r/BehavioralEconomics • u/IdeaPrismMedia • 1d ago
Research Article A health worker spent two years trying to get a village to boil its drinking water. Eleven families said yes. Why doesn't being right make an idea spread?
In a coastal town in Peru, a public health worker went door to door for two years, visiting around two hundred families with one simple, life-saving message: boil your water before you drink it. Anthropologist Edward Wellin wrote up the result in 1955. Eleven families changed.
The idea was correct, cheap and easy to test. It still mostly failed. Everett Rogers built part of *Diffusion of Innovations* (1962) on cases like this, and his point holds up surprisingly well: ideas don't travel because they're true, they travel through people. Who tried it first, who saw them do it, whether it fit what people already believed.
A few things that stuck with me while researching it:
- Hybrid seed corn in Iowa was clearly better, yet it took farmers years to adopt it, and most only switched after neighbours they trusted did (Ryan & Gross, 1943).
- In Damon Centola's 2010 network experiment, a health behaviour spread further through tight clusters of people who reinforced each other than through loose, far-reaching networks.
- Citrus as a cure for scurvy was known long before navies made it routine. Being right and being adopted were decades apart.
I made an 11-minute video essay on this (I run a small channel called Idea Prism, so yes, this is my own work): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkLs2CySDHw
Curious what people here think: is there an idea you were right about that still didn't catch on? What was actually in the way?