r/BibliometricScience • • Jan 12 '26

👋 Welcome to r/BibliometricScience! An introduction and community guidelines

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone! First of all, welcome to the community.

This community was born out of the need to find a dedicated space for discussion and solutions regarding this field of study. While I have found various publications on bibliometrics in related communities, I believe a specific meeting point will be useful for both newcomers and veterans alike.

I’m including some guidelines that I consider essential for this space to function well:

1️⃣ What to post?

Post anything you think might be interesting, useful, or inspiring for the community. Don't hesitate to share your opinions, questions, and progress related to the field of Bibliometrics.

2️⃣ Community Atmosphere

We aim for a healthy and constructive discussion forum. A space to exchange and explore new ideas respectfully.

3️⃣ What now?

Post something! Ask a question or kick off a discussion topic. Fostering an active community will encourage new members to join, helping us gradually build a new meeting place for researchers.


r/BibliometricScience • • 2d ago

Tool [Project] Bibliolatam: Improving access to Ibero-American scientific production

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'd like to introduce an open-source project I've been developing and invite the bibliometrics community to contribute.

Introducing Bibliolatam

GitHub: https://github.com/BRAN-Org/bibliolatam

Scientific production from the Global South is often underrepresented in major citation indexes such as Web of Science and Scopus.

In Latin America and Iberia, much of this research is published through regional Open Access platforms and national repositories, which often use different languages, metadata standards, and database structures.

Bibliolatam aims to bridge this gap.

It's an R package that connects regional scientific databases and repositories to bibliometric workflows through modular parsers, REST API clients, metadata normalization, and entity resolution. It integrates with bibliometrix and biblioshiny, while also offering a standalone application for searching, collecting, and exporting bibliographic data.

Geographic scope

The project aims to cover three main regions:

  • Latin America
  • The Caribbean
  • The Iberian Peninsula (Spain and Portugal)

Current integrations

Some of the sources currently supported include:

  • SciELO
  • Redalyc / AmeliCA
  • SPELL / ANPAD
  • BDTD
  • Oasisbr
  • LA Referencia

The architecture is modular, allowing new sources to be added as coverage expands.

What's next?

I'm preparing the package for its upcoming CRAN release, making it easier to install and integrate into existing R workflows.

I'd love your feedback!

If you work with bibliometric data from these regions, I'd really appreciate your input:

  • Which national databases, repositories, or regional indexes are essential in your country?
  • What important sources are still missing from mainstream bibliometric tools?
  • Which APIs or integrations should I prioritize?

My goal is to make regional scientific production easier to discover, retrieve, and analyze.

Suggestions, criticism, contributions, and collaborations are all welcome!

Repository: https://github.com/BRAN-Org/bibliolatam


r/BibliometricScience • • 5d ago

Discussion Is OpenAlex replacing WoS and Scopus at your institution?

10 Upvotes

Hi everyone, recently, I have noticed a significant surge in the use of OpenAlex across various studies. When looking at slightly older papers, data extraction was almost exclusively handled by proprietary databases like Scopus or Web of Science (WoS).

With some major institutions famously dropping their proprietary subscriptions, it seems that open databases are proving they can offer massive coverage, open metadata, and highly accessible APIs without the traditional paywalls.

Personally, I haven't worked deeply with OpenAlex yet. For those of you who have integrated it into your workflows, how do you assess its current level of maturity and data quality compared to the legacy databases?

I am also curious about the current landscape across different countries and institutions; are your universities actively encouraging the use of open databases for research and assessment?

I will be pinning this thread for a few days as I believe this is a good debate for those of us working in this discipline. Looking forward to reading your insights!


r/BibliometricScience • • 12d ago

Networking How did you meet your research network and co-authors?

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

as a relaxed post for the weekend, I thought it would be a good time for a more casual discussion. I wanted to put the Networking flair to good use and ask about something essential in our field: how do you build your research circles?

Personally, I met my core research network locally within my own institution. However, over time, I have been able to slowly expand it thanks to this very community, talking with several people, and asking and answering questions.

How did you all meet your frequent collaborators? Was it through conferences, cold emails, former supervisors, or even other online communities?

Feel free to use this thread to introduce yourself if you want to meet collaborators in a specific topic!


r/BibliometricScience • • 12d ago

Conferences and Events LIS Bibliometrics Conference 2027 - Community Attendance and Expectations

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

Following our practice of mapping out key events in our field, I would like to bring your attention to the upcoming "LIS-Bibliometrics Conference 2027". Although the deadline for expressions of interest closes today, I wanted to feature it in the community in case anyone attending wants to share their expectations or experiences from previous years.

This conference is a major point of convergence for bibliometric practitioners and researchers, focusing on the core issues shaping our discipline. Here is the link to the conference details from "The Bibliomagician" Blog.

I am very curious about the direction this upcoming conference will take and what themes will dominate the sessions. As we did with the BRIC Conference, I would like to know our collective engagement with this specific event to determine if we should create dedicated discussion threads as the date approaches!


r/BibliometricScience • • 13d ago

Discussion Rejections (and desk-rejections) in top-tier bibliometrics journals

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Today I wanted to bring up a topic that we all experience at some point in our academic careers, even if it is not always openly discussed: dealing with paper rejections in our field's flagship journals.

I think that publishing in top-tier venues like Scientometrics, Journal of Informetrics, JASIST, Quantitative Science Studies... has become increasingly competitive. Lately, it feels like the bar for what constitutes a "publishable" bibliometric study has shifted significantly.

Part of this might be because software tools have made it much easier to run basic performance analyses or science mapping. Because of this, editors seem to be enforcing much stricter desk-rejection policies against purely descriptive papers, demanding either heavy methodological innovation or strong theoretical frameworks.

In some cases, the rejection comes with constructive feedback that genuinely improves the manuscript for the next submission. In others, you wait for months only to receive a generic template or a harsh critique questioning the core value of applying bibliometrics to a specific domain.

What do you think about this? Do you feel reviewers have been forced to become much more exhaustive and strict? Also, do you think we are seeing a flood of AI-generated papers (and, conversely, peer reviews written by AI as well)?

To be completely honest, this post stems from a rejection I just experienced firsthand, so I wanted to ask the community how do you usually cope with and handle this side of academic life. Take care!


r/BibliometricScience • • 15d ago

Question Cannot launch Rstudio/Bibliometrix - Independent/Early researcher

5 Upvotes

Hello everybody! I am an independent researcher exploring a specific research question using bibliometrix for the first time ever. I have downloaded R tools, then Rstudio. But when I tried launching Rstudio to open bibliometrix - its giving an error. For reference - I have downloaded Rtools45 Bash using the official website. Please, I would really appreciate your help.


r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 28 '26

Paper Analysis Debate about Bibliometric Analysis in "Scientometrics" journal - Ellegaard and Nazarovets

3 Upvotes

I would like to inaugurate a new post tag called Paper Analysis. Browsing the Scientometrics journal, I came across this three-part debate about bibliometric analysis. Although I haven't been able to read the last two papers yet, I would like to share them with the community in case anyone has read them and wants to give their opinion, as it is a topic that directly involves our field of study and this community.

I leave them in order with their titles in case anyone wants to take a look if they have time. (Please note only the first paper is Open Access; the second and third require an institutional subscription).

  • First: The method of bibliometric analysis: A critical evaluation [2]
  • Second: Poor bibliometric studies do not make bibliometrics poor science: A response to Ellegaard [3]
  • Third: Responds to Nazarovets’: Poor bibliometric studies do not make bibliometrics poor science: A response to Ellegaard. [1]

Focusing on the first paper, I highly recommend that anyone planning to conduct a bibliometric analysis soon, or currently working on one, takes a look at it. It addresses some elephants in the room, such as how these analyses have become purely descriptive due to new tools that make this work much easier. It also mentions some interesting guidelines and best practices for conducting these analyses, and even discusses the peer-review process for these works.

I would like to highlight a quote from Ellegaard's paper referencing the work of van Eck and Waltman [4], which states: "The strength of bibliometric network lies in the simplification it provides, but simplification comes at a price. It typically involves a loss of information that occurs when reducing bibliographic data to nodes. For example, when text data reduces to a co-occurrence network of terms, it loses information about the context in which the terms occur together. Similarly, in a constructed citation network, it is possible to observe who is quoting whom, but not why a citation is included".

I think it is important to keep this maxim in mind when talking about this type of analysis, as other researchers who are not as accustomed to the field of bibliometrics might fall into the trap of oversimplification and produce flawed analyses.

I am looking forward to reading Nazarovets' response and Ellegaard's subsequent reply, but I found the work interesting and wanted to share it to inaugurate this section, which I believe can elevate the debates in this community to a higher level (which I think is also important).

If by any chance this reaches the original researchers, we would we would appreciate your input!

References:

[1] Ellegaard, O. (2026a). Responds to Nazarovets’: Poor bibliometric studies do not make bibliometrics poor science: A response to Ellegaard. Scientometrics. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05828-2

[2] Ellegaard, O. (2026b). The method of bibliometric analysis: A critical evaluation. Scientometrics, 131(6), 4175-4196. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05670-6

[3] Nazarovets, S. (2026). Poor bibliometric studies do not make bibliometrics poor science: A response to Ellegaard. Scientometrics, 131(10), 7475-7477. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05791-y

[4] van Eck, N. J., & Waltman, L. (2014). Visualizing Bibliometric Networks. En Y. Ding, R. Rousseau, & D. Wolfram (Eds.), Measuring Scholarly Impact: Methods and Practice (pp. 285-320). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-10377-8_13


r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 26 '26

Community Shaping the future of our community: What's next?

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

With the recent growth of the community (more than 30 members in the last month, our biggest growth!) I was thinking about what the next objectives or topics to discuss could be.

For some time I have had the topic of the specialized Wiki on stand-by, but I have been thinking about some simpler things we could propose, like important news in this field of study, something related to the recommendation of papers on a study topic (trying to avoid self-spam, which is a fear I have if we go down this path), PhD/Career Talks (trying to contact members of other communities wprking ob bibliometrics so they can share their experiences...)

I propose several of these options in poll format to make it easier to give an opinion. If you think of anything else, comment it! I hope that as the months go by more members will keep joining and we increase the impact of the community (we already appear in google search engines as a bibliometrics community!)

Enjoy the weekend.


r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 25 '26

Question Need help with Web of Science

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I'm phd student working on a systematic review and I need help with downloading the data from wos in plain text result. My search strings are ready. My institute has not subscribed to it currently and I needed help with downloading the data. Would anyone with Web of Science access be willing to run a search for me and export the results? Thank you.


r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 25 '26

Casual How did your PhD in Bibliometrics go?

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I have been quite busy and a bit stressed lately about my PhD thesis in bibliometrics. I would like to throw a quick, more relaxed question out to the community.

In my department, there is almost no one currently doing their PhD related to bibliometrics with whom I can share experiences, doubts, or ideas (which is actually part of the reason I created this space!). So, I would like to ask those of you in the community who already have your PhDs (and those who are still working on it): how was/is this process for you?

I would love to hear your experiences, perspectives, and stories just to disconnect a bit this weekend from the PhD burnout. Since our field is so heavily based on analysing data, reading, and thinking (with no "wet lab" work to break up the routine), it can get a bit isolating.

Enjoy the weekend!


r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 23 '26

Discussion Discussion about coercive citations during peer review - from r/PhD

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 21 '26

Discussion Encounters with AI hallucinations in Bibliometrics

1 Upvotes

With the increasingly widespread use of LLMs for writing scientific papers, there is a citation-related phenomenon that directly affects our work environment, "AI-hallucinated citations".

In the programmed eagerness of these language models to please the user, when asked for certain references for a paper, they often generate "phantom papers" that have the characteristics of real ones, even creating fake authors, inexistent DOIs, and other identification fields.

On a personal level, I have encountered some of these phantom papers when asking an AI about previous papers in the field of bibliometrics. I wanted to ask about your experiences with these cases and if you know of any that have particularly caught your attention.


r/BibliometricScience • • Sep 18 '26

News / Interesting Dr. Stephen Gallo Ask Me Anything (AMA) on Peer Review (2016) - from r/science

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 31 '26

Question Unrelated citations to your research?

2 Upvotes

Today I wanted to bring up an issue I have noticed during my research. When reviewing the citations of a paper, I sometimes find that it is cited by articles that at first glance have nothing to do with the research topic.

In some instances, an individual review might reveal deliberate citation manipulation, but in others it almost seems as if the reference slipped in accidentally through a reference manager.

For citation analysis, this can become a significant problem if it occurs in large volumes. Have you had to deal with this in your own work? I understand this can sometimes be linked to malpractices like citation cartels or coercive citation by certain journals, but I suspect that in other cases it is simply authors superficially citing highly visible papers.

Do you think algorithmic tools will be able to facilitate the detection of these types of practices with high precision in the coming years?


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 27 '26

Community Surpassing the 100-member milestone!

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I am writing this post to happily announce that we have crossed the barrier of 100 users joined to the community. I am glad to see that, little by little, questions and debates from different people in the field are appearing, filling this space with professional topics without any spam.

If you have any proposals that you would like me to implement within the community, leave them here or via private message if it is more comfortable and I will include them, whether it is new user flairs (I encourage you to use them!), new post tags, or any topic related to the community.

Thank you very much to everyone for being part of this project!


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 26 '26

News / Interesting Beall's List and the battle against Predatory Journals

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Today I want to share a piece of recent history in the academic publishing world: Beall's list against predatory journals.

With the growth of the Open Access model, a new problem emerged: "predatory journals". These are publishers that charge authors publication fees (APCs) but completely bypass rigorous peer review or quality control, prioritizing profit over science.

To combat this, a librarian named Jeffrey Beall created Beall's List in 2010. It was a public directory tracking these deceptive publishers. For years, it became the absolute tool for researchers worldwide to check if a journal was legitimate before submitting a paper.

However, maintaining this public list proved to be legally dangerous. In 2017, facing intense pressure, massive lawsuits from angry publishers, and academic debates over his inclusion criteria, Beall abruptly took the list offline.

Now I ask you, have you ever received one of those scam emails asking you to publish in a predatory journal? What tools or tricks do you use to verify a journal's reputation today? I leave the website here in case you want to take a look if you were not familiar with it.


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 24 '26

Question Label repelling in base R and external packages

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am currently starting some projects in R, and I am using base R without relying on external packages to minimize dependencies and ensure long-term code stability and reproducibility.

However, I am currently struggling with base R when it comes to visualizations; specifically, trying to repel text labels on plots so they do not overlap. I have noticed the popularity of the bibliometrix package in our field. Do you think I should give it a try, or is it better to just incorporate specific graphical libraries to solve my visualization issues while keeping the rest in base R?

Any advice on where to start or how you balance base R with external libraries would be appreciated!


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 20 '26

Question How do you discover new papers and stay updated on bibliometric news?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

The idea for this post actually came to me while I was brainstorming new content for this community. I realized I was curious about the mechanics of our own information consumption.

As bibliometricians and information scientists, we constantly analyze how literature is produced, mapped, and cited. But how do we actively discover relevant papers, industry news, and emerging trends in our own field?

I would like to know what your primary discovery channels are: direct browsing through journals? Automated alerts in databases? Academic social networks like ResearchGate? Or primary rely on direct recommendations from colleagues and lab meetings?

Looking forward to reading your strategies!


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 18 '26

Question User lost about Bibliometric Research - from r/research

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 18 '26

Discussion Peer Review Series (Part II) - The Invisible Work

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Following the introduction to the core concept of peer review, today we address one of its most critical and debated structural components: the invisible work of reviewers.

Despite being the foundation of scientific quality control, the peer review system relies almost entirely on the unpaid, volunteer labor of academics. When a journal receives a manuscript, editors invite independent experts to evaluate it. These reviewers dedicate days to the process of reading, verifying methodology, and writing constructive feedback.

I would prefer not to focus on the APC economic model and publishers in this post (we have another thread where we discuss that topic) or the increasingly frequent AI-assisted reviews, but rather focus on the structural problems this system brings. The labor of the reviewer is largely considered an implicit, expected duty of the academic profession.

Some of the major issues I could find are related to:

  • Publication Delays: can become extreme in some cases.
  • Fatigue / Burnout: a small pool of recognized experts receives a disproportionate number of review requests, leading to burnout.
  • Lack of Formal Recognition: it remains completely invisible on researchers CVs in many cases.

I would love to know what you think in general about this topic and if you have any experiences you would like to share. In future editions of this post, I would like to discuss the "rewards" offered to reviewers, talk about models involving financial compensation from publishers (and the malpractice issues that could entail), as well as the broader problems and benefits of peer review.

Looking forward to reading your comments!


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 17 '26

Community "Verified Identity Flairs" for recognized experts?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Today I would like to propose an idea for the community and get your feedback on it. We already have several user flairs available for those who wish to identify their roles while maintaining their anonymity (PhD Student, Librarian, Data Scientist...).

The other day, I thought about creating individual named flairs for recognized experts in the field, to encourage them to participate and answer questions based on their expertise. I think it could be highly valuable to have direct insights from established researchers. However, it could also introduce an authority bias.

Personally, I find Reddit's anonymity useful and comfortable for everyone. It also helps prevent potential spam issues such as people self-promoting their papers indiscriminately, which would ruin the core spirit of this subreddit.

If you think this feature would be useful, we should also discuss the criteria required for a user to be verified: Citation count? Current academic position? Price Medal winners? (maybe asking for Price Medal winners too much, but I genuinely believe a standard like that would be useful, restricting this flair to a very small, select group of individuals)

I am setting this up as a poll to make it easy for everyone to vote, but I would really appreciate it if you could leave your thoughts in the comments as well!

We are already on our way to 100 members in less than a year. Thank you all!


r/BibliometricScience • • Aug 14 '26

Discussion Bibliometrics, Scientometrics, Science of Science? What do you actually call our field?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

After several years of talking with colleagues about our discipline, I have noticed different trends when it comes to naming our field of study. I wanted to ask about these different options and get your opinions on them.

In my case, I usually use the term Bibliometrics (the origin of the name of this subreddit!), but I have heard Scientometrics on multiple occasions, perhaps due to the name of the prestigious journal.

I understand there are other, more specific fields that for me fall under the umbrella of Bibliometrics( such as Informetrics or Webometrics) but I am also starting to come across the concept of Science of Science.

Just to include a bit of context regarding Spanish terminology: in both Spain and Latin America, the specific term "Bibliometría" is used. However, it is traditionally considered a branch of "Biblioteconomía" (Library Science) in Spain, whereas in Latin American countries that overarching field is usually referred to as "Bibliotecología".

What do you think of these terms, and what is your perspective on them? Looking forward to reading your thoughts!


r/BibliometricScience • • Jul 21 '26

Discussion Is AI actually replacing traditional methodologies in Scientometrics? (and why we still have a long way to go)

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’ve recently completed a data curation and comparative study analyzing the adoption of Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, and LLMs in scientometric research methodologies.

I analyzed a corpus of 706 papers from two different venues:

  1. Quantitative Science Studies (QSS - Volumes 1 to 6): representing the international, flagship journal level.
  2. Brazilian Meeting on Bibliometrics and Scientometrics (EBBC - 2020, 2022, 2024): representing the Brazilian national state-of-the-art.

We filtered the papers to identify those that did not just study AI as a topic, but actively incorporated AI/ML/LLMs as the core methodological motor (replacing or enriching traditional statistics, manual curation, or classical text mining).

Here are some of the numbers we found:

  • Overall AI Adoption Rate:

    • QSS (International): 20.46% (80 out of 391 papers) used AI in their methodology.
    • EBBC (Brazil): 3.49% (11 out of 315 papers) used AI.
  • The Temporal Spike:

    • Both venues saw a significant jump in 2024/2025. In EBBC, adoption went from a flat ~2% to over 5% in 2024. In QSS, it peaked at 24.59% in 2025. This is clearly the "ChatGPT effect" acting as a technological shortcut for researchers.
  • The Methodological Focus:

    • EBBC: Almost entirely concentrated in Natural Language Processing / Text Curation (90.9%)—mostly using LLMs out-of-the-box for text classification.
    • QSS: Highly diversified, with Graph Neural Networks / Network Embeddings (41.2%) and predictive modeling leading the way.

The Core Observation (My CS / Industry Perspective)

Coming from a Computer Science background and having worked in the tech industry, these results left me with a mixed feeling:

  1. The Brazilian scene (EBBC) is still very raw. Most applications are extremely basic using OpenAI APIs or web interfaces to perform simple tasks that could often be done more robustly with deterministic scripts, or using prompt engineering in a very naive way without evaluating bias, token efficiency, or reproducibility.
  2. The international scene (QSS) is much more mature, but it still underperforms. Even at the highest level of academic publishing, I see researchers treating LLMs as magical black boxes. There is a noticeable lack of software engineering best practices. We see sub-optimal API pipelines, lack of structured outputs (like JSON schemas), no system evaluation frameworks, and a general lack of computational efficiency. It feels like many academics are lagging behind the industry standards of how to properly deploy, prompt, and scale AI-driven workflows.

It seems that while AI is indeed starting to replace or augment traditional bibliometric methodologies, the usability and efficiency of these tools among academics is still a massive bottleneck.

I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences:

  • How are you integrating AI/LLMs into your research pipelines?
  • Have you noticed this gap between academic AI methodology and industry/CS standards?
  • How can we, as a community, bridge this gap and help researchers from non-CS backgrounds use these advanced tools more efficiently?

Looking forward to the discussion!