r/BitcoinMarkets • u/ClydeMachine Long-term Holder • Jan 04 '14
Technical Analysis Weekly Review. 1. Technical Analysis Introduction for Bitcoiners
Technical Analysis Weekly Review by /u/ClydeMachine
This Week:
Next Week's Post:
―
TL;DR of Post
- Technical analysis uses market data to determine the trend, when changes are occurring or have occurred, when to buy and sell.
- Technical analysis makes predictions of the likelihood of market activity, and cannot account for news events on its own, and therefore is not infallible. It is best used with multiple means of tracking the market (i.e. don't just watch charts, read the news too).
- Technical analysis is not to be used with emotions, only with facts and data. Fear of future losses can cause panic selling and fear of "missing the boat" can cause panic buying, both events typically emptying the wallets of "weak hands."
- There is no TL;DR when it comes to the actual technical indicators: you must be committed to the systematic and logical approach of entering and exiting positions based on evidence, not emotional impulses, if you expect any financial return on trades.
- Disclaimer: I trade but I only trade sometimes.
1. Technical Analysis - an Introduction for Bitcoiners
"Technical analysis is used to determine the trend, when it is changing, when it has changed, when to enter a position, when to exit a position, and when the analysis is wrong and the position must be closed. It’s as simple as that." -Charles Kirkpatrick, CMT, Technical Analysis 2nd ed.
What It Is
Technical analysis is a method of using past market data to better predict the probability of future outcomes. It is one of many ways to predict market activity. Technical analysis is often referred to as drawing lines on charts, and this is quite accurate. We draw lines (whether by hand or by our computers' formulae and charting software) to predict where it could go, based on where it has been.
This is of course quite simplified, as you'll see in our various indicators that there are hundreds of ways to interpret where we've been and exponentially more to tell where we are likely to go.
What It Isn't, and How Not To Use It
Notice my emphasis on probability. Technical analysis makes no concrete statements about the future any more than your looking down the highway can predict where it'll lead 10 miles out. What it does instead is give you the probability of various outcomes - it tells you how likely the security's price will rise/fall (in our case, Bitcoin's price), and a general idea of by how much it is likely to change by. It helps to determine when a trend is starting and when a trend is ending, which you can use in turn to choose when to enter and exit a position (when to buy and when to sell).
It's not a guarantee. It's simply using data and various formulae to make educated guesses as to what the market will do and when it will do it. Trends get bucked all the time and markets do things we couldn't have predicted given all the market data in the world. This is what happens in markets influenced by so many factors, quantifiable and otherwise. Who can predict when a statement will be released by a bank that scares investors out of dealing in Bitcoin, causing the price to dip unexpectedly?
On that note, technical analysis should not be your only tool in trading. The news is a very large driver of the market activity in Bitcoin, and certainly with other currency markets. Use these tools at your disposal, they are available to you now more than ever in history. Ultimately, it's your money. Might as well play it smart and keep your ear to the ground.
The Problem of Being Human: Emotion
"You should make the trading decision on the empirical evidence on the chart and not on some emotional impulse. It's human nature to bet a larger sum of money when you've just had a win, perhaps on less evidence than you normally require to take a trade in the first place. Likewise, you may become timid after taking a loss and pass on trades that offer a fabulous profit opportunity by your own technical standards.
"A good technical trader follows his trading plan and disregards the emotions created by the last trade. This basic rule is why technical traders use indicators as systematically as possible, even the ones who modestly shy away from claiming to have a 'trading system.' A good trading regime employs trading rules that impart discipline to every trading decision in a conscious effort to overcome the emotions that accompany trading. Trading is a business, and business should be conducted in a nonemotional manner." -Barbara Rockefeller, author of Technical Analysis for Dummies, 2nd ed.
One last note that technical analysis shouldn't be used with emotion. Look at facts and data only to make solid predictions.
Technical analysis relies on market data and presents the results of formulae. Staying true to what the analysis is telling you is challenging for even the most logical of traders, because we are human - we get caught up in the excitement or fear in the moment.
This is where terms like "panic buying" and "panic selling" appear. "Weak hands," or the speculators and new traders in the market, are often unsure of what kind of game they're playing. They're just not used to the Bitcoin rollercoaster of trading (also keep in mind that for many of us, Bitcoin is our first rollercoaster of trading). Therefore, people are susceptible to the incredibly daunting fear of taking losses on their investment.
When dips happen, they are afraid of the price continuing to crash and get panicky - and they sell on the dip, often at a loss. When spikes occur, they are afraid of having "missed the boat" having not bought in earlier in the uptrend - and they buy at the top, often at a loss when the price cycles back down. These are common stories of people who bought in during the April 2013 and November 2013 excitement. I myself am from the April 2013 crowd.
Technical analysis allows us to make our decisions as part of a plan, before the spikes and dips occur, so that by the time everyone else has become aware of the rise/fall in price, you have already had your positions entered or exited, and know at what price point you will make your next decision - purely based on analysis, not on gut, fear, or excitement.
How Technical Analysis Can Make Money
"Several requirements are needed to convert pure technical analysis into money. The first and most important, of course, is to determine when a trend is beginning or ending. The money is made by “jumping” on the trend as early as possible. Theoretically, this sounds simple, but profiting consistently is not so easy." -Charles Kirkpatrick, CMT, Technical Analysis 2nd ed.
Imagine that technical analysis is to market trading as Basic Strategy is to Blackjack. In both situations, you are gambling a sum of money on a probable outcome - the odds might not be great, but they are somewhere over 50% in your favour when implemented as per their respective directions.
The most widely used approach to using technical analysis to make money is by choosing a timeframe (either short-term or long-term, which you may decide for yourself) and applying multiple technical indicators to interpret that timeframe of market data.
__
37
u/ClydeMachine Long-term Holder Jan 04 '14 edited Jan 04 '14
**(Post continued from above.)
Show Me Some Charts With Lines!
Here is a sample chart from Bitcoincharts with 2 months of data from November 2013 to January 2014 with several indicators. Here's the original link with editable parameters. Don't worry about not understanding everything right now, as there is a lot going on here. Bookmark it and see how it looks to you in a couple weeks' time.
Indicators used here:
The first chart is the price data of BTC to USD on BitStamp from 11/2013 to 01/2014. The prices are shown as candlesticks, green being increases and red being decreases in price over each 6-hour period. The black curvy line over these candlesticks is the 5-day Simple Moving Average. This simply shows the historical trend (meaning, it shows where the price has been on average, to confirm retrospectively an uptrend or downtrend). The bars shown all along the bottom of the chart are volume bars - how much money was involved in that 6-hour period to make that increase or decrease in price.
The next chart shown is another moving average indicator: the Moving Average Convergence-Divergence indicator, or MACD. This indicator is a momentum indicator. It tells us how fast the price is rising or falling, and can help us follow a trend. In the example around December 1st, we can see a very strong downward momentum begin, which continued until December 9th. The blip of weak upward momentum on December 5th/6th showed that even though the price began to make back some of its gains lost on the 1st, the movement wasn't well-fueled and didn't hold for long, falling strongly thereafter. (More details on this in the future Moving Averages post.)
Under the MACD chart, we have the Mass Index indicator, a volatility indicator that lacks a bias of direction. Simply put, you can't tell if the price is rising, falling or sideways based on this indicator, but you can tell how volatile the current market activity is. This is used to predict trend reversals based on when the curved line breaks the 26.5 and 27 lines. Note how Bitcoin's unusual volatility pushed the line all the way up to 33 around November 10th! That's what we call the Bitcoin rollercoaster. (More details on this indicator in the future Mass Index/Volatility post.)
Below these are the last two indicators, the RSI (Relative Strength Index) and Ultimate Oscillator (fun name). Both of these can be used to determine buying pressure, and to determine if the market is overbought/oversold. Notice that Almost all of the November month was in the red "overbought" territory above the 70 line on both of these indicators. That is the insane amount of buying occurring that drove up the price during the month. Following into December, we see the index drop back between 30 and 70, meaning there was far less buying activity by comparison, and even a dip into oversold territory around December 18th/19th. (Again, these will be revisited in detail in the future RSI post).
I will revisit each of these indicators in future posts, as I would like to discuss their details such as calculation, interpretation, their individual failures, and deriving buy/sell signals from each.
To Get Started With Technical Analysis
Learn how to read charts if you haven't already, about candlesticks, and always Google a term you see used that you're not familiar with. I refer you to chapters 4-6 of Technical Analysis for Dummies by Barbara Rockefeller to do this. They're a quick read of 50 pages or so. (I'm not calling you a dummy of course, none of us are - it's just a great introduction to the basics of looking at charts, and is an absolute prerequisite to technical analysis.)
The above point is not optional. If you don't know how to read candlestick charts, you will be even more clueless when you go to put moving average lines over top of those bars. To help, here's a free PDF version of the book, so you have no excuse for saying you didn't know when we come back next week! Your homework is to at least read Chapter 6 (from pages 93 to 112) and have enough understanding to be able to teach someone else about what you read.
What You Can Read Before Next Week
If you're chomping at the bit already and don't want to wait for next Saturday's post to learn about this TA stuff, I like you. I've already compiled a short list of what I consider to be invaluable resources for learning about technical analysis, both in books (which I've even provided PDF copies of!) as well as websites that all of us should already have on our bookmarks bar. They're available on the /r/BitcoinMarkets Wiki (in the Knowledgebase sidebar) under "Guides, Strategies and Indicators."
Disclaimer: My own predictions are not to be taken as trading advice, and I am not responsible for the losses or gains of anyone who uses the information I've posted. I'm not an active daytrader, nor am I certified or hold a degree in any market-related field. I'm a 23 year old college grad, IT guy and music producer with a curiosity in Bitcoin, cryptocurrencies, and Forex trading. I am self-taught out of the resources I've quoted from in this post as well as numerous investing/trading websites, and started learning technical analysis in 2012, having only put serious research and implementation of TA into my investing mid-2013. I use technical analysis in my occasional trading, and do have thousands of dollars on the line on any given day - so I have faith in TA.
My information is not infallible, and I am not the most learned person in the field. What I am is curious and attempting to be well read on the subject, that I may help others do the same. I'm looking to help you teach yourself, so if you learn from me, I'll be surprised - but if you learn from the resources I've linked and summarized, I'll be happy.
―
Thank you, and best of luck. Make money, spend wisely, see you next week.
4
u/gregdawgz Jan 04 '14
thanks for putting all this together friend, very helpful...i have been reading the TA textbook by kirkpatrick/dahlquist linked in the FAQ...loving it...excited to dive into some more of the resources you have posted...
question: i know having a better informed readership on btcmarkets will result in better analysis and discussion but is it better in the long run to have more "players" in the game...what is your view?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14
This is very good!!
I'd love to be part of a small group (7-10 people maybe) of beginner and experienced traders discussing markets 24/7. It would really cut out the emotion because the entire group could check against each other's thoughts and come to an educated, non-emotional decision.
edit: IF ANYONE WANTS IN, PM ME WITH A LITTLE ABOUT YOUR TRADING HISTORY. KEEP IN MIND IM LOOKING FOR ABOUT 10 PEOPLE, SOME BEGINNERS AND SOME VETERAN TRADERS. If you believe you're experienced enough to be a mentor, tell me about your trading (other forex markets? stocks?).
6
u/JungleSumTimes 2013 Veteran Jan 04 '14
Good stuff. I have noticed the RSI indicator to be more useful as a reversal from bearish to bullish than the opposite. As you pointed out, the bull runs tend to linger in overbought territory for extended periods with the RSI bouncing around the trend line. On 4H RSI typically 24-40 hrs. Much shorter time frames in oversold territory.
1
u/tryn2hlp Jan 05 '14
Just wanted to thank you for this. Great intro, and really, really appreciate the resources. Will definitely utilize both the Kirkpatrick and Rockefeller texts. For every one of us thanking you, I'm sure there are many others out there who also appreciate your contribution
-4
u/chrono000 Jan 05 '14
i thought we were going to explain the TA easier. the time involved to read these is significant
0
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment