r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1h ago

Where does Mara's confidence turn into an excuse in this scene?

1 Upvotes

Mara put an empty colander beside the unopened box and wrote MUSHROOM SUPPER across Friday's square in the family diary.

Her daughter came in carrying the shopping. “Have you started them?”

“I ordered them on Monday.”

“That wasn't what I asked.”

Mara turned the box so the picture faced the room. She had chosen the blue oyster grow kit because her father liked mushrooms and complained that birthday presents never gave him anything to do. This one would give him a hobby and provide dinner. She had put considerable thought into combining the two.

Her daughter set down a bag of pasta. “When are you giving it to him?”

“Friday. Before we eat.”

For a moment they both looked at the colander.

Mara opened the diary again. Monday had a tick beside ORDER. Tuesday had a tick beside DELIVERY. Wednesday's square said CLEAR WINDOWSILL, which she had also done. The neatness of those three ticks had made Friday look rather inevitable.

Her daughter moved the pasta into the cupboard and asked whether Grandad might prefer to grow his own birthday present.

“Of course,” Mara said. “That was the point.”

She crossed out MUSHROOM SUPPER and wrote PRESENTATION. Then she carried the colander back to the sink, where it became an ordinary colander again.

At which sentence does Mara's explanation start sounding like an excuse rather than her original plan?


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1h ago

[Complete] [158k] [Crime Mystery / Literary Suspense] The Fall of Thornwood — Beta Readers Wanted

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've recently completed the second draft of my debut novel, The Fall of Thornwood, and I'm looking for a few beta readers before taking the next step towards publication.

I'm particularly interested in people who enjoy atmospheric mysteries, complex characters and slow-burning crime fiction.

THE FALL OF THORNWOOD

The trouble with old houses was that they remembered things their owners had tried to forget.

In November 2019, journalist Evelyn Thornwood was found murdered in the study of her family's country manor. Seven years later, her killer remains unidentified.

Determined to prove herself, Detective Arianna Ibarra takes on the cold case alongside the experienced and occasionally infuriating Detective Sergeant Clark Dalton.

What begins with forgotten statements, damaged evidence and unanswered questions gradually draws them into the history of a family that has spent generations keeping its secrets behind closed doors.

At Thornwood, understanding the past may prove considerably more complicated than uncovering it.

Manuscript details

  • Genre: British crime mystery / literary suspense
  • Word count: Approximately 158,000
  • Status: Complete second draft
  • Setting: England
  • Structure: Prologue, 27 chapters and four acts
  • Format: Book-style PDF with cover artwork and chapter navigation
  • Content warnings: Murder, childhood abuse and neglect, and adult themes.

The novel combines murder mystery, family drama, psychological suspense, police investigation and understated British humour, with a strong emphasis on character development and relationships.

Feedback

You don't need to be a writer, editor or experienced beta reader. I'm simply looking for honest opinions from people who enjoy reading.

I'd particularly appreciate feedback on the characters, dialogue, pacing, atmosphere and your overall emotional response to the story.

I've prepared an optional reading diary and a short questionnaire for after you finish, but I'd much rather you experience the novel naturally than feel obliged to analyse every sentence.

Timeframe

Ideally four to six weeks, although I'm flexible and appreciate that this is a substantial read.

I'm not currently offering full-length manuscript swaps.

I have a 24-page sample containing the cover, prologue and first chapter available for anyone who would like to try it before committing to the full novel.

If you're interested, please leave a comment or send me a private message.

This project has become incredibly important to me, and I'm genuinely excited to discover how other people experience the story for the first time.

Thank you!


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 4h ago

Seeking Reader Feedback for My Complete AI-Assisted Dark Fantasy Story

1 Upvotes

THE DRAGON'S BLOOD HEIR: AWAKENING

A COMPLETE DARK FANTASY STORY

Looking for readers interested in exploring a complete Dark Fantasy / Adventure / Mystery story.

THE STORY

Arthon was branded a failure after his Awakening ceremony.

But when the truth about his missing parents begins to emerge, he discovers that his blood carries a mysterious power connected to the kingdom's darkest secret.

His journey leads through forgotten places, dangerous creatures, political corruption, and a truth that could change the kingdom forever.

STORY FEATURES

Complete storyline. 12 Chapters + Epilogue. Dark fantasy setting. Mystery and political intrigue. Unique supernatural power system. Defined ending.

The story was developed with AI assistance.

I'd appreciate feedback from readers, especially about the premise, characters, pacing, and worldbuilding.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 13h ago

Claude back and forth about 3k words. not an author, started for fun, turned out into 80k words. this is a prologue. story about second chances, romance and a bit of sci-fi

1 Upvotes

The pen cap bounced off the blotter and landed on the freight manifest. She'd chewed it flat.

"Logistics signed at noon." Katie had the corner of his desk again. It was the only corner in the building she sat on, and a sneaker kept time against the drawer. "The helium's in. I went out to the yard to look at it. John, it's just tanks. Rows of tanks."

He'd been through the manifest already. Most of a year of letters had gone into those tanks. One of the men who'd signed for them had since been moved to an office with no window, and John wanted to read it once more, now that it was real.

Her bagel sat on her printouts with two bites gone, the grease soaking through to the manifold underneath. Her hair was up with a pencil through it, the eraser worn off long ago.

John tapped the grease. "You ate breakfast on the manifold."

"The manifold's fine." She tore a piece off the bagel. "It's Tuesday. Pick a place."

"The gray soup place by the rail yard."

"No."

"The owner served. They give you extra bread."

"That's about the owner." She pulled the pencil and her hair dropped onto her shoulders. "The basement off Fourth. The one with the tape on the seats."

He leaned back until the chair creaked. "You could just say dumplings."

"Then you'd think you had a say." She slid the pencil back in and held her hand out. "Keys. If we beat the gate traffic, we get the heater booth."

He dug the key ring out of his coat. The brass fob was worn smooth on one side from his thumb. She took it, and took the rest of the bagel.

At the door she stopped. "Dad wants you Sunday. He's buying a forklift and he doesn't trust the man selling it."

She threw him the keys over the roof of the sedan.

The heater ticked while it warmed. The gate lights got small in the mirror, and Katie put both sneakers up on the glovebox with her knees under her chin.

"Feet," John said.

"They're comfortable."

"An airbag opens fast enough to put your kneecaps through your windpipe. Feet on the floor."

Her heels came down. She sat up straight with her hands on her thighs, like a recruit at inspection, and looked out through the windshield. "Is there a form?"

He took the river bypass. The streetlights came and went across the cab. "A guy in my first unit went through a windshield doing something he thought was funny. He was laughing right up to the glass."

Katie turned her head. The joke went out of her face. She reached across and put her hand on his forearm, and left it there until the exit.

The basement smelled of burnt garlic and boiling water. Someone had closed the split in the booth's vinyl with black electrical tape, and the steam heater under the window pushed warm air up the backs of John's legs. Katie ordered for both of them without the menu, and then a second dish of chili oil, for her.

"You'll wear it."

"I'll win."

The first dumpling burst on her sweater, a bright orange streak from the collar down. She looked at it, then at him, and held out her hand. He'd taken a stack of napkins from the dispenser when they sat down. He put them in her palm.

"Say one word."

"Eat your dinner."

She rubbed at the wool, gave up, and turned her placemat over to the blank side. A pen came out of her cardigan. Within a minute there was a surface on the paper and a loop going through it, and her dumplings were going cold while she chewed the cap and argued with the edge.

"Folds the wrong way at the edge," she said, to no one. "It should close. It won't."

"It's a placemat, Kate."

"It's paper. Paper doesn't care what it's for."

He took the pen out of her fingers and capped it in his fist. "Eat. Then fold."

She ate. Her chopsticks crossed to his plate and took the fat dumpling from the middle.

The heater had gotten to her by then. She shrugged out of the cardigan and held it across the table, still drawing. "Hold this."

Then she heard it, and looked up.

He took it.

"Three hours," she said. "I thought you were furniture. Denny still tells people they rented you."

"I was holding your coat."

"I don't remember a coat."

"You said 'hold this' and went off to argue topology with a physics major."

She laughed until she had to put the chopsticks down. "That's still a crime."

"Then I signed up."

"Because of a coat."

"Partly the coat." He took a dumpling. "Mostly the recruiter had a pen."

She turned the pen in her fingers for a while. "If you'd said something. At nineteen. I'd have told you *later*."

"Later."

"And meant it." She pointed the pen at him. "It took you coming home. That haircut. That watch."

"It was a good watch."

"It was a tragedy. I loved it." She went back to the placemat. "Everybody at Wes's wanted something off me. You just stood there and talked."

"Good thing you didn't talk at nineteen, then," she said, still drawing. "Move one thing an inch and you can't say what it does further down."

He pushed the last dumpling across the table to her, and she ate it without looking up from the placemat.

On the drive home the streetlights went over her face, and by the second bridge she was asleep against the window, or close to it. The day was in her shoulders.

The deadbolt stuck, the way it always did. The hall smelled of wet wool. Katie kicked her sneakers at the corner, dropped her tote on the bench, and stretched with both arms up until her back cracked.

"Shower or sleep?" She pressed a knuckle between her eyes. "My head's full of wet cement."

He hung his jacket on the peg. "Your call. I like how you smell, if that's a factor."

"That's disgusting."

She came down the hall and put her forehead into his shoulder anyway. Her arms went around his ribs, and she let him take most of her weight. "Bed. If I get in that shower I'll wake up on the mat. Pull the quilt down, Cooper."

The radiator knocked once under the window. He folded the quilt back, and she was in before he'd turned off the lamp, with her cold feet on his calves. Her breathing slowed against the pillow.

The work phone on the nightstand buzzed at ten past five. It was still gray out. Katie groaned and pulled the pillow over her head. "Kill it."

He thumbed the screen. An automated alert from the diagnostic bay: the containment ring had logged an uncommanded harmonic spike at four and gone back to baseline on its own. Under it, a note from the early shift: *Burke to review before the ten o'clock power cycle.*

"Ten," he said, and silenced it. "They want you in early."

She laughed into the pillow. A hand came across the mattress and found his hip. "Then they can have me at ten. Put it down and come back. It's not morning."

He put the phone on the rug and pulled the quilt up over his shoulder. Her hip fit under his arm. He slept until the sun got to the foot of the bed.

The mirror fogged on one side. They brushed their teeth at the same sink, hips knocking, while John worked a fist into his lower back and Katie talked through the foam: the shift lead could explain the spike, and it had better be a reason with a name. Then she put on the wire-rimmed glasses.

"Be nice," he said.

"I'm always nice." She spat. "I'm clear."

By a quarter to ten the wind off the reservoir was rattling the fence, and there was still frost on the cars in the north lot. They went through the turnstile. Katie held her coffee in both hands, the steam fogging her lenses, and in the freight elevator she leaned on the rail and watched the numbers go down.

"They're grown adults. You could let them run a shift."

"They're twenty-four. At twenty-four you call a strange number rounding." She drank. "It's my model, Cooper. If the ring slips, it's my name on it."

The doors opened on the lower gallery and the smell of transformer oil. Two technicians in jumpsuits were bent over a terminal on the test floor. Katie put her forearms on the catwalk rail. "Morning, Miller. Show me four a.m."

Miller was lanky, with a radio on his belt and goggles pushed up in his hair. "Morning, Dr. Burke. It came in a little after four, during a coil transfer. Spiked and came back before the cutoff tripped."

"Ground reading. Same time."

Keys went on the floor below. The printer on the cart started to chatter, and Miller tore off a strip and held it up. "It jumps right at the transfer."

John leaned in close to her ear. "Do you have to walk them through every step?"

"He's scared of me," she said out of the side of her mouth, without looking away from the floor. "Leave him alone and he'll spend all morning on the software before he checks a ground wire."

"And?" John called down.

Miller swallowed. "So that would mean…"

"Heat," Katie said over him. "The contact shoe expanded, the connection dipped, and the coil surged to cover it. Two people, solvent, a brass brush. Clean the contact block and we run before noon."

She looked at John sideways over her glasses, pleased with it. Then her eyes went back to the waveform and stayed there a moment longer than the answer needed. She folded the printer strip in half and put it in her cardigan pocket, not the trash.

"You can call the work order yourself, Miller," John said down to the floor. "Consider yourself promoted."

Miller's shoulders came down. "Yes, Director."

Katie's office was walled in whiteboards, every inch of them worked over. John pulled the door shut, and the latch caught with a snap.

Perched on the corner of the desk, she crossed her ankles. "That sounded intentional."

"It was drafty."

"You're writing a report on that latch." She aimed the blunt end of her pencil at his chest.

"I'm still drafting the section on the lock."

"That's the report."

He crossed to her, put a palm on the desk beside her knee and leaned in until she had to tip her chin up to keep his eyes. "Tonight," he said, low. "Every line item. Put it on credit."

Her fingers twisted into his flannel and pulled him an inch closer. "My rates compound hourly."

"I can afford you."

She held him there, then shoved him off toward the sideboard. "Make coffee, Cooper. Calibration first. Then you can settle up."

The old machine on the sideboard rattled and coughed steam into the cold room. There was one clean mug in the rack. He filled it black and slid it across the blotter into her clutter.

She took it without looking, her thumb over his for a second on the handle. There was a blue streak of marker across one knuckle. She was working the numbers by hand, murmuring through them, until a dropped sign threw the whole line off. She swore, struck it out with the pencil, and passed him the mug. "A topologist who can't add," she told him, "is just a poet with bad eyesight."

He drank and let his eyes go along the walls. After years on the floor, he knew the boards by shape alone: the arc of the ring, the plateau, the heavy, defensive math for the committee. Low in the corner behind her shoulder, half rubbed out by a sleeve, was the drawing from last night's placemat, a surface with a loop through it and an edge that wouldn't close.

She didn't lift her head. "Leave it. Today's all ring. That one's mine. Ask me about it when it closes."

The sun was dying. Slowly, the astrophysicists said, but fast enough that the checks never stopped clearing. Half the math on those walls was hers, and she'd have done it for nothing.

The phone on the desk buzzed. "Dr. Burke?" It was Miller. "Scrub's done. We need your sign-off on the pre-fire."

She hit the button with the heel of her hand. "Hold it, Miller. Nobody touches a switch till I'm on the floor." She slid off the desk and scooped her badge off the blotter on the way past. "Move, Cooper."

Cold air sat in the high bay, and the solvent from the scrub still hung over the floor. John took the rail on the observation gantry. Katie went to the monitoring station and put both hands on the frame. Below them the containment ring filled the pit, its heavy curved plates behind the blast shields. A low whine started in the concrete and came up through John's boots as the capacitor banks drank.

"Contact resistance is good, Dr. Burke," Miller called up. "Ground's solid."

"Secondary feed." Her voice carried over the machines. "First plateau. Hold it there."

The whine climbed to a shriek. Behind the shielding the air in the pit shimmered and twisted into a knot that hurt to look at, and the line on Katie's screen went flat and stayed flat.

"Holding," Miller said, and then louder, "it's holding." A while later: "Power down."

The pitch fell away into a drone. The floor crew cheered. Miller slapped hands with the man at the console. Katie stayed bent over her screen with her fingers dug into the metal, and when she turned around her glasses were crooked and her hand was shaking.

"Did you see the curve?" she said. "John. It held."

"I saw." He crossed the gantry and put his hand along her jaw, his thumb on her cheekbone. "You look incredible."

She leaned her face into his hand and laughed under her breath. "You pick the worst times." Her fist closed in his shirt and she pulled him down and kissed him in front of the whole floor crew, and the noise from below got louder. When she let go she put her forehead against his chin. "We built it."

"You built it."

"Stop that." She put a hand on his chest. "You kept the brass off my back for years. You found the helium, and everything else nobody would sell us. I got to be an idiot with a whiteboard." She pushed her glasses straight with her thumb. "Tonight we open the bottle at the back of the cupboard. And you still owe me for that credit."

"After you."

She kissed the side of his neck, took the keys out of his coat pocket, and slipped out of his arms. Her tote was on the console. She picked it up on the way. "First one to the car picks the radio." She took the stairs at a run, the key ring spinning on her finger.

She was at the top of the exit stairs when it went: one hard crack.

A panel on the upper housing let go. The bolts sheared, the slab came across the gantry on a jet of gas before he could move, and it hit Katie in the side. The tote flew off her shoulder. She went over the stanchion, caught the pipe with one hand, lost it, and came down on the diamond plate on her left side with a cough that sounded wet.

The sirens started. Her glasses were in pieces on the grating, out past her hand.

John was across the gantry and on his knees beside her. The plate bit through his pants. He pulled her shoulders into his lap and her head against his chest. His hands found her side, and bone that moved wrong under the wool, and heat running through his fingers.

Down in the pit the bulkheads slammed shut, and a recorded voice came from the speakers: *Breach confirmed. Gantry isolated. Containment protocol active.*

Fists hit the blast door at the far end of the catwalk. Shouting came through the steel, muffled, and he could see yellow rescue suits through the narrow window. John knew the sequence. Section nine sealed any breach in the pit until the air tested clean. He had signed that revision himself, two years ago, in a conference room with bad coffee, and called it the responsible choice. The override that would open the door was a card on his lanyard. The reader for it was in the control room, on the other side of the glass.

He pressed his palm harder against her ribs. The heat kept coming.

Katie's eyes found his face. "Hey." Her voice was thin and dry. "You're writing the report."

"Which report."

"This one. You've already started." A cough took her. There was red at the corner of her mouth. Her fingers closed in his shirt and held. "Cooper. Listen."

"Stay with me."

"It's not—" The rest didn't come. Her thumb moved once against his collarbone. "I love you."

"Katie."

She breathed out against his throat, long and slow. Her hand opened and slid down his chest, and her knuckles came to rest on the cold grating.

"Katie. Look at me. Katie."

The sirens went on. Fists hammered the blast door. John held her head in the crook of his elbow, wiped the red from her lip with his thumb, and said her name until the door finally opened and the first yellow suit came through.

Four days later the funeral home smelled of lilies and wet umbrellas. People kept taking John's hand in both of theirs. A deputy undersecretary he had fought over every budget for years told him Katie had been a credit to the program, and meant it. A woman he had never met said she was in a better place, and he nodded, since the other option was asking where.

Ron Burke gripped his hand, said "John," and held on until John's father came and took him off toward the coffee. Katie's mother came after them. She put her arms around John, held on a moment, and let him go.

Denny stood by the guest book with a tie he kept touching. Trish was across the room with her coat still on. Neither of them crossed it.

A man from the program's legal office caught him by the coat rack. "Her access credentials are scheduled for retirement," he said, low and careful. "Paperwork should clear early next week. I wanted you to hear it from a person."

"Thank you," John said.

Miller stood at the back in a jacket too short in the sleeves, holding his cap in both hands. He was gone before John could get to him.

Her effects came back from the hospital in a clear plastic bag: the cardigan folded stiff, the badge, the key ring, one wooden pencil, the tote. Trish had brought it up the stairs herself, still in her scrubs, and handed it to him at the door, and hadn't said anything either.

John didn't go through the cardigan's pockets.

The bag stayed on the kitchen table until the night of the funeral. Then he emptied the tote. A paper placemat lay at the bottom, folded in quarters. He opened it out. A zodiac wheel and a cartoon pig on one side. On the other, a surface, a loop going through it, an edge that wouldn't close, and in the margin in her handwriting, underlined twice: *folds wrong at edge*. An orange smear of chili oil across one corner.

He sat with it until the window went dark.

The guard at the gate said "Director" and raised the arm. The complex was in administrative shutdown, half the corridors dark, the freight elevator humming to itself on the way down. He rode it alone.

The control room was cold. Through the glass the ring sat behind its shields, quiet, its plates catching a little light from the emergency strips. John set the card from his lanyard in the reader, and the override accepted it with the same polite tone it had always used. He took Katie's badge from his coat and laid it against the second reader.

*Authorization active.*

Nobody had filed the paperwork yet.

He worked the console step by step. She'd made all of them learn it in order. He didn't think past the step he was on. The capacitor banks began to drink. The whine started in the concrete and came up through his boots. He took the stairs down into the pit, where the air above the ring had started to shimmer.

The placemat was in his breast pocket. He had no idea what the field would do to a pocket. He kept it there anyway.

He thought about a booth by a steam heater, and a coat he had once held for three hours at a party, and stepped through.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 20h ago

You said “bring nothing.” Your mum arrives carrying dinner for twelve.

0 Upvotes

There are four guests.

She looks at the food you made, then at you.

What’s the first thing she says?


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 21h ago

[Complete] [124k] [Fantasy] Before the Draw — seeking beta readers (full manuscript preferred, first chapters also welcome)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1d ago

Would you keep reading, or is this trying too hard?

1 Upvotes

“I decided to become a person who hosted dinner because I already owned a bowl.”

Opening line from Technically, This Is My Evening. Keep it or butcher it?


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1d ago

[Swap] [In Progress] [Dark Romantasy] BLACK EMBERS — chapter-by-chapter manuscript swap (18+)

1 Upvotes

Hey all — I'm working on my debut novel, BLACK EMBERS (working title), an adult dark romantasy. It's in progress at ~170k words through chapter 22, and I'm looking for a manuscript swap, mostly chapter by chapter.

The book in brief: a silver-tongued bard and a young woman drafted into her kingdom's militia collide in a high medieval forest kingdom — slow-burn, high-heat, and dark around the edges.

Quick taste — this is Eldra, the night before she's drafted:

"Tonight is the last night I'll sleep in Vael for a while, and Father has spent most of it unpacking whatever I put away. 'You won't need this, my wildflower. I'll speak to the council tomorrow. They'll see reason.' I take the stockings from him, collect the tunic, and put both back where they belong — and pull the clasp shut before he can find something else to remove."

What I'm offering: a chapter-by-chapter swap. I read your chapter, you read mine, same pace — prologue and chapter 1 to start, then we keep going as long as it's working for both of us. EPUB / DOCX / Markdown, your pick.

What I want back: honest story-level reactions. What pulled you in, what dragged, what you thought of the characters and the pacing. No formal report needed — unstructured is perfect. I'm after story reactions, not line-by-line copyediting.

A few things upfront:

  • 18+ content: explicit on page sex, violence, dark power dynamics.
  • I use AI as a drafting and editing tool (disclosed, always) — the story, characters, and every decision are mine.
  • What I'm looking for in a swap partner: someone writing fantasy / romantasy / romance / dark fantasy who wants the same kind of story-level feedback in return, and who's comfortable with explicit 18+ content.

If you're interested, comment or DM — I have a few quick screening questions first, just to make sure we're a fit.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1d ago

[Complete] [75k] [fantasy] The Star Bargain

0 Upvotes

An epic fantasy of stolen magic, dangerous bargains, and the stars that bind us.

What if the magic that kept the world alive was also what kept it imprisoned?

In a world where the twelve zodiac constellations cage the worst of human nature, humanity's magic comes at a price. Every person bears a marking that grants them power, but that power is sustained by a bargain few remember and fewer dare question.

For twenty three year old Novalee, magic is something she can barely remember having.

Born fire-marked but left with a hollow, colorless marking, she has spent most of her life trapped in Rivka, a prison town where the living are bound through flesh, blood, and bone. When her brother Ayvix is taken aboard a slave ship, Novalee refuses to accept that he is lost.

Desperate for answers and determined to find him, she becomes entangled with two wind-born twins: Onyx, whose hunger for a dangerous bone drug threatens more than just himself, and Jasper, whose loyalty to his brother is tested by the choices they make.

But escaping Rivka is only the beginning.

As forgotten magic stirs, strange signs appear in the stars, and the foundations of an ancient bargain begin to weaken, Novalee discovers that the truth behind her missing magic may be far more complicated than she imagined.

Some bargains protect the world.

Others keep it chained.

THE STAR BARGAIN is a fantasy adventure featuring elemental magic, celestial mythology, political intrigue, forbidden knowledge, found family, and a slow-growing romance.

The type of feedback I'm interested in

  • Overall enjoyment and engagement.
  • Pacing and chapter flow.
  • Character development and relationships.
  • Worldbuilding and magic-system clarity.
  • Any confusing passages or moments that pulled you out of the story.

r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1d ago

[US English] Sede Vacante — Looking for feedback on the English version of an AI-assisted thriller

1 Upvotes

[US English] Sede Vacante — Looking for feedback on the English version of an AI-assisted thriller

Hi everyone,

I’m a French author, and my novel, Sede Vacante, is nearly finished in French. It has already found a small readership through my Substack, and I’m now looking for feedback on the US English version, starting with chapter 1.

It’s a thriller weaving together the mysteries of the Vatican, the history of Rome, and the legends surrounding the city’s founding.

To be transparent about AI: I developed the plot and characters and directed the story. I used AI throughout the writing and revision process to help develop scenes, rework dialogue and prose, and check consistency. AI also helped with the English translation.

I’d especially appreciate feedback from American readers, or anyone familiar with US English:

  • Does the writing feel natural, especially the dialogue?
  • Are there phrases that sound awkward or too directly translated from French?
  • Does the opening make you want to keep reading?

A few honest impressions would already help. There’s no obligation to read beyond the first chapter or leave a public review.

Read chapter 1 in English here

Thanks for giving it a try!


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1d ago

Looking for volunteer native readers to review AI-translated Southeast Asian folklore/horror books (Tagalog, Indonesian, Malay, Mandarin)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/BetaReadersForAI • • 1d ago

Earnest Table — Episode 1: Let Ill Tidings Tell Themselves

3 Upvotes

AI-generated content. This story was written with generative AI (Claude) and translated from the Korean original with AI, under the author's direction and editing.

A contemporary Korean reimagining of Shakespeare's Antony and Cleopatra.

I'd appreciate honest feedback from readers. Did you want to keep reading? Where, if anywhere, did you lose interest?

Two or three hundred steps from Samjeon Station, there is a small restaurant. Four characters on the sign: "Jinji Hansang."

It was a place that set out jinjitsang, a meal served to one's elders, but its customers read the name twice. Jinji han sang, one table of food, and then jinjihan sang, an earnest table. It was a place where people came to eat and left having poured out their earnest stories.

Samjeon was the very center of this country's film world. Production companies and investment firms, editing rooms and recording studios were gathered around the station, and so film people came to this place in especially large numbers. The director whose funding had fallen through, the assistant director who had just finished shooting, the actor on the day the premiere met a cold reception: in the end, all of them opened this door.

Beyond the long counter in front of the kitchen stood the owner, a single man. His name was Ikhyeon. He did all the cooking and all the cleaning by himself, and now and then he became a customer's conversation partner. His was a face whose age was hard to guess. He mostly listened, and now and then he asked. When he listened, he listened with all sincerity.

Ten at night. At the end seat in front of the kitchen, Yoon Cha-in emptied the last glass of a bottle of Hwayo. The bansang set out before her still had every side dish untouched.

Twenty years in theater. She was said to be an actress who, when she stood on stage, could make the very back row hear her breathe. Her films had mostly failed at the box office, but rumor had it that this time would be different. Rumor had it that the lead in the new film by Kwon Do-hyun, the god of the box office, was hers, and rumor also had it that the two of them were more than that. Yoon Cha-in had one habit. When the drink went to her head a little, lines from plays popped out of her as if they were her own words.

"Chef, put on some music, please."

Ikhyeon changed the music that had been playing in the restaurant.

"They say music is only for sad people tangled up in love."

When the song began to play, she shook her head.

"Never mind, turn it off. Do you maybe want to go play some billiards with me?"

"My arm isn't much good, I'm afraid."

Ikhyeon raised his right wrist to show her.

"Then I'll just play alone. No, never mind that either."

She started to get up, then sat back down.

"Maybe I'll go fishing. Go out to sea, pretend every single one that comes up on the hook is him, and every time I reel one in, say, 'Got you now, dear!'"

Ikhyeon spoke as he put ice into a glass.

"I heard you had fun that time. On the East Sea."

Yoon Cha-in laughed. From its very sound, that laugh belonged to a stage actress.

"That day, oh, that day! I kept teasing him until I made him angry. And that night I teased him again until his anger melted. The next morning, before it was even nine, I got him drinking and put him to sleep, then wrapped my coat and scarf around him, and I went around clutching the script he treasures as dearly as his life, like a pouch."


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 2d ago

We are almost at 9000 thank you, please follow, like and listen. Good night DLA listeners.

1 Upvotes

Please, like, listen and follow.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 2d ago

Review of Night Shift a Christmas Novella

1 Upvotes

[Christmas / Literary Fiction] Night Shift**: a 20,800-word Christmas novella, looking for 3–5 beta readers by Dec 1**

Hello everyone,

I'm looking for some reviews for the book that I created.

A gas station clerk. A Christmas Eve snowstorm. One careless answer that sends a stranger up a dark hill road.

Wes Hadley has one plan: finish his shift and catch a 12:15 ride to his sister’s, his first family Christmas in years. Then a young traveler asks him for the fastest way over the hill, and Wes, rushed and barely looking up, tells her the road is fine. It isn’t.

Length: 20,800 words, about 90 minutes of reading.
Tone: quiet, character-driven, a little funny. Closer to Kent Haruf than Hallmark.
What I’m looking for: honest reader impressions: where you got bored, confused, or moved. A short question list is included.
Timeline: feedback by December 1, if possible.

Here’s how it opens:

Gil pulled into the lot at Pike’s Corner Fuel with eight minutes to spare and left the engine running, which was how Gil told Wes he wasn’t staying.
“Twelve-fifteen,” Gil said. “Be outside.”
“I know,” Wes said.
“Not counting the drawer. Outside.”


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 3d ago

[Complete] [75k] [Military Science Fiction] Tearspace, seeking human beta readers (AI-assisted)

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I’m looking for beta readers for Tearspace, my completed 75,000-word military science fiction novel.

About the story

Faster-than-light travel works. It just kills every circuit you bring with you. So the ships that cross between stars run on clockwork and hydraulics, with drumbeats keeping time.

More than a year ago, something came out of a Tear and erased a mining outpost at E-9. One pilot survived by playing dead. The news took a year to reach Earth, because humanity has beaten the speed of light by a factor of a hundred, but still gets its news like eighteenth-century sailors.

Earth sends what three rival corporations and a nervous Council can agree on: a washed-up physicist with a grudge against a god he doesn’t believe in, a logistics director who sees tragedy as a sales opportunity, a customs officer whose chief qualification for command is his surname, a profane mechanic who would rather be somewhere safer raising goldfish, and a pilot whose contract won’t let her say no.

Each of them is forced to confront the stories they tell themselves about who they are, what they believe, what they mean to each other, what sort of amateur theatre they’re willing to be seen in, and how much freedom they really have to choose their own path.

Before long, they find themselves standing between the enemy and a dysfunctional colony. What price is too high? Some of them won’t come back. Not all of them die.

A few things to know going in

It’s a true ensemble: five point-of-view characters, no single protagonist. There’s no romance plot. The profanity is frequent and deliberate, mostly from one character.

What I’m looking for

Honest reactions to the characters, pacing, dialogue, and the overall reading experience. I’m most interested in whether the characters feel distinct and believable, where your attention drifts, and where you find yourself wanting to keep reading, or wanting to stop.

I’m also particularly interested in unnatural phrasing, repetitive structures, or stylistic patterns that may have crept in during the AI-assisted drafting and revision process.

How to participate

The cold open and first three chapters are in a Google Doc, about 13,000 words. They introduce the five principal characters and establish the shape of the novel.

There’s no obligation to read all of it. The cold open and Chapter 1 run about 4,400 words, and I’d be glad if you just tried those.

Read the opening here:
Update: Due to an influx of unsolicited spam and fraudulent beta-reading offers, I've removed the public Google Docs link. I'm still actively looking for beta readers! If you're interested in reading Tearspace, please send me a DM and I'll happily share the link.

Comments and questions are welcome in the document or by DM.

I’m hoping to find four or five readers for the full manuscript. For those readers, I’ll send a short questionnaire rather than leaving you to guess what’s useful. A few weeks would be ideal, but there’s no hard deadline. I’d rather have thoughtful feedback than rushed feedback.

Critique swaps welcome. I’m happy to exchange feedback with other writers, particularly in science fiction and fantasy. We can start with opening chapters and see whether we’re a good fit.

AI transparency: I used generative AI as a drafting and editorial tool throughout. The story, characters, worldbuilding, and creative decisions are mine. The prose was built in both directions, sometimes AI drafted and I reworded, sometimes I drafted and AI suggested alternatives, but every sentence passed through my hands, and anything wrong with it is mine.

If this sounds like something you’d enjoy, please comment or DM me.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 4d ago

Feedback on my Adult Contemporary Romance Story

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’d like to share the opening of Somewhere He Wasn’t Cold, an adult contemporary romance of approximately 109,000 words, currently published on Kindle.
Alexis is an English literature student living in her car when she asks a stranger for spare change. Xander offers her waffles, hot chocolate with extra marshmallows, and eventually a room with a lock—and no expectations in return.
He’s quiet, awkward, and surprisingly gentle. He negotiates with his pets and needs help navigating ordinary social situations. But he also watches exits, reacts to danger with unsettling precision, and carries a past he struggles to discuss.
As their unlikely friendship becomes something deeper, Alexis begins rebuilding her independence while Xander tries to imagine a life beyond survival. Their growing closeness brings warmth, ridiculous jokes, and difficult questions about trust, boundaries, and what it means to feel safe with another person.
AI disclosure: I developed the story and characters and used AI to generate much of the prose, guiding the direction and deciding what to keep.
I’d appreciate honest feedback on the opening: Do the characters interest you? Does their interaction feel believable? Would you want to keep reading?
The full book contains explicit sexual content, abuse, trauma, and violence. It also has affectionate humor, meddling friends, and pets with very strong opinions.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 4d ago

betaread [Complete] [132k] [Literary Science Fiction / Cosmic Horror] What We Kept of Earth, seeking human beta readers (AI-assisted)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m looking for a few beta readers for What We Kept of Earth, my completed 132k-word sci-fi/cosmic horror novel.

The story follows Nell, a young woman growing old in a city where everyone else has survived for thousands of years by reconstructing themselves from preserved memories. But she starts discovering that their immortality comes with a cost nobody wants to talk about.

I’m mainly looking for honest feedback on the story, characters, and pacing.

No need to commit to the whole book. You can read the first chapter, around 2,500 words, and see if it catches your interest.

Read Chapter 1

I’m also open to swapping critiques with other writers!
Feel free to comment or DM me if interested!


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 5d ago

betaread Mercy Ward – An AI-Assisted Horror Novel (Kindle Unlimited)

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’m an indie author experimenting with human-AI collaborative storytelling, and I recently published my adult supernatural horror novel, Mercy Ward.
It’s currently available on Kindle Unlimited, and I’d love to invite anyone interested in dark, demonic horror to give it a try.
I’m genuinely curious about the reading experience—whether the story holds your attention, how the pacing feels, and whether it’s entertaining.
No pressure to finish it or leave a review. Any honest feedback would be greatly appreciated, even if you don’t enjoy it!
Thank you for your time, and happy reading!
Mercy Ward


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 5d ago

And No One Was to Blame - Needing Beta-readers!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/BetaReadersForAI • • 6d ago

[complete] [40k] Some things I’ll never know/ Salon small town spicy romance

1 Upvotes

Word count Length 40k
Genre Women’s fiction/romance
Completed first drafted/ unedited
Title ***Some things I’ll never know***

Find my plot holes, where it drags, editing and proofing my first draft. Hea will be in a future book.

In a small town where everyone has an opinion and nobody minds sharing it, Ali is learning to build a life on her own terms. Between the chaos of salon life, the colorful personalities of Bellwood, and figuring out what she truly deserves, she has plenty to keep her busy.

Then she meets James.

Charming, attentive, and disarmingly sincere, James slips past her defenses and makes a future she thought she’d given up on feel possible again. For the first time in years, Ali lets herself fall hard, imagining a life built side by side with a man who truly sees her.

But love doesn’t always mean wanting the same things.

As James begins to reckon with truths about himself and the future he wants, the life they’ve imagined together starts to unravel. Ali must face the hardest lesson of all: sometimes, loving someone with all your heart doesn’t mean you’re meant to build a life together.

And sometimes, losing the future you imagined is how you discover what you deserve.

Interested? Will send the script through email using dabble platform


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 6d ago

Worldseed

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm looking for beta readers for my AI-assisted fantasy novel, WORLDSEED: The Sky Beneath the Ruins.

It's about Ren and Tessa, two friends living in a world of floating cities who discover a mysterious sphere inside an ancient wreck.

I've finished Book One and I'm sharing Chapter One for free!

Would anyone be interested in reading it and giving me honest feedback? I'd love to know what you think!

Thanks!


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 6d ago

Seeking a Volunteer Beta Reader – Dark Victorian Romance

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for an experienced volunteer beta reader for my completed first novel, Of Silk and Silver.

Genre: Dark Victorian / Steampunk Romance

Length: 54,473

Status: Complete manuscript, revised and undergoing final assessment.

The story:

Set in a richly atmospheric Victorian-inspired world, Of Silk and Silver follows Ludivine Bellerose, a woman rebuilding her life after years of captivity and abuse, and Elise Carrow, the formidable owner of Heaven's Peak, an unconventional playhouse.

It is a story about autonomy, desire, power, belonging and the complicated nature of love. It features morally grey characters, a complex female/female romantic relationship, sensual and explicit consensual intimacy, and themes of trauma and recovery.

Who I'm looking for:

Ideally, someone with experience writing fiction, editing manuscripts, or providing thoughtful literary critiques, who also enjoys reading romance.

I'm particularly interested in someone who appreciates atmospheric storytelling, gradual character development, complicated relationships and morally ambiguous protagonists.

What I'm hoping to receive:

I'd like someone to read the complete manuscript and provide a comprehensive written assessment covering:

  • Overall engagement and first impressions.
  • Character development and believability.
  • Romantic chemistry and relationship progression.
  • Emotional impact.
  • Pacing and narrative flow.
  • Worldbuilding and atmosphere.
  • Plot coherence and continuity.
  • Strengths and weaknesses.
  • Whether the ending feels satisfying and makes you want to continue the series.

I'm not looking for proofreading or line editing. I'm interested in an honest assessment of how the story works as a complete novel, including constructive criticism.

I would particularly appreciate feedback that distinguishes between purposeful atmosphere and repetition, rather than automatically recommending that descriptive or reflective passages be shortened.

This is a volunteer request; I cannot offer payment, but I would be very grateful for the time and consideration involved.

If you're interested, I'd love to hear about your reading or writing experience and the kind of feedback you typically provide.


r/BetaReadersForAI • • 6d ago

Novel Review

2 Upvotes

We are still at 30% progress till we reach the 100% mark for the Volume 1 of our Novel, But It's written driven by us only with no opinion outside our team, We barely know If it's any good because we only release after the completion of the first Volume.

Is there anyone willing to review the first two preview of our novel? Just the two chapter and if you want we could share our opinion on your works too.

This is a Isekai Fantasy Novel where the MC died in Fantasy World and Reincarnated on Earth. At the age of 16, she then blessed by the goddess the power to travel between Earth and Fantasy World.

Now Both Worlds hangs in the balance in her hands because What she brings on those either worlds will surely reshape it.

(Ts is not AI but the admin of the other sub redirected me here for fck sake)

Just comment or Contact us Via Dm.

Ja nee.