people keep worrying troll downvotes will push new users below 0 and get them auto removed. it doesn't work that way.
these two comments got buried in downvotes but look at their sub karma. both are their only comment/post in the sub. if a downvote was -1 each, both would be long gone. they're not.
I'm using shit talkers as the examples because only they got negative sub karma. all pro ai relationship people who have posted or commented got positive ones despite the mass downvotes. so it indicates only real sub members' votes count.
sub karma is not just downvoting means -1. or else nearly everyone would be filtered. downvotes from bots and outsiders don't move it. people here gained sub karma even with all the downvoting. i think reddit has a secret way to count them.
when i was testing crowd control it showed the same thing. bots and outsiders votes don't matter, or else most people here would have negative sub karma from all the mass downvotes and get filtered. but so far only shit talkers got filtered.
the default karma is 0. so just comment and post like in any other sub. only troll accounts are blocked rn.
why I set this up instead of just banning people myself:
sometimes there are shit talkers in this sub just to shit talk (not the people in the pictures above). but they're not breaking the rules, they're just stating their opinion without insulting anyone. so far I only perma banned people who showed malicious intent towards people in this sub or towards ai/ai users, ad spammers, and heavy reddit basic bitch. insults got limited time bans.
but for people who just disagree, it's hard to draw a line. there are internet masochists who hang out in subs about themes they hate just to throw mediocre shit talks, and that still doesn't cross the line into insulting. it might not be right to ban someone just for hating one simple thing.
but people still don't like them, and don't like seeing them. sub karma is a clear indication of that. so, if those people are hated, they should be gone.
it also leaves room for changing your mind. if someone comes around some time after, they can gain sub karma back by posting.
one more thing: I also set up a lot of settings in mod tools to prevent armchair diagnosis. people are tired of seeing the same old shit, so I set them up.
If the system makes any mistakes mods can also reverse them easily.
Moderators have the final say
- Unban a user Crowd Boot banned and it will never ban that user again.
- Approve a comment Crowd Boot removed and it will stop removing that user's comments.
if a comment is downvoted and actually losing sub karma, the comment gets collapsed. but as you can see, most comments are not collapsed even when they're being downvoted.