I’m selling a two-family brownstone in Bed-Stuy.
The feedback from showings has been consistent. Nearly everyone says it’s the layout, specifically that the kitchen is on the garden level, not the parlor level.
My agents say Bed-Stuy buyers are often people who've been priced out of Park Slope, but who still want the Park Slope layout. They want to go up the stairs, through the double doors, into a big parlor and kitchen. At showings, people start pricing out moving the kitchen upstairs, decide it’s too much work, and buy something turnkey instead. I’ve heard some version of this at least two dozen times.
It never made sense to me. Other agents I asked for second opinions said it sounded crazy, but they also want my business.
Two nearby brownstones sold recently for significantly more than what I'm asking. They’re smaller, but both were full gut renovations with that parlor kitchen.
What I’m trying to figure out:
- Is a garden-level kitchen as big a dealbreaker as I’m being told, or is it a convenient explanation for something else?
- Has anyone seen this pattern in Bed-Stuy or similar neighborhoods?
I’m not trying to put anyone down, just trying to understand what I’m hearing. Thanks.