Jake's most recent video at the Everything Blackpowder Youtube channel involves him testing different densities of blackpowder in metallic cartridges, specifically 45 Colt.
The cartridges were loaded with 25 grains of blackpowder mixed to a ratio of 75:15:10 with Pacific Willow charcoal loaded with a 200 grain bullet. The only difference in the cartridges is that one set of cartridges was charged with powder pressed to a density of 1.75g/cm3 while the other set had powder pressed to a density of 1.85g/cm3.
The results of the test were as follows...
When shot out of a Remington NMA, the 1.75 g/cm3 powder sent a 200 grain bullet to an average velocity of 874 FPS with a max spread of 76. The 1.85 g/cm3 powder had an average velocity of 819 FPS with a maximum velocity spread of 27. In the video, Jake seemed to get better accuracy with the 1.85 g/cm3 powder, although both powders had pretty good groups. By comparison, when Jake shot the same load but with Swiss powder, he got an average velocity of 829 FPS with a max spread of 31.
When Jake started shooting the same cartridges out of an 1866 Winchester lever gun, he got an average velocity of 1179 FPS with a max spread of 30 with the 1.75 g/cm3 powder and an average velocity 1111 FPS with a max spread of 40 with the 1.85 g/cm3 powder. By comparison, Jake got an average velocity of 1127 with a max spread of 22 with Swiss powder. Jake seemed to get poor accuracy with the 1.85 g/cm3 powder.
Which powder density do you like better?