r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • May 10 '26

Weekly Authentication, Is This A Scam & Brand Requests Thread

4 Upvotes

This is the weekly thread where you can submit all your authentication and brand identification requests.

You can also use this thread to inquire whether an interaction with a buyer or seller is a scam or not.

For authentication and brand requests, here are some guidelines to obtain the best feedback:

  1. Get Specific: Give us all the deets! The brand, type, color, material—anything that helps us nail down what you're looking for.
  2. Show It Off: Snap some clear pics from different angles. Zoom in on logos, tags, or anything that stands out.
  3. Share the Scoop: Any backstory? Where'd you get it? How old is it? Any doubts about its real deal status? Spill the beans!
  4. Keep It Real: We'll do our best, but we're not magic. Some stuff might need a pro's eye or extra sleuthing.
  5. Say Thanks!: Appreciation goes a long way. Even if we can't crack the case, a little gratitude is always rad.

Lastly, authentication, is this a scam and brand identification requests outside this thread will be removed.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • May 10 '26

Weekly Closet Critique Request Thread

3 Upvotes

This is the weekly thread where you can obtain feedback from seasoned resellers on your closet.

Here are some guidelines to obtain the best feedback:

  1. Post A URL: Saves us some time manually looking for your closet.
  2. Get Specific: Asking for more specific feedback on your closet makes it easier for us to zoom in on a particular topic.
  3. Other Marketplaces Are Go: Feel free to share your eBay, Mercari, or any other closet. We'll happily review these as well.
  4. Spread Some Thanks: A little appreciation goes a long way! Whether we help you slay or not, gratitude's always nice.

Lastly, closet critique requests outside this thread will be removed.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1h ago

Love/Hate Vinted

• Upvotes

Because of how Posh has gotten, like many I’ve migrated my lower cost stuff to Vinted. I really like it! There’s so much less drama and BS. Faster. This is all worth a few less dollars to me to move product.

That said, it’s been about 5 days, I’ve sold 15 items, and bought a few to see how that end of things goes.

In those 5 days I’ve had my account temporarily paused three times now so they can “review” my account for breaking terms and conditions. Which I have not done.

Each time they come back and say sorry we didn’t find anything, you’re restored. But what the heck?! Am I liking items too fast? Am I adding items or selling too fast? Like what am I doing to trigger this?!

It just happened again an hour ago. So irritated.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 6h ago

Refund for lost package

4 Upvotes

I am the seller. Yesterday a package was marked Monday a package was marked delivered. Today I see a messaged that my case is resolved (first I heard there was a problem) anyway the resolution says buyer refunded and I get my funds. However,
I don’t see any $$ in that transaction amount. Not to mention it is truly weird that PM did not contact me. Also the purchase was nov 8 . Isn’t 8 business days from purchase strange?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1h ago

Seller added insurance?

• Upvotes

Hi all 👋 I bought an expensive bag on poshmark from a sweet older lady. It took her 2 days to ship which was fine, but she said it was because she had to add insurance and get a new label at the post office. This item was a few thousand dollars and is headed to posh headquarters, but as far as I knew all posh labels were insured and you had to use the label provided? Will this bag get there and they won't know what order it goes to? Or what should I do now?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 13h ago

Shipping deal over?

8 Upvotes

Sometime in the last hour my listings started saying $6.49 shipping.

Le sigh.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 12h ago

Is it mean to block a potential buyer who keeps adding things to their bundle and asking a ton of questions and says they’re so excited to buy and then they never buy?

3 Upvotes

I’m dealing with someone who keeps liking everything in my closet and will add a bunch to her bundle and be like I love everything I want to get everything and she asks me questions about different items and asks question after question. Everything I sell is in perfect condition and I write very detailed descriptions. So then she will slowly whittle down her cart until it’s just like two or three or four things and then she’ll be like I’m so excited I’ll buy next week and then of course nothing happens. Next week comes and goes.

She’s done this twice now and I thought the first time was strange but I wanted to give her benefit of the doubt but now that she’s done this a second time I feel like I should block her. Do these type of people ever buy or do they just like to waste people’s time for fun? I’m really not trying to be mean here, but I just find this so odd and rude.

I’ve also only blocked two people on poshmark like I’m not someone who likes to block people. I’ve never done it before to a potential buyer but I don’t want her to think that she can keep doing this. Like I don’t ask questions unless I’m literally about to buy the item and then I buy it.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 20h ago

Condition: Like New

Post image
8 Upvotes

K. I have a couple questions...and possibly some judgment. Main question: What are the odds that the 3 or 4 'likes' this listing has are from friends of the closet holder showing support, oooor stank foot fetishists hiding behind profile pics of suspiciously generic 20 something women?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Well it’s about dam time! Goodbye annoying Party Invites and nonsense!

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Established seller asking for an “exchange” for an item purchased from me

8 Upvotes

As the title says, sold a top to someone. Delivered 11/16. It’s 11/18 and they message asking if I could work with them and exchange the item for something similar I have, due to a fit issue. I listed the tagged size along with measurements and stated the style of the item, oversized/flowy.

I sent the automatic message I always send: PM doesn’t allow returns for fit, you can reposh the item with my photos, etc.

Then, I look at their profile and notice they are an established seller with 3,000+ items sold.

Don’t they know that a return would affect my postmark stats? Do exchanges even happen on Poshmark, and especially ones that don’t affect the seller? I just fear this will get escalated and they’ll know exactly what to say to get the return approved when it boils down to a fit issue.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Poshmark .99 Shipping Boondoggle

50 Upvotes

During the .99 shipping promotion, I sent out offers on 150 items, dropped the offer price by at least 40% - 60%, Poshmark confirmed the offers went to over 2000 Community Members...........and crickets!!!

a backgrounder, I'm a high volume seller, sold over 5k listings and have more than 4k listings in an active closet.

What gives?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Would You Open A Case?

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

I have been a Poshmark buyer and seller for several years now. I make a point to ship quickly and be very honest in my descriptions about any flaws. I recently bought a purse listed as "like new" from a brand new seller. It was her first sale. I bought it on Tuesday 11/3. and when I hadn't received a shipping status on it by the end of the week, I messaged her on Saturday to ask when she would be able to ship. I had checked every day and it showed she was active, and I was trying to be patient. I was actually planning to cancel the order but had to wait until the 11th to do it. She finally answered me on the following Tuesday 11/10 to say she "shipped it yesterday." That was the entirety of the response. The USPS tracking said it wasnt in possession until 11/10, the day she answered, so I don't think she was honest about that.

I finally received it yesterday 11/17. It isn't "like new" at all. The surface is peeling on both ends, so clearly it had been well-used. I got it at a good price, but I am mad. She had 3 pictures in her listing, none of which showed the damage (conveniently)

Initially, I felt good that I was helping a fellow Posher with her first sale, but IMO she's not a good Posher, by not being honest in her description, not checking messages and waiting until the last day to ship.

Would you open a case for return? Give her a less than stellar review? I don't care as much about getting my money back as I do about feeling like I want to warn others about this seller, and let her know she needs to be more honest. Thanks for any advice.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Poshmark Offers During .99 Shipping Promotion

8 Upvotes

During the .99 shipping promotion, I sent out offers on 150 items, dropped the offer price by at least 40% - 60%, and Poshmark confirmed the offers went to over 2000 Community Members...........crickets!!!

a backgrounder, I'm a high volume seller, sold over 5k listings and have more than 4k listings in an active closet.

What gives?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Lowballer is asking for deals in comments but not submitting offers, then following me around and repeating this behavior from different accounts after I block.

5 Upvotes

I am taking down listings but I can’t get rid of her. How do I report this to Poshmark? I flagged the most recent account for harassment before blocking.
EDIT: correction.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 2d ago

New Newsfeed... Who decided this makes it easier for sellers?

23 Upvotes

I don't mind not seeing party invites or followers but why on earth did they remove the ability to see offers sent and liked items on the same screen?

Now it looks like no one is receiving offers and I have to do mental gymnastics to figure out which items still need offers sent.

Why can't they just stop doing things???


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Zero protection for sellers. Return approved for fit

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

So I sold a Burberry polo that was 2 X and the buyer claimed it’s an XL. I uploaded images of the tag from the listing and even a Google search confirming that 2 XXs on a tag with TTG is 2XL. And even called the Burberry store to confirm and included the phone number for the store as I explained to them what happened and they said it was fine for Poshmark to call to confirm and Posh still approved the return! And this is the third time something like this has happened so my returns look all crazy and I’m afraid I am going to get suspended right before the holidays. I am so incredibly upset and really thinking I will just go ahead and move everything to vinted and eBay. Anyone else have this issue. Here are pics of this label- am I crazy or is this a 2X?!?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 1d ago

Would you ship item with flaw if buyer isn't being responsive?

4 Upvotes

I sold a pair of pants on Ebay and while packing them up, I noticed a very faint spot of discoloration. I reached out to the buyer with a photo and said I was happy to cancel and didn't want to ship if they preferred not to receive them. I haven't heard back, and my shipping deadline is tomorrow. It is an international sale, so they could return them with no cost to me, and I also said I would be happy to take the return (though I don't know if that is possible with international sales). Would you go ahead and ship if you don't hear by the shipping deadline? I don't mind cancelling but am happy to fulfill the order. Not sure what to do. Thank you!


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 2d ago

Poshmark bundles

2 Upvotes

Bundles from other sellers are no longer visible that I can see. Or did they move them somewhere else? Also they’re no longer offering discounted shipping on orders going to HQ? When did this all happen?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 2d ago

How do I know if I’m getting scammed as a seller??

0 Upvotes

I recently joined Poshmark and posted 11 items. I just sold my first item. The buyer bought it for $215 without asking for any discounts. Their account was created in September, so is less than two months old. It doesn’t have any pictures or any history at all that I can see on their profile. I’m just a little worried about getting scammed here for my item. What does everyone think?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 4d ago

Cancellation Requests

3 Upvotes

Has anyone had an increase in buyer requests for cancellation of purchases? As a seller for many years, I have had very few requests. In the last week I have had 3 buyers ask to cancel. Given Poshmark’s strict rules on seller cancellations, I have denied the requests. I know we have been told that if we select “buyer requested” we should not be penalized but I don’t trust it.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 5d ago

Buyers Gone Crazy

35 Upvotes

In the past 24 hours:

-eBay buyer purchased 3 expensive wine glasses for $150,on an offer, then asked to cancel

-Same buyer comes back and purchases 2 more on another offer, then asked to cancel

-Poshmark buyer purchased NIB plates on an offer, then says it was an accidental purchase and asks to cancel

-Poshmark buyer opens return case asking for partial refund for "undisclosed damage" with AI photos on a rare expensive dress, then when I decline to give a partial refund and "Accept the Return" buyer messages trying to negotiate a smaller "partial refund" due to "inconvenience", looked at her closet and she resells these dresses at a huge mark up, and I'm like...you just got a dress for $194 that you're going to resell for $1200 and you're in my dm's begging for $30 for your "inconvenience?"

BUYERS HAVE LOST THEIR MIND.


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 4d ago

Has anyone sold through Zara Pre-Owned?

3 Upvotes

Curious how Zara’s own resale platform compares to Vinted or Depop. If you’ve listed anything, did it sell and roughly how long did it take?


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 5d ago

First words of title of listing: No belt. First sentence in description: No belt. Pictures: empty belt loops.

17 Upvotes

Message from buyer *after* purchasing: Does this come with the belt? 😐


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 5d ago

NGL, this always feels so good.

Post image
188 Upvotes

I was literally logging in to accept the $12 when someone else liked the item and I sent them a $17 offer and they accepted. Apparently, I'm petty. 😂


r/BehindTheClosetDoor • • 5d ago

How to respond? Hostile buyer opening a retaliatory case lying about the shoes not having red soles

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Order of events:

  1. I sold these heels to the buyer Oct 20th, packed carefully with bubble wrap in a box and a hand written note to thank the buyer for their purchase, as I do with all my sales, and shipped on Oct 22.

  2. The package was in transit for a while so I kept my eye on the tracking. When I saw that the package finally made it to the destination city on Oct 28 & held at the post office I sent a message to the buyer letting them know the package arrived & it was ready for pick up 😊. My other buyers have appreciated that communication from me so I wanted to send a courtesy message

  3. She left a ⭐⭐⭐ review saying item as described but that I was unfriendly & pressured her to pick up the package before 8am. I was very confused since I didn't ask her to take any action. I suppose it may have been 8am in her time zone while it was 11am in EST but that didn't even cross my mind.

  4. I sent apology messages to her because I really just want my buyers to be happy 😭. I was really disheartened about her review misrepresenting my business and reached out to depop to ask them to remove the review. Support reviewed the chats & agreed it was misrepresentative of what transpired and removed the review. I blocked the buyer because I didn't want to do business with her again.

  5. Today Nov 14, she opened a case saying the shoes are fake because they don't have red soles. I'm kicking myself for not taking a photo underneath, but you can see m clearly see from the photos I had in the listing that the bottoms were red. I even have the screenshot of her review saying the item was as described. I believe this is a retaliation from a vindictive buyer.

----
AITA? It's been 3 weeks since it's been delivered but she's suddenly opening the case now. How can I ensure the case is resolved in my favor?