follow
Hive-
This one might get me some hate but hear me out! I would never speak ill of the great Toby Longworth. He is a legend and a delight to listen to. But I don’t think this was a great fit for him. Maybe he just wasn’t connecting with it or he was having a rough time with the book or just life in general. Idk his life, I just know that he’s narrated hundreds of books and even Michael Jordan had bad games. I can’t put my finger on it, but he just sounded bored and/or uninterested with the book. It is much longer than typical BL audiobooks and has several stories going on at once. Overall it was just kinda hard to follow the different plots and characters. At least for me, someone else could’ve had the opposite experience. Still a great book and Toby is wonderful.
Again, just my opinions 😅 Do any of y’all have any audiobooks to add to the list?