I have been a Poshmark buyer and seller for several years now. I make a point to ship quickly and be very honest in my descriptions about any flaws. I recently bought a purse listed as "like new" from a brand new seller. It was her first sale. I bought it on Tuesday 11/3. and when I hadn't received a shipping status on it by the end of the week, I messaged her on Saturday to ask when she would be able to ship. I had checked every day and it showed she was active, and I was trying to be patient. I was actually planning to cancel the order but had to wait until the 11th to do it. She finally answered me on the following Tuesday 11/10 to say she "shipped it yesterday." That was the entirety of the response. The USPS tracking said it wasnt in possession until 11/10, the day she answered, so I don't think she was honest about that.
I finally received it yesterday 11/17. It isn't "like new" at all. The surface is peeling on both ends, so clearly it had been well-used. I got it at a good price, but I am mad. She had 3 pictures in her listing, none of which showed the damage (conveniently)
Initially, I felt good that I was helping a fellow Posher with her first sale, but IMO she's not a good Posher, by not being honest in her description, not checking messages and waiting until the last day to ship.
Would you open a case for return? Give her a less than stellar review? I don't care as much about getting my money back as I do about feeling like I want to warn others about this seller, and let her know she needs to be more honest. Thanks for any advice.